Learn what is true in order to do what is right.
-Thomas Huxley
"A.I?...Pppbbbbbbb!" The old man pursed his lips and made the raspberry sound in response to the AI dating ad playing on the wall-mounted video screen. "More like A. Lie! That's your 'April Fool' right there! AI doesn't know joy. It doesn't feel pain. It doesn't experience laughter. It doesn't feel love."
It was April 1st, and the old man sitting by himself at the end of the bar, spouting off to no one in particular, was obviously drunk, and quite possibly crazy. Under normal circumstances, I'd have been inclined to ignore him. But these weren't normal circumstances. First, there was what brought me here. There was also that glance the bartender shot towards him, so quick it was nearly imperceptible.
I gave it another 20 minutes as I looked around the place to try and take things in, get the feel, and wait for my moment. The decor of this place, The Stranger's Room, was broadly what I expected, sort of a late Victorian era English pub, compromised by modern lighting, replica furnishings, and of course by the video screens. I nursed my beer with half an eye on the screen that had prompted the man's outburst. My phone went off. I looked. It was a text from my mother.
"Happy Birthday! Call me when you get a chance. No special hurry, but please don't forget."
I put the phone back in my pocket. I would deal with mom later.
The video screens in the bar switched over to basketball. I saw the opening I was looking for and took it, directing my comment toward the old man whose outburst I'd noticed earlier. He was only about three stools down from me.
"How about those Bucks, man? You think they're gonna finally get it this year?"
"God I hope so."
"I bet you remember the last time, don't ya?"
"Oh yeah, over thirty years ago with Giannis. That was a great team. Hell I was born the year they won it the first time, 1971 with Kareem, except he was known as Lew Alcindor way back then. If they take it this year, I might just go out with 'em too. Ha!"
"No kidding! I was born in 2021, the same year as the last one." I lied a little. I was really born in 2022. "Let me buy you a beer. You can tell me what you remember about the 2021 team. I've got the same name as their star...except that's my last name instead of my first. My name's Giannis, Ted Giannis." I slid down to the stool next to him and stuck out my hand. "Whaddaya say?"
"OK Ted, you're on. Beer's worth a story, I s'pose. Everyone calls me Z."
I wasn't near as much of a basketball fan as I pretended to be that first day, and Z, or what was left of him, was despite appearances still far more than an old drunk holding up the end of the bar.
We talked basketball loudly and long enough that the bartender began to pay us no mind. Then I switched it up.
"You a regular here, Z?"
"I suppose you could say that. Been coming here almost 20 years now, ever since I
retired
." He put a little extra emphasis on the final word, as if there was extra meaning behind it, but offered no explanation.
"Oh. What did you used to do, before you retired, that is?"
"Computers mostly. Probabilistic analysis of natural language models. Got my PhD in machine learning. That's what we used to call it back in the beginning. Now they call it A.I."
"Shit, Z. That's pretty heavy stuff. And it sounds like you were in on the ground floor! Forgive my asking, but how come you're here, and not set up with your own private island somewhere?"
"Long story. But short story is, I got fucked, metaphorically speaking."
"Sorry, man. I bet that's a helluva story too. Buy you another beer if you want to get into it. I got nothing but time."
"Good-looking kid like you? Ain't you got a cute little wife to get home to? A girlfriend or something? Boyfriend? Shit, I don't care. Ain't none of my business."
"Nope. Not me. I'm kind of a lone wolf, a bit of a seeker. That's what led me here to this bar. I grew up on those old Sherlock Holmes stories. If you're a regular here you must know about the significance of the name."
Z's eyes suddenly stopped swimming lazily and narrowed to focus in on me. "If you're hoping to find Mycroft and sundry boffins of Whitehall communing silently in the back, I can assure you, you will be disappointed."
Clearly he got the reference. In the Holmes stories, The Stranger's Room was the only place within Mycroft's exclusive Diogenes Club where people were allowed to speak. "I'd settle for even the barest hint of an approximation," I offered.
"Tell me Ted, what did you say it was that you were seeking?"
"The truth, of course. But first I need to find an honest man."
"Well, Diogenes, you won't find one here."
"I think maybe I already have. Max Menschlich told me about this place."
Z's eyes widened ever so slightly at the mention of the name. "Ted, did the bartender take your I.D. when you bought those beers?"
"Yeah. Sure he did. Lots of places card everybody these days. What of it?"
"Nothing. You just look young is all. Buy me another beer. I gotta go take a leak."
Z got up and headed toward the back, where I presumed the bathrooms were. I got the beers and waited. Maybe he had prostate problems or something, cuz it took him a few minutes before he returned.
"Thanks, kid." Z lifted his glass and took a sip. "When you head back to get rid of that beer, take a look at the sign in the corner, underneath the lamp, if you still want to play Diogenes, that is."
"OK, I will." I replied. "Diogenes, you say. My favorite fun fact about him is, aside from all that searching for an honest man stuff, he was also famous for masturbating in public."
"Well in my book, his lack of inhibition only serves as testament to the purity of his search for truth."
I raised my glass to Z, saluting his banter. It all seemed a bit cryptic. But that's sort of what I was hoping for. As I pondered, I realized I did, in fact, need to take a leak. The beer had caught up to me too. I got up and walked toward the rear of The Stranger's Room. Amidst all the other English pub decor, I noticed a few items that were Sherlockian hung on the walls. There was a houndstooth coat, a bit further down there was a deerstalker cap and a pipe in a framed case. There was a prominent painting of a large and vicious-looking hound overlooking the fog-bound moors. Another frame held a quotation attributed to Arthur Conan Doyle, "Any truth is better than indefinite doubt."
As I found the short hallway that led to the restrooms. I saw the sign at the end, under the lamp on the wall, all done up in fancy script letters on a yellowed, parchment-like background. The sign said, simply, "Seek Truth." Z had made a point of referencing that lamp "if I still want to play Diogenes." I took the hint, and lifted the lamp a little. The fixture didn't move much, but it definitely moved, and it didn't feel like it was just because it was loose. I half hoped a secret door would open up or something, but none did. I pushed through the regular door and went in.
When the door closed, I noticed that behind the restroom door, there was another door. It appeared to be possibly a janitorial supply closet. Not too surprising or out of place in an older building such as this. Then I heard a click, and the closet door opened, just a crack. I couldn't quite see in. "Ted Giannis?" A woman's voice inquired.
"Yes."
The door opened fully, out towards me, but I could see that behind the door, the entire shallow closet was a false front that was now swinging away into the space behind. A slightly pale, thin, 40ish woman with medium-length straight hair, very dark brown eyes, and a somewhat cold, businesslike manner appeared. "In here," she said, as she stepped back to let me in.
I entered. We were in a passageway of some sort in-between walls that weren't even finished on our side. The woman replaced the false door and closet back into their original position and then turned to face me.
"I'm Amanda French." She extended her hand.
I took it. "Pleased to meet you, Ms. French. I'm Ted Giannis."
"Yes. You seem to be looking for something, Mr. Giannis. Do you know what you are looking for?"
"The truth."
"The truth can be a dangerous thing."
"The truth will set you free."
"Or sometimes, the truth can land you in jail. Are you an undercover policeman, Mr. Giannis? A federal agent of some sort?"
"Hardly. Honestly, do I look the type?"
"Honestly, no. But appearances can be deceiving. Let's have it. Why are you here? Who sent you? How did you learn about his place?"
"Nobody sent me. I knew a man named Max Menschlich who mentioned it once, just in passing. I had to piece the rest together. I had a few clues. In college I used to go out with Tajna Bryss, and I once had dinner with Hugh. She said some things back then, things she maybe didn't even completely understand, but that got me started. Mostly, I'm here to learn the truth about the government's use of AI. It starts with the data they collect on people through Sensala, the AI cupid, but I know it's a lot bigger than that."