We had been rehearsing "Godspell" at Carter High School now for one week, every day after school for three hours. Patti was doing fine, and she was very sweet to me and learned quickly. I cast her in the "Day By Day" role, and her scenes with Jesus were touching. She had such an unaware quality; unaware of her budding beauty, and desirability. I couldn't believe that the boys in the cast didn't ogle her more, but I put that down to high school cliquedom. She was kind of shy, and didn't really banter with the other cast members.
And she certainly gave me plenty to fantasize about. One night on a break I went to the old cafeteria, which was plastered with colored streamers and pep rally posters that read "Go Rams!". The place still smelled like spaghetti sauce and peas. Patti was talking to her mom on the telephone. She was sitting on the floor, wearing a pair of baggy gym shorts that billowed at her soft thighs, offering tempting views up her shapely legs. Her knees were open, and between her legs I could see the stretch of her pussy mound under her shorts. As she chatted she casually opened her knees a bit more, and I got a good view down her shorts, and caught a glimpse of white panty, and that beautiful hollow girls have on either side of their pussies. I imagined slipping a finger across that hollow, sliding it under her panties and into her cunt, finger-fucking her while she talked to her mother. "This is a good one." I thought. "This will be a good fantasy for later."
"Do you need me?" she asked, looking up.
I was getting myself a coke from a machine and had stopped to stare at her. She obviously thought I wanted her to get off the phone and get back to rehearsal. Geez! Now I was fantasizing right in front of her! "Yes, break's over." I said, and then, in a more flirtatious manner, "Is that Mommy? Say hello for me."
"Mark says hi." she giggled into the phone. "Yeah, he's the one I told you about. Okay, I'll see you later. Tell Dad I need some help with Trig tonight. Bye." She hung up.
"Talking about me, eh?" I said, sipping my soda.
Patti stayed on the floor, and looked up at me brightly. "She thinks she saw you in some shows here. My brother was in your class."
"Really? Who?"
She was chewing gum and blew out a big bubble while she talked. "Tommy Cielo."
"Oh yeah! I remember him. What's he doing?"
She popped the bubble. "Air conditioner repair. He lives with his wife in New Haven. Did you really do a car commercial?"
"Yep."
"That is so cool. Was it fun?"
"Boring, actually. It took four days to shoot."
She was still casually bouncing her knees opened and closed, offering me flashes of white, creamy thigh while we chatted. Her halter top left her arms and tummy bare, and I could see a good amount of cleavage. My cock was rising, and I couldn't stand in front of her for very long or she'd notice. "All right, back to rehearsal." I said, reaching out a hand. She took it with a groan and I pulled her up. "Don't groan or you get a spanking. Let's go." Her hand felt warm and soft in mine, just the perfect size.
"Slave driver!" she moaned, like a little girl forced to clean her room.
"Move it! Move it!" I said, miming a whip and making cracking sounds. I gave her a little slap on the butt. She giggled and ran out of the cafeteria.
I looked around to see if anyone was watching, then reached into my pants and re-adjusted my cock, which had become engorged. I wanted to run to the bathroom and jerk off right there, but I could hear Mr. McCoy start playing the piano in the theatre, and I knew everyone was gathering for rehearsal, so I buried my lust and went back to work.
Some of kids had taken to sitting with me in the back to watch scenes they weren't in. We'd joke and goof around a little, and this time I was kind of using their heads as bongo drums as I tapped out the melody of "When Wilt Thou Save the People". It was a typical, childish, high schoolish thing to do, and they all laughed. Patti was sitting in the seat in front of me. I could see her pink bra straps underneath the straps of her white halter. The back of her neck was smooth, and I could smell an apple scent from her hair. "Okay." I said, "let's run through the Prodigal Son parable. No stopping. Let's see how much you remember."