This is a continuation of In The Arms of Angels Pt. 1. It is long, which is why it is in the novel/novella section.
Recap: Jason Hughes is torn from his mother and sisters by his useless father after a messy divorce, moved across the country, and never sees or hears from them again. Fast forward 15 years and his father dies in a horrific accident. After years of his father poisoning him against his mother for not contacting him, Jason finds an unopened letter in his dead father's bedroom indicating that she has been trying to find them the entire time. He reaches out, they make contact, and as any loving mother would do, she immediately flies across the country to be reunited. It's awkward at first, but his mother and 18-year-old sister begin to mend old wounds.
All characters in this story are 18 years of age or older, and this is a work of fiction.
----------------------------------------------------------------
The meal Elin had prepared, with Paige's help, was a hit. Not long after they began eating, Jason had a sense of déjà vu, realizing he'd had the same meal before. And not just spaghetti with meatballs, but
her
spaghetti and meatballs. It tasted different; better than any other he'd had in a long, long time. Elin teared up as he commented on it and told him that it had always been his favorite meal when he was young. The conversation continued as Jason told both women more about himself and described the circumstances around David's death. It broke his heart when Paige went silent, and then tears began falling.
"I'm sorry," she whispered as Elin comforted her. "It just made me very sad." She looked at her brother. "I know that you're very cross with him, but he was still a person. That's a very, very horrible way to die."
Elin saw her son's face scrunched up in anger, but when he glanced again at his little sister's honest tears, his anger quickly abated, and he actually felt a bit of shame. It's like she brought out the best in everyone she was around with her honesty.
Elin cleared her throat and said. "Please, continue."
"That was it," he said. "I didn't have anything else, really."
Now that her tears were under control, Paige gave him a kind smile. "I'm glad you told us all of that. Not great memories, but you are a good, strong, and handsome person."
Jason stammered a bit. "Ah, I mean, I-I don't think I had a hand in the handsome part. DNA, you know? But thank you, Paige."
His sister then let out a long, protracted yawn. "I'm so sleepy," she said with a deep sigh and a frown. "I was enjoying this."
Looking at the time, Elin frowned. "It's 9 o'clock here, which means it would be midnight back home," she said, standing and gathering the plates. "It's past our normal bedtime, young lady. We should probably turn in."
Paige nodded and stood to help clear the table, but Elin stopped her. "I'll take care of it. Go on. Get to bed."
Paige nodded again, hugged her mother, and kissed her cheek. "Goodnight, Momma," she said before she rounded the table and hugged Jason, followed by a kiss on his cheek as well. "Goodnight, Jason."
"Uh, goodnight," he said. He heard her door close and decided to help his mother clear the table.
"Are you okay?" Elin asked as he began loading the dishwasher.
"Yeah," he replied softly, then chuckled lightly. "She really does just kind of know what you need, or at least what you need to hear, doesn't she?"
"She's an incredibly perceptive young lady. I don't know how she got this gift, but I know that I appreciate it." She looked down the hallway almost as if she could still see her daughter. "It's as if she's wise beyond her years but delivers her wisdom in riddles or very obscure ways."
Throughout the rest of dinner, Elin had noticed that Jason still did not want to make eye contact with either her or Paige. Apparently, he was still upset about what had happened earlier. She needed to get him over that hump if they were going to make progress this week. He'd told her that he wanted to come home, which meant that he wanted to go back to Vermont with them. But now he could barely look at her or his sister, presumably out of shame. Going home to a house with not two, but three beautiful women, which Elin was proud to say, would be much worse if she couldn't get him over this particular issue.
"Jason," she said, finally deciding on the direct approach, "may I ask you a personal question?"
"Um..." he started.
She huffed lightly. "Normally, I would just ask, but my relationship with you is different than it is with the girls, or if you had been with us—" she stopped before she finished her thought. "Ah, heh," she let out a nervous chuckle. "I-I didn't—" she stopped again.
"It's complicated," he said, finally looking at her with a weak smile. "You can ask."
After a moment of hesitation, she asked, "Are you seeing anyone? Like, a steady relationship?"
He almost said yes, but Willa wasn't exactly what he'd classify as a steady relationship. And having one glorious night with her wasn't really what he'd refer to as seeing someone. "No."
"It's been a while, I take it?" she asked, but before letting him answer, she added, "I want you to know, Jason, that boys—ah, I mean,
men
your age get easily excited sometimes. So, I really did not take offense to what happened earlier. And I know Paige doesn't either." She stopped, wiggled her head back and forth with pursed lips as she seemed to briefly consider her statement, then said, "To be honest, I'd be surprised if she even noticed. But she's more comfortable about that sort of thing."
He didn't say anything, and instead just rubbed the back of his neck nervously.
"I'm making it worse," she muttered. "I want you to come home with us, if that's what you want, Jason. But I want you to be comfortable around us. It's just been you and David—"
"Not exactly a great role model," Jason growled.
"—and I don't want you to think that you can't be welcome in our home."
He chuckled. "Three whole pairs of boobies, though," he joked, and to his surprise, she laughed with him.
"Hard to tear your eyes away, right?" she asked, then her eyes flared open as she realized what she'd insinuated.
"This—"
"Don't say it," she said as she grasped his hands. "Don't." She was breathing hard as fear rippled through her. "I can't lose you again, Jason. And definitely not for something as silly as this." She touched his cheek. "You're a good man. The fact that you're even upset about this tells me that."
He turned away from her and started the dishwasher, and then leaned on the counter with his eyes closed. "Yes, I'm only 19. No, I don't get much action," he said, and he wasn't wrong. It had been almost seven months since he'd had sex before Willa visited him last night. "And to suddenly have two ridiculously beautiful women here who are family but are more like strangers and are talking about...stuff," he said with a frustrated sigh, "is a bit difficult to process."
It wasn't his intent, but his words about incredibly beautiful women made a shy smile appear on her face. It had been so long since someone had called her that in a genuine way, as opposed to the normal "Damn, you're hot!" comments she regularly received at the country club from men who just wanted a quick fuck.
"You're right. It doesn't help that we don't really even know each other," she said, realizing what he was saying.
"So, you see the issue, then," he said. "I was scared to death to meet you in the first place, worried that I would be seen as a disappointment. Then Paige wanted to come along, another person that I could disappoint. And then two stunning strangers show up. My brain knows that you are family. Other parts of me, not so much." He let out a shaky breath. "I'm so ashamed," he said, barely loud enough for her to hear him, then added, "and couldn't possibly be anything but disappointing."
"Because you find your mother and sister attractive?" she asked, then clicked her tongue at him. "Don't be ridiculous. As I said before, I think you're a good man. You're also a very handsome man. It thrills me to no end that someone like you would find me attractive," she said as a quick thought entered her mind,
Did I really just say that about my own son?
She quickly continued, "And you'd have to be deaf
and
blind to not find Paige attractive. Elaina as well, but you've not met her yet."
"I'm sure she's just as beautiful as her not-at-all-old mother," he said, stressing the last few words as he waggled a finger at her and rolled his eyes. He then let out another chuckle, relaxing at her words. "I don't know. Maybe I'm just making too big of a deal about this. I'm just so worried that you won't want me."
"You couldn't be more wrong," she replied. "I'd be overjoyed if you came home with us. Maybe you could just visit for a week or two? You could see how it goes and then make a decision. If it falls through, you always have this place." She stepped closer to him, taking his hands. "But if it helps you make up your mind, just know that I'd like you to be with us, and to do so as long as possible."