This story is part of an ongoing series.
The chronological order of my stories is listed in WifeWatchman's biography.
Feedback and
constructive
criticism is very much appreciated, and I encourage feedback for ideas.
This story contains graphic scenes, language and actions that might be extremely offensive to some people. These scenes, words and actions are used only for the literary purposes of this story. The author does not condone murder, racism, racial language, violence, rape or violence against women, and any depictions of any of these in this story should not be construed as acceptance of the above.
Note: if you try any of the whiskeys discussed in this story, please drink responsibly.
***
Part 22 -
Town & County v. Breonna Bryant
Redux
"Prosecutor, Defense Counsel, I'll see you both in Chambers." said Judge Watts. They followed him out the door as we all sat there, wondering what was going on.
"What's going on?" Teresa whispered to me. "Do they have a verdict already?"
"I don't know." I said. "But Judge Watts looked right at me for a second before asking the lawyers to join him in Chambers. So maybe they dooooo..."
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Once in Chambers, Judge Watts said "The Jury sent this note to me. They are unanimously agreed on seven of the eight charges against the Defendant, and the only one left is the Felony Murder charge. They are asking if they can consider a lesser charge, such as Voluntary Manslaughter. I want your input before I give them an answer."
"Someone in there must know the law." said Paulina. "Man-1 would be the next level down."
"But that wasn't one of the original charges." said Gwen Munson. "So I'm opposed to allowing them to consider a lesser charge.
'If the charge don't fit, they must acquit.'
."
Judge Watts grunted a laugh at that play on attorney Johnny Cochran's words in the O.J. Simpson trial ("If the glove don't fit, you must acquit!"). "Very amusing." he said. "What say you, Prosecutor?"
"If there is any possibility that considering a lesser charge could lead to a successful appeal and overturning the verdict," Paulina said, "then leave it as is."
"Oh, any guilty verdict is going to be overturned after all of the points of appeal I've accumulated." Gwen Munson said cattily.
"But you won't be the one making those appeals after I move to have you disbarred." said Judge Watts. To Paulina's shock, Gwen Munson just smirked at the Judge.
"I'm going to tell them that I'm considering their question overnight, and send them to their hotel." said Judge Watts. "Be here at 9:00am tomorrow morning..."
* * * * * * * * * * * * * *
7:30pm, Wednesday, September 15th. For reasons of safety and better security, Laura and I and our kids and dogs were staying at The Cabin on a weeknight, as were Molly and her boys. Paulina had brought Tasha to spend the night, as well.
"Well, it's just about over." Paulina said to us as we adults sat in the greatroom after supper. She told us about the meeting in Chambers after Judge Watts had gotten the Jury's note. "I have no idea if they're in agreement to acquit or to convict, but the Felony Murder is the only sticking point, from what the Judge said."
"Sounds like they're leaning toward convictions." said Molly.
"I'd like to think so," said Paulina. "But nothing is final until that verdict report is signed and the Jury states it in open Court. They could be voting unanimously today, but then the Judge says they have to vote Felony Murder or nothing, and in a snit they change their previous vote to acquit on all charges."
"True." I said, almost absentmindedly. "But I think Molly's right. Tell me this... could Gwen arrange a plea bargain at this late hour?"
Paulina emitted a low whistle, which got the redoubtable Bowser's attention. As he padded over, Paulina said "Wow, I don't know. I've seen cases where insurance companies fight a claim for eight years, take a plaintiff suing them right up to the moment a line is formed outside the door for jury empaneling, and then they settle. But I don't think I've seen a plea bargain made after the Jury has been charged and is deliberating. I guess it's theoretically possible, and may have happened the past. But knowing Judge Watts, he'd never allow it at this point. Why?"
"Just curious." I said as I petted the redoubtable Bowser. A moment later, Carole appeared.
"Daddy," said Carole, "Sheriff Griswold is about to arrrrive. He wants to talk to you, and it must be im-por-tant."
I said "I'm sure it will be------"
"WOOF!" barked Bowser. A second later we heard the sound of tires on the driveway. And a moment later, Laura opened the door to admit Our Sheriff.
"Hello everyone." he said as Carole and Tasha hugged his legs. "Hi Bowser." he said as he petted Bowser, who wagged his tail mightily at the attention. "Don, can I talk to you outside for a moment?"
"Sure, Sheriff." I said. "Bowser, do you need to go
out?
" Buddy appeared out of nowhere and beat Bowser to the door. They scampered around the side and down their hillside trail to do their business as the Sheriff and I sat in our 'usual' places on the deck.
"It's getting cooler." growled Griswold. "We'll be using that wonderful fire pot soon."
"Would you like me to light it now?" I asked, taking the hint and moving forward to light it.
"Sure." the Sheriff barked. I started the gas and lit the fire pot, then sat back in the metal mesh loveseat as the Sheriff settled into his seat to my left, and began: