This story is part of an ongoing series.
The chronological order of my stories is listed in WifeWatchman's biography.
Feedback and
constructive
criticism is very much appreciated, and I encourage feedback for ideas.
This story contains graphic scenes, language and actions that might be extremely offensive to some people. These scenes, words and actions are used only for the literary purposes of this story. The author does not condone murder, racism, racial language, violence, rape or violence against women, and any depictions of any of these in this story should not be construed as acceptance of the above.
***
Part 12 - Sunday Morning Data
8:30am, Sunday, June 6th. To say I was dumbfounded at Captain of Detectives Claire Michael wanting to remove and replace MCD Lieutenant Jerome Davis would be a massive understatement. I'm sure the shock showed on my face as I gaped at her, then looked at the Chief and back to her.
Chief Moynahan said "If your intent was to sur-prizzze the Iron Crowbar, Captain, you have exceeded all ex-pec-tay-shunnns."
"No doubt about that, Chief." I said, regaining control of my wits. "Why? And why
now
, of all times?"
Claire: "I've been meaning to bring this up, but Detective Washington was insubordinate on the way to notifying Tia Maple. I told him that, and he immediately asked for a Union Rep. And it's that culture of insubordination and outright disrespect that has been fostered by Lieutenant Davis, so I don't feel I can wait any longer to discuss this."
I said "Give me every detail of what happened between you and Theo." Claire did, though slanted towards her side.
The Chief said "That is hardly insubordinate, Capt-nnnn. You asked what amounted to a personnel question, and he didn't want to answer it within a protocol environment. And you could have handled that in in a much more reeeee-sonable fashion."
I added "And why are you taking this situation with Theo out on Jerome?"
Claire said "First of all, when I brought up these partnership changes, I was met with resistance from the very start, especially by Davis. He didn't give me the report I asked for in the time I asked for it, and when I pressed him and he did send it, it was not what I asked for."
"Furthermore, gentlemen," she said, to include both me and the Chief, "since I took the Captain of Detectives job, I've been evaluating the people within the three divisions. And I just don't think Davis was ready for the MCD Lieutenant job, and he's not ready for it now. He's not in the top four in MCD as far as being a Detective, and I simply don't feel I can trust him to get the job done in my absence and y'all's absences."
"Your response, Commanderrrr?" the Chief said, and I could sense he wanted me to totally demolish Claire's arguments. I proceeded to do so.
"Obviously I don't agree with your assessment, Captain, and that's based on my much longer assessment of him, as well as my assessments of everyone else, and all the leadership's evaluation of Davis." I said. "I think the Chief will back me up on this when I say that making Jerome the MCD Lieutenant despite his youth was a Team decision. Lieutenant Davis is a good Detective, but it was his leadership skills that attracted us to him. The other Detectives follow him because they
want
to, not because they
have
to. And he has stepped up into that leadership role every time that leadership is needed."
Me: "I also need to say this: the partnership changes have had a deleterious effect on the morality of the unit. The Detectives are unhappy with them, and there are even discussions by some of them of finding other jobs. I permitted you to do a trial run on those changes because it's your Division to run. Unfortunately, I think you are not correctly reading the room on the subsequent effects... and this conflict with Detective Washington is a manifestation of that. We're busy with this case right now, but when it's done we need to have an in-depth re-evaluation of it."
"I agreeeee." drawled the Chief. "Captain, the Commander and I are duty-bound to consider your request, and we will sincerely do so. But for now, we'll leave things the way they are, and sort it all out when we finish this case."
Claire nodded, but I wasn't finished yet. I said "I have one other thing, Captain: why did you go to Savannah Fineman to get the warrant to see Maple & Hogue's papers and financial records?"
Claire looked genuinely surprised by the question. She said "She's the ADA assigned to the case, sir."
I said "First of all, there is no case that we have referred to the D.A.'s Office. We're still investigating to determine the true facts for ourselves, so D.A. (air quotes) 'assignments' are moot. Second of all, I thought that after you observed me kick Fineman off of the crime scene and made it clear to you that Fineman was a problem, you would make the correct deduction and understand that we don't work with Fineman. If I have to make that a formal order, I'll be glad to do so---"
"You won't have tooooo." said the Chief. "I'll make that order myself... if Sheriff Griswold doesn't beat me to it."
Claire said "I understand you don't like her, Commander, but I was trying to diffuse a lot of tension with the District Attorney's Office by working with them in a normal way."