The Girl Is Trouble

We had been going strong since my unusual proposal. It had been several weeks since then and it felt like we were finally really in sync with each other. Of course, that time included frequent coupling between Mark and Jess.

Mark got into his role as a performer. He picked up on the prompting from Jess and started improvising on his own. Lots of calling me "Cuck", making me get my face in close up, encouraging me to clean her up, those kinds of things.

We had found a pretty good match for us. And apparently, it worked well for him. He didn't mind passing on other girls for a bit. Jess was hotter and nastier than most he'd been with and I think he was enjoying the bull role a lot.

The school semester was progressing and we'd told our families about our engagement. We made plans to meet each other's parents. It wasn't so crazy we hadn't met them yet as we both went to school out of state from where we grew up and it was the Spring semester.

All was good.

Until it suddenly wasn't.

I was serving as a teaching assistant for an Intro Computer Science course as an early Graduate studies credit. The professor I was working for was nearing retirement and believed me to be one of his brightest students, so he was very happy to let me teach most days.

It was a Wednesday afternoon and I was in the middle of giving a lecture about operators when my phone rang. I hit ignore and apologized to the class, proceeding to continue.

The phone instantly rang back and I saw it was Jim. This seemed unusual. I apologized to the class and stepped into the hall to take the call.

"Darren! You need to come quick! Sarah says there's some sort of scene by the Education building between Jess and Jacen Summers! She says it's intense and she's really worried about Jess!"

I didn't know Jim or Sarah to be prone to hyperbole, so I apologized again to the class and told them class was over. I took off running to the Education building.

I ran fast, realizing that I'd left my bag in the classroom but not caring at the moment. I nearly knocked over several folks, telling them I was sorry as I flew by. What the fuck was Jacen thinking?

By the time I got there, they were gone but Sarah saw me and came straight over to me.

"I'm so sorry. You just missed them."

"What do you mean? Where'd they go? What happened?"

We both caught our breaths, me from running and her from apparently the sheer adrenaline.

"They went towards central campus. Jacen grabbed her as we were coming out of a class. He either knew her schedule or took a gamble he'd find her here and was waiting. He instantly began yelling at her that she was his and no 'limp dick white boy cuck' was going to take her from him. Sorry, his words, not mine," she explained, blushing at having to repeat those words spoken about me.

I nodded, blushing but also, embarrassingly, aroused.

"Jim said you were concerned about her? Did he hit her?" I asked.

"No, but he did raise his hand like he was going to and then wrapped a hand around her neck as if he was going to choke her. That's when I called Jim to call you."

"Fuck!"

"Yeah, but she just screamed back at him. She told him he was a great fuck but she loved you. She told him they'd only ever be good together in bed and that wasn't enough. Then she..."

"What?"

"She grabbed his... crotch... in front of everyone. She told him if he'd just chill the fuck out she'd give him one more final fuck. You have to understand, there were like 50 people around when she did this."

"Oh shit," I groaned.

"He kissed her hard and they were full-on making out in front of everyone. He had her up off the ground with his hands on her ass at this point. I mean, Jesus Darren. I told Jim to warn you about her."

"He did," I replied. "Then what?"

"She stopped him and told her they needed to get someplace private fast."

I started running through where they'd be going. If they went towards the center of campus, it was more likely they were headed to his place. It sounded like she was confident she had him under control, but I wasn't sure he was going to be that easy.

"Thanks, Sarah! I got this," I said as I raced off to my car.

------------

I got to his place fast. Bolting up to his floor I was surprised to see his door hadn't fully closed because her shirt was on the ground stopping it from shutting.

I pushed the door in and instantly heard them from the direction of his bedroom. A trail of their clothes littered the path. The door was wide open and I saw his bare muscular ass with her hands on each cheek. Her legs were almost completely up to her head and he was pounding away at her stretched pussy.

"Did you forget who's pussy this is, slut?!?" he yelled at her.

"Fuuuucckk, Jacen. Give it to me!" she replied without giving him what he wanted.

"No, you don't get to call me Jacen anymore. Call me Daddy. Tell Daddy who's pussy this is, slut."

I could see Jess's face now and, as she saw me too, she rolled her eyes at him.

"Hey, Jacen, what the fuck?" I yelled.

His head whipped around, but he didn't even bother to remove his cock from Jess.

"You motherfucker! You're taking her from me!" he bellowed.

"No, he's not, Jacen. Ooooh, god... I'm taking myself from you," Jess interjected as he continued pounding away at her. His head whipped back around to face her.

"The sex is hot as hell, but you've gone crazy. We were never supposed to be anything more than a recurring hookup," she continued. "YOU are the one freaked out about some gold digger getting their claws in you. Remember- I was the safe fuck. When did that change?"

It was a mental scene. The pair of them continued to fuck while they were arguing.

"Goddammit, Jess! I fucking love you, ok?" he shouted and his voice cracked.

"No you don't, you damn big cocked jock. You don't 'fucking love' me, you just 'love fucking me'. Uhhhh...You just can't stand that you can't have me so you think it's love. Do you know my fucking birthday? Fuck... do you even know my last name?" Jess laid into him.

This actually stopped him in his tracks. She got him there, apparently.

She smacked both of his ass cheeks hard and dug her nails into his flesh.

"Oh no, you don't. You wanted to fuck me, so fucking give it to me, 'Daddy'!" she yelled, saying the name he insisted she called him dripping with sarcasm.

This pissed him off and he reared his hand back to slap her. I grabbed his arm mid-swing but thankfully Jess's next words stopped him flat.

"Don't you fucking dare. You are not your goddamn father. You do not hit women," she screamed in a commanding voice that I had never heard her use before. Apparently, at some point, they'd had some discussions about his family life for Jess to have made that comment.

His arm relaxed and, looking incredibly defeated for such a powerful man, just gave into fucking her. I couldn't believe how she completely controlled him. And just like that, a switch had been thrown.

"That's it, you bastard. Fuck my slutty pussy," Jess told him, exerting dominance. It was such a hot thing to see.

I mean, it's still my girl fucking another man in front of me, something others would question my manhood or sexual orientation for allowing her to do. But they couldn't see what I was seeing. They couldn't comprehend the beauty, passion, sexuality, and control exhibited by this amazing specimen of a woman who somehow deemed me worthy of her love. In the end, it didn't matter what she took from the other men she was fucking or the games we would play to get off on our mutual kinks. She went home with me. Every night. We might tease about denial or whatever, but if I told her I wanted to have sex with her and I meant it, I had zero doubt that she would do exactly that.

I liked that she was free to fuck other men. I get off on it. Because in many ways, it gave me power over them. At any point, if I asked, Jess would stop having sex with them. Hell, I didn't even HAVE to ask her to stop seeing Jacen. She was the one who had already determined that he was more trouble than he was worth.

All that said, it still was hot as fuck seeing his enormous black cock pounding away at my fiancée's pussy. Despite the fucked up situation, we all silently agreed to just enjoy this one last screw.

They both held off from cumming for a long period. I swear it was like they were in some sort of competition not to be the one who came first while edging the other. She finally flipped him over and began riding him hard.

"Come on, Jacen. Don't you want to fill up my white pussy with your superior black seed anymore? Don't you want to show my cuckold boyfriend who the real man is and claim my pussy? Uhhhh, yes. Your cock is so big. No one fucks me like you do. I don't want to give this dick up, but... oooooo... You've made it too hard to have this work. Why can't you be ok just taking my pussy from time to time?"

"Uuuuugh," Jacen growled, trying hard to not cum. "You'd like that, wouldn't you, slut. Just getting a little black cock on the side. Are you going to smuggle me into your honeymoon suite the night of your wedding, Jess?"

"Oh, fuck. Christ, that would be hot, wouldn't it, Darren?" Jess said looking at me.

I'm sure my face told her all that she needed to know, but I still was able to croak out, "Yes."

She leaned forward, hands on his chest, and worked her ass up and down, pumping his cock in and out of her stretched pussy. Even Mark didn't stretch her this much. The addition of seeing his darker cock penetrating her pale pussy amped it all up. Fucking is supposed to be about mating, breeding. The cuck desire for this act to reach completion of that purpose was strong. The reality of what that would mean, which they explored verbally in previous sessions together, would be both a nightmare scenario and the peak of the kink.

The idea of a man, any man but especially this man, in my place on our wedding night was one that passed through my head the first time I watched them together. I guess I'd read a story that put this thought in my head, but for Jacen to bring it up and Jess to be so into it was exciting. This session was so all over the place. Was she ending things with him or not? Was this a way for Jacen to hook us both into wanting to continue being involved with him?

His profile on campus and all the talk about them, which I'm sure will be exacerbated after their very public confrontation today, made anything more between them fraught with danger. Especially if he truly believed he was in love with her. And who knows how Mark would react. Our deepening involvement with him and how well that mutual relationship was going could be endangered by anything with Jacen. Hell, even thinking about how this might affect things with Mark made me realize that we, not just Jess, had a serious relationship with Mark at this point. Again, angst about that realization was so intricately intertwined with excitement. Had we become a 'throuple'? Someone to at least consider in any extra-curricular encounters that Jess had.

Reality was definitely sinking in that my life with Jess, which I was 100% committed to, would very likely always include another man. As much as I loved watching her and as much as it turned me on to be 'cuckolded' by her, this wasn't a daunting vision of the future. But it would be a reality that we would both live in every single day. She would be known as a slut. I would be known as a cuck. Hell, that is probably already the case.

Jess continued to ride Jacen's cock hard and a moan signaling the start of her orgasm shook me out of my drifting mind. Right in front of me was a demonstration of something I wouldn't be able to give her myself. Her legs began trembling and Jacen quickly grabbed her by her ass and continued the pumping action as she was practically passing out from such a tremendous orgasm. He used her out-of-control body to continue jerking his cock and her vibrations triggered his own orgasm.

"Oooooo fuck, Jess. So good. Damn your pussy is so fine," Jacen as he blew his load deep into my fiancée.

Jess had collapsed on top of him. I would have been worried if I hadn't seen her breathing heavily. They laid there together for some time. Her small pale white body looked like a dollop of whipped cream on top of his darker body, like a brownie sundae.

I wanted her to keep fucking him. It was counter-intuitive to want it as it was such a clear threat to our relationship. This was clearly an addiction.

I watched as his dick softened and finally slipped out of her, followed by a large clump of his cum. I found myself licking my lips unconsciously. Jacen gently rolled her over on her back and pulled the sheet over her naked body. He got up and summoned me to follow him back into the living room.

As I stepped out with him, he pulled the door closed. His large, muscled body stood before me still nude. His thick cock hung between his legs, obscenely still covered in their combined juices. He noticed me looking and reached over to the sink in his kitchen area for a towel and he cleaned himself off.

I studied his face as he seemed to be searching for his words.

"I'm sorry, Darren. I'm sorry for the scene I caused," he said in a soft sincerity that conflicted with what I had experienced from him before. Gone was the cocky jock. Before me stood a vulnerable guy my own age who had dispensed with any false bravado.

"It's... it's ok, I guess."

"No. It was pretty fucked up. Everyone will be talking about it. Fuck, Coach is going to be pissed."

I found myself feeling bad for him, hoping this didn't screw up his future.

"You know the messed up thing is, the whole situation is, well pretty hot."

"Jesus, dude. You really get off on her getting taken and everyone knowing, don't you?" he asked incredulously.

"It's embarrassing as hell, but yeah. The embarrassment just adds to it for me."

"I know what she said is likely right. About me just not wanting to lose out on her. I probably don't love her. But it feels like I do."

I nodded, unsure what else to say.

"You know, I wouldn't really come and screw her on your wedding night, right?" he went on.

I blushed, hoping he couldn't tell what was actually in my head. "Yeah. I know that would be a bit extreme, wouldn't it?"

He chuckled lightly. "Yeah. But the idea does turn you on, doesn't it?"

I shrugged, not wanting to admit to him that truly it would be one of my top five biggest fantasies.

"You know, I just don't get how you could be ok sharing her. In some ways, it makes me a little mad for her. That she would be with someone willing to share her."

"I know. But, crazy at it may seem and as good as you are in bed with her, I still don't think you'd be enough for her. And she wouldn't be happy caged in. That's why we, her and I work. When I fell for her, I wouldn't have even considered sharing her. In reality, she was already fucking you, even as we were falling in love. When I found out who she was, what she needed, I just... I understood her. And it awakened my kink. To think of her with other men, to see her with other men. Men who could give her what I couldn't, even though our own sex is pretty great."

"Darren... would you help me hang on to her? Even if it's just for a bit longer?"

This was such a surreal situation. To have this man, nearly twice my size and very much still naked before me, asking me to help him continue fucking my girl.

"Jacen, I can't tell her what to do... I certainly like seeing her with you or even knowing what she is getting from you when I am not present. Today may truly be it for you two because of that scene on campus. And I'm actually sad about that. But it's a selfish thing for me to want to see her with you, as twisted as that is. I can let her know that, but it's got to be her decision to continue being with you."

He nodded.

We both heard a rustling in his bedroom and then the door opened. Jess emerged still naked with obvious signs of his semen still clinging to her pussy.

"What are you boys talking about out here?" she asked with a smirk on her face.

"How much I like to see you both together," I said, saving him from any need to explain.

"Is that so?" she smiled saucily at me then looked to Jacen. She moved so that she was next to him and she pushed him to sit down on his couch. She moved closer to stand between his legs which made him just below eye level with her.

"Listen you, that was a very stupid thing to do today. In many ways, it reinforced my concerns about continuing to be with you. And you scared the shit out of me. That alone should mean we're over. I mean, my god, everyone will be talking about it. Have you thought about what your coach will say?"

He nodded ruefully.

And then she looked my way, "And you... You really want this to continue even with all that out there?"

It was my turn to nod, somewhat sheepishly.

She shook her head in mock disgust. "You crazy, crazy boys. Ok., here's what we're going to do. I'm going to talk to your coach, Jacen. I'm going to explain that you and I had a thing. I'll tell him Darren and I weren't exclusive and I had trouble letting you go, but when I did you were hurt. I don't blame you for your reaction and I'm not scared of you hurting me. I'm going to tell him it's done-"

"-But-" Jacen started to interrupt her but she stopped him.

"-but nothing. That's what I'm going to tell him. I'll tell him we talked it out and it won't be a distraction for you any longer. We'll wait a few weeks for things to settle down and then we'll continue much more discretely. You and I cannot be seen together. You can't come by my place, I can't come here. But, you can get away from time to time to meet me at Darren's."

My eyebrows went up when she said that. Mark. What about Mark?

She instantly read what was on my mind, "Darren will make sure none of his roommates are around and we'll have fun in his room. If one of his roommates comes home unexpectedly, we'll deal with it. They like him and won't want to embarrass him. No one will think we're meeting there of all places. It won't be every week. We'll do it when we can. And yes, I very much like fucking you too. I never wanted to give you up, I just was too concerned about what it would mean for all of us. Again, as today clearly showed me I was right to be. If anything like that happens again, Jacen, I'm serious, it's over. That was colossally stupid and dangerous."

He nodded again to let her know he understood. He put his hands gently on the back of her thighs and ran them up to her ass. She smiled at him knowingly.

"I'm going to fuck you again, Jacen. But understand that this time I'm doing it for Darren. Not for you. I love him and while I thoroughly enjoy my time with you and genuinely care for you, nothing will stop me from loving him. It's really by his good graces that you're getting this second chance. Now, that doesn't mean you shouldn't remind him constantly that you're fucking his woman and that you're much better at fucking me than he is."

That last bit came with such a smirk for both of us. Jacen smiled back devilishly as Jess began rubbing his cock to get it hard again.

"You hear that, cucky? She loves you but she still needs my cock. I know you like it, but damn that's still messed up too."

"I know."

Jess had gotten him hard again. She moved to straddle him on the couch, facing me, keeping his cock in her hand the whole time. She was about to put him into her again when she stopped and looked right at me.

"This is what you want, right?"

I nodded.

"Say it. Say you want Jacen's cock in my pussy. Tell him you want him to own my pussy."

I cleared my suddenly dry mouth. "I want Jacen's cock in your pussy, Jess. I want Jacen to own your pussy."

"Good boy. But if you want it so badly, I think you should come over and put it in me."