"Well, Lynn," Sam said, "Now that you've paid the penalty, it's time to commit the crime. Tell us Liza's secret."
Lynn looked at me and then at Jake. Her small chest heaved. Her nipples pointed to the sky, and then back to the horizon. I just couldn't get over the sight of this young girl seated naked with legs spread over the chair arms. Her blue eyes, still moist from crying, seemed to blend with the sea behind her. Her pussy, still moist from the humiliation of disrobing, puckered in the new found delight of her own naked beauty.
"Jake," Lynn began softly. "I know you think I should tell, and I've done everything you've asked. I'm sitting here naked for you, after all, but now I just can't do it. I can't tell on Liza. It was wrong of me to even think about it. Please don't make me do it. I'll do anything else you say. I promise."
I held my breath; my mind raced. It was dΓ©jΓ vu: the boys had arranged things to the point that Lynn was now willing to agree to anything. I saw myself in that naked, spread-for-their-viewing girl, and I realized several things: Lynn was about to be put in the same naked boat as I, I had helped put her there, and we were both going to pay dearly. I needed to act and act quickly to divert the boys.
"It's okay, Lynn," I said. "I'll tell the boys everything."
"Just a minute," Jake interrupted. "Lynn, do you really care enough for Liza to do anything? Is that what you just said?"
It was no use. They had latched onto the word, "anything," and would milk it for all it was worth. I continued to hold my breath.
Lynn looked at me, searching for guidance. I tried to shake my head, warn her, indicate in some way that she was on the road to perdition, but I couldn't make my head move. I'd turned to stone - naked, scented stone; I smelt my own arousal.
"I can't betray Liza," Lynn replied in a steady voice. "She's been good to me and for her I'll do anything you say. I owe her that."
"Will you wear an anklet like hers?" Sam asked. "Will you make the same promises that Liza has made?"
"Oh, yes," Lynn said without hesitation and with enthusiasm. "We would be like sisters!"
The breath I'd been holding left me in a rush. I felt like I'd been punched in the stomach.
"Liza," Jake said to me in an officious tone, "Embrace your sister."
I rolled my eyes, but said nothing as I stepped toward her chair. Jake took Lynn's hand and helped her stand up. She opened her arms wide and I pressed against her. Even on tiptoe, her head only came up to my chest. She nuzzled her face between my breasts as I held her tightly. Her firm, small breasts poked my stomach. She wrapped her arms around my waist and squeezed with all her might. I felt my pussy grind into her abdomen, and I felt hers on my leg. Both were leaking.
As I held her I realized that I no longer wished to spare her my fate, but was content that she shared it. She embraced her indenture as she embraced me. I welcomed her to my life openly, sincerely.
"Okay, that's enough, you two," Sam broke it up.
We slowly released each other and Lynn returned to her chair. She sat down, smiled broadly and displayed herself with pride.
"All right, now." Jake looked at me. "You were about to tell us something, Liza."
I dropped my head and spoke quietly. "This morning Ms Thomas called me to her apartment." I paused.
"Yes," Sam prodded.
Jake and Lynn became attentive.
"Well, as I told you, she intended to give me that spanking with the hairbrush, you know, for being on the balcony with you guys in just a towel and then going without panties to a bar. So, there I was, over her lap, my naked ass at the ready, when instead of spanking me, she starts pulling out the hairs around my, you know, the hole. God! It was erotic. I never felt anything like it. Well, once she had me all hot and bothered, she got a phone call and told me to come back tomorrow. I couldn't stand it. Feelings were awakened I didn't even know existed. Ally was with me. Have you met Ally? Anyway, we ran home and I buttered the handle of a spatula and made her shove it up...there. Let me tell you, I had one hell of an orgasm. By the way, I still had that spatula in me when you found me this morning. I was under the covers, thank god, or you would have found out my dirty little secret a lot sooner."
"So, that's the big secret?" Jake asked. "You had a spatula up your ass?"
"Well, it's not that simple. The big secret, you see, is that I liked having that spatula up my ass. I was afraid that if anybody found out, before I had a chance to sort out my feelings about it β remember, this only happened this morning - things might happen before I was ready."
"So Marc doesn't even know about this, huh?" Sam asked.
"No. Please, I'm sooo not ready for him to find out. Please don't tell him."
"Hum," Sam began slowly. "That's an interesting story, and I congratulate you on your openness and honesty, but certain problems remain. First, a penalty must be imposed for your initial secretiveness. Now a second penalty must be imposed for asking that we keep this from Marc. Will you never learn?"
"Oh god! I'm sorry. I didn't mean..." I blubbered incoherently.
"Alright, here's what we're going to do," Sam said as I held my breath. "First, I want you to bend over and show us this eager hole you've been talking about. Bend over and spread your buttocks so we can all see. Do it in front of the chair so Lynn can have a good look, too."
God! I was humiliated. The thought that I would display myself in that manner to these three...eighteen-year-old...children...made me crazy, but I got myself into position in front of Lynn's gaping pussy. I felt the knot in my stomach tighten as I bent over, and I felt the tug at my anus at I parted my buttocks. I really didn't like this inspection, but I knew I needed it.
"Well, what do you think, Jake?" I heard Sam ask. "Do you think that looks like a hole that should be filled?"
That they would talk about my asshole like that was more humiliating than I thought I could ever bear, but I just pulled at my anus even harder in response.
"It's rather small," he remarked. "What do you think, Lynn? Is it too small to have pleasure?"
"It's not the size, that matters," Lynn made a joke that made them all laugh. "She wanted my finger up there. Maybe she still does."
"Wow! Now we're really getting down to the nitty-gritty," Sam said. "You didn't include that little tid-bit in your story," he said to me. "Do you want Lynn's finger up you butt?"
"Oh, god yes," I heard myself blurt out.
I watched from between my legs as Lynn sucked her middle finger to lubricate it. It was a sensuous, teasing sucking that had the boys hollering. I watched as she aimed it at my hole, approaching slowly, as if it were the docking of the shuttle with the space station. I was out of my mind with desire. The docking made me jerk initially, but I pressed against the tip of her finger as it settled in. I felt it go past my sphincter and beyond, where no man had gone before. When the entire length of her finger was imbedded in me, she began to wiggle it. The sensation was out of this world! Suddenly she pulled out all but the tip, and I panicked that it was over, but then I felt another finger, her ring finger, work its way inside me. Together the two fingers impaled me to their full length. She began to pump, and my juices began to flow. She was working it for all she was worth: screwing my ass like a pro. I couldn't believe it, but that she spent a lifetime with her brother's privates in hand should have prepared me for her expertise. I was grateful for her training and knew my orgasm was near. My cries filled the boat. My scent floated over the waves. My juices poured from my pussy. Sam and Jake both grabbed a hold of me so that the spasms wouldn't knock me over. I felt like I was going to pass out.
Sam and Jake lowered me to the deck as Lynn's fingers left their nest. I lay there panting, catching my breath and waiting for my legs to turn from rubber back to muscle.
"Okay," Sam joked. "We're convinced that you like it up the ass."
I could only grunt acknowledgement of his conviction, and then, I don't know why, it just popped into my head to say, "I keep violating the crap out of Marc's 'no touching' rule."