This story is part of an ongoing series.
The chronological order of my stories is listed in WifeWatchman's biography.
Feedback and
constructive
criticism is very much appreciated, and I encourage feedback for ideas.
This story contains graphic scenes, language and actions that might be extremely offensive to some people. These scenes, words and actions are used only for the literary purposes of this story. The author does not condone murder, racism, racial language, violence, rape or violence against women, and any depictions of any of these in this story should not be construed as acceptance of the above.
***
Part 15 - The Better Mousetrap
It seemed like an eternity as everyone waited to hear Cindy Ross's answer.
"Well, Commander Ross?" goaded Lindsey Black. "Did Donald Troy have sex with Betty Morelli?"
"I don't know." Cindy replied.
"What do you
mean
, you don't know?" thundered Lindsey Black. "How could you not know?"
"Just what I said." Cindy replied. "I don't know if they had sex or not."
"You said you were with them, or at least her, the whole time." Lindsey Black said.
"And I was." Cindy replied. "But I also told you that Commander Troy and I slept in shifts during the night. If they had sex while I was asleep, I obviously was not aware of it."
"You think you're being cute?" Lindsey Black snarled. "You've lied to a Federal Agent, one way or another----"
"No she didn't!" Agnes T. Spires yelled. "She answered each of your questions truthfully. Stop your lies and intimidation tactics!"
"So why didn't you just answer the question before?" asked Dalton Kendell, trying to keep his voice calm. "Why did you take the Fifth, which is meant to be protection against self-incrimination?"
"
Because
*I*
am the one who had sex with Betty Morelli!
" Cindy fired back.
In the stunned silence of the room, she continued: "You've gone after Donald Troy alleging he had sex with her. You destroyed his home unnecessarily. One of your colleagues pointed a gun at his daughter and took the safety off, intending to murder her! And you think I was going to confess to having sex with her without immunity, and subject my daughter and my family to your brutality? Really?"
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
"No, no, no, NO!" yelled Richard Baldwin in the anteroom, realizing fully the implications of Commander Ross's statement. As he turned and began beating the back wall in bitter frustration, Robin Isley was immobilized, staring through the one-way glass. Bob Rovers could not take advantage; he was equally stunned.
"We just gave the bitch immunity!" gasped Baldwin. "We just gave away the whole game!"
"Maybe not." said Special Agent Peter Page. Everyone turned to look at him...
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Richard Baldwin re-entered the Interrogation Room. Lindsey Black stood up to let him sit in her chair, and she took the one to the side that had been occupied by Glenn Alberts.
"Okay, Ms. Ross." said Baldwin. "I want to be clear on this. You say you don't know if Commander Troy had sex with Betty Morelli, is that right?"
"I refer you to the reply I gave some moments ago." Cindy said.
"You did not see them have sex, you did not hear them have sex, is that right?"
"That is correct." said Cindy.
"After you and Commander Troy delivered Betty Morelli to the Federal Building," said Baldwin, "she took the Fifth and was released. She went to where her husband was, south of the City, is that correct?"
"All I can say to that," said Cindy, "is that Commander Troy and I found her with her husband later on."
"Of course." said Baldwin. "Ms. Ross, did you tell Betty Morelli's husband that Donald Troy had sex with Betty Morelli?" (
Author's note: 'Film Noir', Ch. 02.
)
"I don't remember my exact words." said Cindy. "But I was goading Jerry Morelli, and I might have suggested something to him along those lines."
"Ms. Ross," said Baldwin, "Federal Agents interviewed Jerry Morelli in Federal Prison, as well as some of his gang that were arrested and incarcerated with him. They said you definitively said that Donald Troy had sex with Betty Morelli. So I'll give you one more chance to tell the truth, before I bring the hammer down on you for lying to Federal Agents and a U.S. Attorney."
"Hmmphf!" Cindy grunted. "What did you offer them to get them to say what you wanted to hear?"
"You forget yourself, Commander." Baldwin said coldly.
"She's right." said Agnes T. Spires. "Do you really think any sane jury is going to accept the word of criminals who would grasp at straws to reduce their sentences or just get favors, over the word of a decorated Police Officer? And furthermore to this point, when I put them on the stand and ask what you offered them in exchange for whatever you wanted to hear?"
"I'm willing to give it a shot." said Lindsey Black.
"You gave my client immunity, then tried to entrap her." said Agnes T. Spires.
"You really should read up on that entire case." Cindy said. "We were goading Jerry Morelli into following us into a trap, a sting. It worked; we recovered Morelli's military-grade weaponry, and got to charge him with attempted murder, too. So of course I told any old lie to goad Morelli and enrage him."
"I think you admitted the truth then, and Morelli's men are telling the truth, too." said Lindsey Black.
"Which just proves what I've been observing all along." said Cindy. "You're not too good at thinking. Probably from lack of practice." Lindsey Black glared hatefully at her...
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
"Dr. Isley, you have a phone call." said an NCPD Officer. Isley followed him out of the anteroom and to the Conference Room. "Line 2." the Officer said.
"Thank you." said Isley. She went to the landline phone on the table, pressed the button for Line 2. "Dr. Isley... that is correct, sir... no sir... no sir... yes sir." She hung up and went back to the anteroom.
"It's not working." said Robin Isley in the anteroom. "We don't have a case."
"We can't stop trying now---" Bob Rovers started.
"We don't have a case!" Isley repeated. "She has immunity. And you want to pin our hopes on Jerry Morelli's mobsters? Good luck with that. We've been told to drop it. Let's go."
As they began filing out of the anteroom, Isley said "Donald Troy is the State's problem now, Alberts. The Feds won't be taking part in prosecuting him."
"Like it should be." said Glenn Alberts, spiking the football. Isley did not respond as she collected her Agents and Attorneys, and left NCPD Headquarters.
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
News travels fast. When Commander Cindy Ross entered TCPD Headquarters, she found the hallway lined with Officers. Upon seeing her, they broke out into a sustained round of applause, and would not stop until she walked through the gauntlet to the anteroom of her office.