Synopsis: Marge and Peter Baylis, and their attractive guests, Ann and Gordon, rescue a young waterskier while cruising in their sailboat, "Love Boat." The young man has just told Peter the boat he and his were using wasn't theirs.
* * * * *
Peter looked more closely at the young man. "What do you mean, the boat wasn't yours?"
The boy stared back. He seemed defiant, but Peter thought he was really frightened. Then the young man looked away. "I don't know their names," he said. "Those guys picked me up in Bremerton; I got an aunt I never seen in Port Angles, and I was hitching up there, but they wanted to stop here on the way; one of them knows a girl here, or something.
"Anyhow, we seen the boat. Nobody was around, so what the hell? The skis was just laying there. Neither of the other guys knew how to ski, so I said I'd show them. Then they come too close to you guys, and with my luck, I had to let go just in time to hit that damned log."
The others were quiet as Peter weighed the boy's statement. "For some reason, I believe you," he said. "I hate to do this," he added, "but I've no choice. I have to turn you over to the authorities. Grand larceny, even for a joy ride, is a serious crime."
Marge's face was strained as she stared into her husband's eyes. "Do we really have to turn him in? Couldn't we just pretend we found him in the water? I don't think he's a criminal. I think he's just a little boy who's lost his way."
Gordon and Anne had a private conversation. Then Gordon turned to Peter. "I don't mean to butt in," he said, "but we sort of agree with Marge. You're a lawyer. Isn't there some way we can avoid making a federal case out of this?"
"It's not that simple," Peter said. "I'm surprised the Coast Guard isn't already out here looking for him. Someone may have seen us pick him up, but whether they did or not, I don't intend to jeopardize my license by aiding an escaping criminal."
Seeing the downcast expressions surrounding him, and hearing the self-righteous tone of his own voice, Peter added, "Look, there's no sense going on about this. We'll go to the town dock. Then I'll go see the sheriff or town marshal or whoever is in charge of law enforcement, and find out if they're looking for Kenny. If they are, we'll have to hand him over. If not, well, that's a different story. Is that fair?"
The gloomy expressions lightened considerably. Only Kenny seemed doubtful. "But I didn't do anything except take a ride with those guys," he said sadly.
Peter said, "I believe you. Maybe they will, too."
Peter looked around. Love Boat had drifted a few hundred yards downwind since recovering Marge and the boy, but they were still clear of other traffic. Peter ducked down the companionway and started the engine.
Within minutes, they were tying the boat up to the town dock. "You folks wait here," Peter said, slipping on his shoes. "I'll find out whether our young friend, here, is a wanted man."
He climbed the ladder to the dock and walked across the rough plank dock until he reached the street. Virtually no one was on the street. Peter paused at a corner drug store and asked for directions to the police station.
The clerk sent him two streets over to a crumbling old brick building. He opened the door, and walked to the desk where the duty officer sat.
"I understand there was a joy riding incident today out in the bay," Peter said.
"I ain't so sure it was joy riding, but we got them young fellas back there." The officer motioned behind him with his thumb.
Peter opened his wallet and showed the officer his Bar Association credentials. "I wonder if I could interview them?"
The policeman grinned knowingly. "I don't think they got much money, but I don't see why not. Do you mind if I pat you down? Our metal detector's been on the fritz since last Tuesday."
Peter ignored the implication that he was soliciting business, and nodded. After a perfunctory search, the officer led him back through a barred door to the three cells that constituted the Kingston lockup. "You can sit here and talk to them through the bars," he said. "When you're finished, just sing out, and I'll let you out."
Peter nodded, and while the officer noisily let himself back into the front office, he introduced himself to two surly young men.
"Who sent for you?" the older of the two demanded.
Peter shook his head. "That's not important," he said. "I'm interested only in the third man who was with you."
The two men hesitated and looked at each other. The older one shook his head, and said firmly, "You're wrong about that. Wasn't nobody there except us."
Peter looked skeptical and said, "Are you certain?"
The older man glared at him. "I just tole you! There wasn't nobody except shit-for-brains here, and me!"
Peter said, "Well, tell me this; How'd they catch you?"
This time there was no hesitation. The older man looked scornfully at the younger one. "If dumbo here had checked the gas like I tole him, we might be in Seattle by now."
"You're really sure there wasn't a third man?"
The two men exchanged glances again and nodded.
"OK," Peter said. "Now let me give you a little free legal advice. If I were you, when you talk to the prosecutor tomorrow, I would go easy on talking about trips to Seattle. It might make a hell of a difference in the way they look at your case. I don't practice criminal law, but if you want to get in touch with me, here's my card." He handed each of them a business card.
Peter smiled inwardly as he walked back to the boat. It was obvious why they were lying. They thought they had killed Kenny. But whatever their reason, Kenny was in the clear. The officials didn't even know he existed.
"What's the verdict?" Marge asked as he stepped into the cockpit.