Authors note: This is a multi-part series following the sexual journey of two married couples, as they explore various fetishes and kink, including their own sexuality. Please read the story tags. You've been warned.
When I woke up, Lisa was still asleep, her head on my shoulder, in our usual position. Her arm and naked breast were resting on my chest. I didn't hear any other noises, but needed to get up and pee. As I did, I felt a weird sensation.
I had forgotten about the plug. I was having trouble getting hard again as she was working her oral magic on my soft cock. So, Lisa she pulled the steel plug out of her ass and put it into mine as she was going down on me. I finally got hard enough for penetration, so she got back on all fours and had me take her from behind, again. I remember having an intense orgasm, as the weight of the steel ball bounced on my prostate as I came. I've played with toys before, but nothing with weight like that. It felt amazing.
I looked back down, and she was still in a deep sleep. I pulled the plug out, washed it, and then headed into the main cabin to make some coffee.
I peeked back in as I took a sip, but she was still out. The door to the captain's cabin was still closed, so I decided to sit on deck. The sky was dark and the temperature was cool, but I was wide awake, thinking about what had happened last night and all day yesterday. Part of me couldn't believe I had agreed to swap with Tom and Susan when the opportunity arose.
Yet, I was looking forward to exploring sexually with our friends. We had always been open about our sex lives, and now at this stage of life, why not swap with them? It's just sex. It seemed natural. Fun. Exciting. New. Different.
Lisa could experience a longer cock, reaching her special spot I can only reach at a certain angle. I would finally be able to fuck Susan, and see how tight that pussy really is. If Tom says it's tight with his skinny cock? I just smiled at the thought.
And then to explore some of the domination stuff that Susan was talking about. That's something I never thought Lisa would have been into. Not only is she open to it, she brought it up!
"I thought I heard someone. You're up kind of early, aren't you?" It was Susan.
"Yes. I guess. After I woke up, my mind started racing."
"Want to talk about it?" She asked as she sat down next to me, wearing a robe, as she sipped her cup of coffee.
"Why do I suddenly feel under-dressed?" While I was getting used to being naked, it was cool out and my cock was hibernating.
"It's in the low 60's Dan, it's still winter out here. But if it makes you feel better, here." She unfastened her robe, letting her breasts spill out as she looked at my shriveled cock. Her nipples started to harden, as the cool breeze swept across her skin. My eyes were drawn to her chest, as I covered my cock with my hand.
Sensing my embarrassment, she said, "I've seen shrinkage before, Dan. Don't worry. I've also seen your cock hard, and can't wait to try it." Winking at me, she took another sip of coffee, waiting for me to respond to her comment. Again, fucking with my head like she does.
"What makes you think we agreed to anything?" I love giving it back to her, always have. But ever since she got her PhD in psychology, she's been more confrontational with me, just to fuck with my head.
"Please. If you hadn't agreed, you wouldn't be sitting out here wearing nothing but an embarrassed smile because your cock is shriveled up." Grinning, she continued, "We didn't bring you out her to force anything on you. The two of you are our deepest friends and we love you. We would never do anything to jeopardize our relationship. I know you agreed, or you wouldn't be talking to me like this now. I know you agreed because you are a lot like Tom. I know you agreed because I know you, and you want to be led, seeing where this journey takes us.
But, we aren't going to do anything without complete consent. The only way this works is for us all to be 100% onboard."
"How did you know we would say yes?"
"I've known Lisa since we were little girls. We've shared secrets for longer than I can remember. She is like me, in a loving, long-term relationship, just looking for a new spark. Tom's heart attack, odd as it may sound, was the best thing to happen to our sex life. It opened so many new experiences I never would have imagined before. When I started describing what we were up to with Lisa, I knew she wanted some of the same things too.
Dan, I know the last day has been a lot to take in, but trust me, we are still the same people we have always been. If you feel uncomfortable at any time, let us know and we will stop. We are on a small boat, so things can't be done behind anyone's back. There is no need for jealousy.
But, in this stage of life, it's natural to want to experience someone else. I've seen it hundreds of times in my practice. People cheating. This is different though. This is an openness with life-long friends to share new experiences." She took another sip of coffee.
"What if something goes wrong? What if we get jealous, and ruin our friendship?" She thought for a moment before responding.
"Dan, you and I have always had a good relationship, going all the way back to when you first started dating Lisa. The last thing I want to do is lose the two of you, as you are more than friends to us. Nothing is going to be forced on you, unless you
want
to be forced." She lifted her eyebrows and gave me a devilish grin when she said that. "But, you and I both know you want this too. I've known you've had a thing for me for years, and I respect you immensely for never once making a move.
Tom and I are in a different place now, and I'm open to it, and I know he is. And the truth is, I've always wondered what it would be like to fuck you, ever since Lisa told me about the first time you had sex." She sat in silence again, letting me think about it.
"This is surreal." I looked up at the millions of stars scattered across the sky. We sat in silence for a few minutes. She allowed me space to think before she finally spoke up.
"Dan, don't overthink things. We are here to have fun and enjoy one another. We have a new perspective on life, and aren't going back. Given the investment you made, you are no longer trapped in the 'working yourself to death' routine. You and Lisa are still young. You both want to experience new things too. Enjoy life!"
She spoke with confidence, and she was right.
Were we really going to do this?
The stars were fading, as a light blue hue was coming over the eastern horizon.
