πŸ“š too-good-to-be-true Part 31 of 31
too-good-to-be-true-ch-31
EROTIC NOVELS

Too Good To Be True Ch 31

Too Good To Be True Ch 31

by naughtypaladin
19 min read
4.73 (8000 views)
adultfiction

Dear Readers,

Thank you for waiting, here is the next chapter! I hope I didn't keep you waiting too long. Big thanks go out to my new editor, Pandamonium, for helping me get this chapter ready! Without further ado, I hope you enjoy it!

~NaughtyPaladin

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Chapter 31

I had to admit, the members of my harem looked so... damn... good in their swimwear. Not all of them wore bikinis, but with the amount of time that Tina spent working with the girls, doing yoga, cycling, weights, and other exercises had worked them all into beach-worthy shape. Debbie had made the biggest changes, having lost over a hundred pounds since she started working with Tina.

I sat on the edge watching all the girls play, either sexy in the slight mystery of hiding under the water, making my mind flash back to all our erotic encounters, or jiggling and bouncing in all the best ways above the water.

The frosted glass of the ceiling over the pool, giving natural light to the swimming and playing beauties, while protecting us from potential peeping. I knew the girls were all nervous about the fact that a drone might try and slip in at any time. Parker and the security team had countermeasures, but it only took a second to ruin everything.

Courtney and Sarah emerged from the changing room. A second of seriousness in their expressions told me they had been talking about something more than what games they wanted to play, and I was sure if it was relevant, I'd be let in on it later.

Courtney went to one of the cabinets, pulled out a beach ball and blew it up before tossing it into the water to Tina.

"Keep it up!" Courtney called and jumped in. "Don't let it touch the water! If you do, we kick the last person who touched it, or the person who missed it! Whoever's fault it was!"

"What do you get for winning?" Cindy laughed.

"Ah... I'll figure out something when we get down to like... five people." Courtney mused. "But I'll make sure it's something you want!"

That got the girls excited. They were jumping, diving and pushing to really make sure that beach ball hit the water. I just sat back and smiled, damn, that was so hot to watch.

Suki, in her red bikini, was the first to get out, accidentally knocking the beach ball clear outside the pool and into the sitting area.

"Ah, man..." Cindy groaned.

While everyone else was mature enough to not say it, the agreement was on their faces. The worst part of swimming was getting in for the first time, and any time you had to get out of the water. The air in the pool area always felt cold and miserable, and while getting back in wasn't so bad, just staying in the water was preferable.

I went to stand up, but someone beat me to it.

"I GOT IT!" Mary called, and lifted herself out of the water. The eighteen-year-old was the youngest girl here, and the only one not wearing a bikini. That didn't mean the skin-tight one-piece didn't make her look great, her athletic legs leading up to a nice, tight, little butt. She wasn't incredibly busty, but the top clung to her enough that her breasts were complimented nicely as she ran over, grabbed the ball and ran back, tossing the ball to Sarah before jumping back in.

"It's getting to be kinda nice, having Mary around," Suki admitted. "Don't even have to ask if someone's willing to help anymore, she jumps up and does whatever it is... though, sometimes it feels a bit like we're taking advantage. Everyone knows she's on probation, and let's be honest, Ali enjoys having someone waiting on her hand and foot... which is funny, considering how much she complained about it with her family..."

I chuckled. It was true. Ali did complain about how overbearing her family had been, and how she'd been spoon-fed everything in life... But I think it was more the objection to her parents trying to mold her into what "they" wanted her to be, instead of letting her be herself.

Cindy was next to be eliminated, being just too slow to reach what everyone agreed was a reachable volley. She came over and joined me and Suki.

"Damn it, it had to be volleyball." She grumbled. "Why couldn't it be water soccer? I'm good at soccer."

"What would that be? Water polo?" Suki mused.

"I don't know..." Cindy grumbled. "I'm getting in the hot tub. The air is too cold in here."

"Fuck!" Abby groaned, as the beach ball went flying.

"I got it!" Mary volunteered again, and went running.

And so it went, one by one the girls got out, until it was Tina, Sarah, Khloe, Taylor and Mary. I could tell Tina was just being competitive at this point. Sarah had the benefit of being the tallest girl in the harem, and those long arms and legs were a real advantage here. Khloe seemed to be going purely on the drive to see what her reward would be, and Taylor seemed to have just been lucky.

"Do you think Mary noticed we're throwing for her?" Courtney whispered in my ear as she scooted closer to me, watching as Mary once more retrieved the beach ball and returned to the pool.

"You're what?" I whispered back.

"Oh, come on." She giggled back. "You know that the reward is gonna be something sexual. The girls and I can get whatever we want from you whenever we want. This gives Mary a way to get a little something."

"I thought she wasn't allowed full harem privileges until her probation was over?" I mused.

"Oh, absolutely. Your dick isn't going in her pussy until she's proved she isn't going to try and pull any of that nonsense again." Courtney assured me. "But... like, none of the girls had any issues with you eating her out on the plane, so... she can probably have a little something as a reward if she convinces the others to all throw for her."

I looked at her again, and watched more carefully. Mary was the youngest, the shortest, and frankly was already getting tired. She hadn't had the time to work with Tina to build up her physical fitness and endurance, so if the girls had wanted to, they probably could have put the ball exactly where she'd be too slow to reach it, but they weren't.

"How did everyone know it was going to be a sex thing?" I asked, and Courtney laughed and leaned her head on my shoulder, grabbing my arm.

"Oh, Tom... we're not a bunch of kids anymore. Adult rewards are money, food, or sex. I suppose it could be a money reward, but since everyone has free food and a place to live, both money and food are less appealing. So of course it was going to be a sex thing." Courtney chided.

I wasn't really sure what to make of that. I could think of a few other things that would be rewards, prizes like tools for hobbies, getaways or vacations, and the like, but since those were all basically just cash prizes where the cash was already spent for you.

"You think she'll get it?" I asked.

"I don't know." Courtney admitted. "Khloe was pretty mad about her trying to break up our family like she did, and Tina is just competitive. Sarah's probably gonna just let her win if it's between the two of them... Let's give them some encouragement."

Courtney let go of my arm and stood up.

"Hey, before you get going again... why don't we propose prizes for the winner?" Courtney suggested.

"Okay, sweet." The girls accepted.

Courtney put a finger on her chin. "Let's see... I don't see all of you wanting one single thing... so a unique reward for whoever wins?"

The girls all, still in the running or otherwise, cheered for that.

"So let's see... Taylor... I guess you get to run a photoshoot with anyone you want from the harem, and Tom, of course. Your script. No wimping out." Courtney gave a look around. "Agreed?"

Abby was the last to agree, and she squirmed a bit, but eventually she conceded.

"Alright, Taylor gets a no holes barred photoshoot-" Courtney noted.

πŸ“– Related Erotic Novels Magazines

Explore premium magazines in this category

View All β†’

"Can I do video too?" Taylor piped in excitedly.

"Sure!" Courtney laughed.

Abby grumbled something and it took a moment for me to realize she said, "There goes my asshole." Sounds like I knew what was happening if Taylor won. Abby had been resisting anal for... well, forever.

"Khloe... what do you want? No... I know what you want, but we're not doing that yet." Courtney chided.

"Yeah, I guessed as much..." Khloe grumbled. "Eventually..."

"So what ELSE would you like?" Courtney laughed.

"Um... maybe..." She swam over and whispered in Courtney's ear, making Courtney laugh before turning to me.

"She wants to help you break in a few of the staff members? You willing?" Courtney giggled.

"I mean, if they're willing, why not?" I chuckled. For having started off such a religious prude, Khloe had gotten kinky.

"Sarah?" Courtney turned.

"I'd take an entire day, just me and Tom, no interruptions..." Sarah smirked, giving me a look that told me the reward would be as much a reward for me as it was for her.

"Okay. That's reasonable. Tina?" Courtney turned to the last full harem member.

"I mean... winning is the reward for me... but if I've gotta pick something... I have a new position I'd like to try out with Tom. That work?" Tina shrugged.

Mary was looking thoroughly depressed at this point.

"Sounds good. So, Mary? What do you want?" Courtney asked.

"Nothing I can have..." She grumbled.

"How about this, we'll loosen- LOOSEN- your restrictions for one thing..." Courtney suggested. "Anyone object to that?"

No one voiced any opposition, and Mary seemed to take heart.

"So we could finally...?" She began.

"Not full sex, that would be removing the restrictions entirely... maybe oral? He could give you oral?" Courtney suggested.

"But you already let him do that on the plane on the way here." Mary noted. "But I haven't been allowed to touch him... so maybe... I could give him oral too? It isn't sex, because he isn't going in my pussy...?"

"Sixty-nine it is." Courtney accepted, and Mary started bouncing happily in the water, renewed determination in her eyes.

You could tell who was actually motivated by their reward and who wasn't. Tina seemed to actually lose motivation, I'd guess because she knew others wanted their rewards far more than she did. I mean, winning would be nice, I'm sure... but now I was curious about this new position and honestly it was probably happening either way. That Sarah wanted a full day of just the two of us was only surprising in that she hadn't mentioned it before. I'd happily spend a day with her, and the others would probably happily give it to her. Taylor, apparently, was highly motivated by her "no holes barred" photo/video shoot with her choice of cast. Khloe seemed to like the idea of her reward, but she "accidently" got out next, but... it almost looked like she realized she was messing up, but couldn't recover it, sending the ball flying far enough Mary had to scamper after it.

Mary was fired up. Her lagging steps and slow exits and re-entrance to the pool were gone and she was ready to go almost instantly. I wasn't sure she was actually excited to suck my cock, but just doing anything was progress and I could tell she already felt behind compared to the other girls.

"Any of the girls in particular you were hoping to help with?" I asked her quietly.

"It might sound weird... but I kinda want to be there when you take the driver... What's her name? Elaina? I want to make sure she actually submits to you properly. That's probably dumb..." Khloe admitted.

"Maybe, but I'll see if she's willing. If not, I'll be sure to let you know. How does that sound?" I laughed.

"I'll take it." Khloe smirked. "As much as I want to make sure she is a proper member of the harem... if she doesn't want me watching... and helping... then... fair, I guess."

Sarah "slipped" and missed the ball next.

"You wanna pick a day, and we'll schedule it?" I suggested to her, quietly.

"Sure, but I want to wait until we're home." she told me, "A vacation to recover from our vacation, so to speak."

"I like it." I chuckled.

Tina was the next. She accidentally put a touch too much power, or perhaps got her angle just wrong, but there was no way either Taylor or Mary was getting that. A quick vote showed everyone agreed and she was disqualified.

She sheepishly retreated leaving the final two to duke it out.

"A new position?" I asked curiously.

"Yeah, it's called the Amazon. I stand over you, roll you on your back, and fish that fun-stick out and ride you." She smirked. "Like I'm trying to pin your ankles behind your ears for a change... though all the pictures I found didn't have your legs nearly that far back."

"Is that why you've been working with me on hip flexibility?" I asked suspiciously.

"...maybe. I can neither confirm, nor deny any such allegations." Tina muttered, looking in great interest at the textured glass of the sunroof.

"Well, now you've got me curious. We'll have to find a time and see how it goes." I chuckled.

"HA! Even when I lose, I'm winning!" She celebrated.

We turned to watch the two girls dueling it out in the water. Taylor was taller, with longer arms and legs, and she hadn't been chasing the ball out of the water for the past hour or so. Mary was breathing hard, but she was giving it all she was worth. She dove and knocked the ball back towards Taylor in a slow high arch.

"Ha! Might as well have set me up for a spike!" Taylor laughed.

"No!" Mary gasped struggling to recover as the ball descended.

"Abby, better get the lube read-AH!" Taylor gasped. Her foot slipped on the strips of smooth tile along the otherwise textured floor. She tried to recover but her hand swung too late and instead of spiking the ball toward Mary, it plunked into the water just two feet away from her.

"My ass is saved!" Abby celebrated.

"Damn it." Taylor sighed.

"I won!" Mary celebrated.

πŸ›οΈ Featured Products

Premium apparel and accessories

Shop All β†’

"Congratulations!" Cindy laughed.

"You certainly worked hard enough for it." Courtney chuckled.

I grinned. With the effort I'd seen her putting in to try and fit in better with the rest of the girls, I was kinda glad she was getting a bit of a treat, even if I had a hard time seeing the privilege of sucking my dick as a treat. Mary clearly thought it was, and she was the one who mattered here.

"Can I... get my reward now?" She asked, suddenly bashful.

"Sure, you thinking the chairs over there?" I laughed, pointing to some pool chairs that would be comfortable enough.

"I was hoping for a bit more... privacy." Mary admitted.

"Take her to your room," Courtney urged. "Just remember, oral only."

I smirked. The number of women that would be outraged at the very thought, and somehow I had landed a girlfriend who was openly encouraging this. Lucky me.

"Come on." I laughed, taking her hand.

Mary was nearly vibrating with excitement as we walked from the pool.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"You trust her alone in a room with him? When they're both gonna be naked?" Tina prodded.

"No, I trust him alone in a room with her." Courtney countered. "He's bigger, stronger, and I trust him not to do anything with her he shouldn't. If she tries anything, there's no way she's gonna be forcing him."

"I guess that's fair." Tina relented. "He can bench three times what she probably weighs. And I've barely started working with her, so... I suppose that's fair."

"I don't like questioning you, but why'd you cut her so much slack like that?" Khloe asked. "Isn't the point of her probation that she's paying for her sins of trying to turn us against each other?"

"No," Sarah jumped in. "It's making sure she won't try it again. Let's be honest, she never really stood a chance, not with how close we all are, so her efforts were wasted to begin with. Her penance, if you want to call it that, is becoming friends with all of us, so she never wants to break us up again. The probation is a chance for us all to watch her and make sure she is, in fact, a good fit."

"Interesting way of looking at it." Taylor noted. "But I still don't see why we're being so nice to her. She was a bit of a bitch, so why are we giving her anything?"

"Because she knows enough she could be a problem." Sarah admitted. "By giving her small concessions, we can win her over, and make her glad to be a member of our harem. Where if we just abuse her for an entire month, she's just as likely to run to the media and blow the whistle on our little arrangement, as she is to stick around hoping for a measure of happiness she has been actively denied."

"I don't like that." Ruth admitted. "I could try and-"

"No, Ruth." Courtney stepped in. "Bossing her around and showing her who's boss is not going to help. She's here for Tom, and he's going to be the reason she stays and cooperates."

"Just got to rank up their relationship enough before the time limit, or we lose a party member." Laura nodded. "And you have to go slow or her panic meter will fill faster than her arousal meter."

"What kind of games do you play?" Cindy asked in a mixture of horror and curiosity.

"Eh, most flash porn games are too formulaic and dumb." Laura sighed. "Might as well just watch porn for most of them. Seriously, where are the game designers with actual STORY."

"Probably trying to work around the media they can get access to for cheap or free." Taylor noted.

"That explains why most of the games use the same clips." Laura noted. "Sucks for immersion."

"Wait... you aren't gonna make a porn game with the pictures and videos you take of everyone... are you?" Cindy asked, a little pale.

"What? No. And those aren't for sale either." Taylor declared.

"I am curious... how much do you think you could get for some spicy pictures?" Debbie grinned.

"Sadly, not as much as you'd think. Too many girls in their teens, and early twenties, eager for a touch of attention, posting nudes like they'll never regret it." Taylor sighed. "I could do boudoir shoots, and maybe get some artistic shots... but unless we went hardcore into OnlyFans, online chat rooms, or the like, we wouldn't make a decent amount. Even then, the top performers make a pretty penny, but your average content producer makes maybe a few hundred dollars a month, and that's posting nearly daily."

"Lame." Debbie sighed.

"Do you need money for something?" Courtney asked in concern.

"No... I guess just my illusion of being able to support myself doing what I love is getting another crack." Debbie sighed.

"You'd be a porn model?" Cindy piped up.

"I mean, probably not. Not for that kind of pay." Debbie sighed. "And I suppose my college education would be totally wasted."

The girls chuckled.

They looked back at the pool, but seemed to decide against getting back in. They'd been out long enough now that it would be just like getting in for the first time again, and the girls decided to call it.

"Miss Carmichael." Parker, head of security, poked her head in. "I have a briefing for you from Mr. Hughes."

A briefing from Clarence? That couldn't be good.

"I'll be right there." She assured her. "Just let me get dressed."

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

"Be gentle with me," Mary asked demurely. "It's my first time."

"We aren't having sex." I assured her, before I slipped out of my trunks. "Just oral."

"I know." She pouted. "But... I saw how you pushed that beautiful thing down their throats on the plane. I'd puke."

I laughed, reassured she wasn't going to try for more than had been agreed on. "I generally don't shove it down your throat, unless you ask for it," and I let my trunks drop.

Her eyes were locked to my swinging cock.

"Look as good here as it did on the plane?" I asked.

"I didn't really get to just... can I touch it?" She asked quietly.

Enjoyed this story?

Rate it and discover more like it

You Might Also Like