*Author's note: This is Chapter 3. You should read at least Chapter 2 for some backstory.
Fun fact: I've received many comments saying my story is not realistic, fair enough, but I actually take inspiration from real life events that me and my friends have experienced*
*****
"I'm pregnant." she said.
Andy didn't know what to say, and he didn't have time to say anything because she kept talking.
"I found out almost four months ago. For the longest time I didn't know if I should tell you or not.
My mother hates me, she doesn't know it's yours and that we had sex while we were together.
She didn't even ask if it's yours, because she knows you're a good guy, so she assumes I was a whore and that's why you left me. And I know I had sex with you when you told me we shouldn't, so I can't blame you or her for thinking that.
This is my punishment. I deserve it...
I don't know if you wanna be a part of our baby's life, but now you know."
She said all this almost without breathing, while tears ran down her face. She was glad he couldn't see her. She was shaking and waiting for him to say something.
Finally, he spoke.
"Wow. I don't know if I wanted to know or not, but I guess you were honest, so you did the right thing.
It's true you didn't cheat, but that doesn't make you any less of a whore.
We weren't married or even engaged, and you knew how I felt about pre-marital sex.
You literally had sex with me while I was asleep. That was fucked up.
I hope you aren't telling me this in hope that we will get back together, because it's not gonna happen.
I do want to be part of the baby's life, I'll send you money to support it, but I don't know if I want him or her to know I'm their father, because I might have a real family one day and I don't think it would be fair on them."
"I understand" she said, still crying.
"Are you sure it's mine anyway?" he asked.
"Yes Andy, I wouldn't be calling you if I wasn't sure. You're the only one I've had sex with. And no, I didn't call you because I want to get back together, but I'm still in love with you."
Andy didn't know what to say back.
Deep down he wished he still cared about Laura, because after all she was carrying his child, but he just didn't feel the same anymore.
He wasn't going to start a family with a woman he didn't love or respect, so he just apologised for not returning her feelings, wished her good luck and told her she could call him whenever she needed money or anything for the baby, which she really appreciated.
When he walked back downstairs, most of his co-workers had left the party. Jenny smiled and winked at him but he didn't really pay attention to her. He was still thinking about the conversation he just had.
It was just sinking in that he was going to become a father, and the poor child would be a bastard. He cursed his ex for what she did to him, and he was also starting to regret what he did with Jenny.
She had tempted him into having meaningless sex.
He kept worrying that even though he didn't cum inside her and she was on the pill, she might still get pregnant, and he would have to deal with another child, from a different woman when he hadn't even turned twenty-five or earned enough to support them.
He couldn't think about all that.
He decided he wouldn't worry about Jenny for now, since the chances of her being pregnant by him were very slim, but he decided he would never sleep with her again.
When Andy left the party he barely looked at Jenny while he said goodbye.
She could tell he was being cold, and something must have happened, she wondered what his ex wanted from him, and the mere thought of them getting back together made her feel jealous. She could still feel his dry cum on her chest and belly and that made her feel both embarassed and upset.
She couldn't believe this guy.
Only a few minutes before he was fucking her, she even let him fuck her in the ass, and now he barely looked at her, all because of one call.
She needed to know what they talked about, but she didn't want to be nosey, so she figured she would just ask him when the time felt right.
She thought about him the whole ride home and when she got there she masturbated thinking about earlier, looking at her cum covered tits in the mirror while she did it.
After finally cumming she felt kinda slutty, and kinda sad, but she also couldn't help but feel a deep admiration for Andy.
She thought that maybe she didn't really deserve him as a boyfriend, that she had been a slut to him and tempted him into having sex with her and now that he had had her he probably wouldn't have any interest in dating her, especially considering his views, and she didn't blame him.
Maybe he would still fuck her from time to time, (since she was pretty sure she had given him the best orgasms of his life) but there was nothing else she could offer him.
------------
For over two weeks, Andy and Jenny didn't really talk at work (or outside of work), they would just greet each other if they saw each other and that was it.
Andy had so many thoughts and worries that he decided he didn't need more drama in his life. Plus he was still kinda angry at Jenny for tempting him into having sex with her.
He focused on work and barely even went on dates anymore.
This other co-worker, Amanda, had been trying to catch his attention lately, but he barely noticed.
Jenny was obviously heart-broken by this situation, but she wasn't surprised. She really wanted to know what Andy's ex had told him though, so she resolved she would ask him, one way or another, but it was really hard since he wouldn't give her a chance to talk to him.
She had only told about their "encounter" to one of their co-workers, Amanda, who was also her friend. She knew she could trust her to keep the secret and she noticed something was wrong and that her and Andy weren't talking anymore, so she basically forced it out of her.
She was ashamed of telling anybody else, especially her best friend, since she'd always talked badly about him to her, so she felt like she would judge her.
