My continuing thanks to Erik Thread for his skillful and insightful editing. He helps make this a much better and readable story. He is a very patient man. Any errors are, of course, mine.
Martin Polikoff pushed into the tavern just before two-thirty that afternoon, rushing through a late summer downpour. He spotted John and the woman sitting in the far corner of the room, away from everyone else.
"Thanks for coming, Martin," John said, rising from his seat. "This is Nina Milano. She's from Westport, Connecticut. She's pretty sure she's my wife," he grinned.
Martin held out his hand and smiled at the woman. She was nervous. The first thing to do was confirm her identity.
"Mrs. Milano, I've been working with John since he woke up in the hospital and we've been having no luck at all establishing his identity until you came along. Please understand that I'm not here to interrogate you, but the circumstances surrounding John's case reek of foul play. I'm a cop. I'm naturally suspicious, so excuse my questions if they sound like I don't believe you. I need to be certain of the facts. Understood?"
"Yes ... understood," the woman said, calming down.
"The first thing I'm going to need is some proof that you are who you say you are. Pictures of you and John together would be very helpful. References that identify John and you together. Family photos would be good. Particularly older ones. Can you do that?"
"Yes ... I'm sure I have a hundred of photos of us together. I have his passport with his picture too. When do you want them?"
"I'd like to send someone to your home to get them as soon as possible. When will you be returning?"
"I don't know. Tomorrow, I suppose," she said, looking to John.
"Fine. I'll have someone from the Westport police drop by and pick them up. If anyone asks, we're still searching for John ... Tony, I mean. Please don't tell anyone you've been in touch with Tony. We still don't know what's going on and we have to be careful."
"Of course. Tony said the same thing. I won't mention this to anyone," she promised.
"I have another question. Why did you come to the precinct station to ask about your husband and not give them any details?"
"I don't understand."
Polikoff produced the picture taken by the security camera. "Isn't this you?"
Nina examined it carefully. "Yes, it does look like me. But, I was never in a New York City police station. I know I called several people in the N.Y.P.D., but I never did go to see anyone. I couldn't get anyone interested in looking for Tony. I had the Westport Police fax them their missing person's report. That's as far as I ever got."
The detective sat looking at the woman, studying her face and her reactions as she talked.
"If it's not you ... then who is it?"
The woman shrugged, not looking at the detective. He decided to carry on.
He spent the next ninety minutes talking to Nina and Tony. The questions were largely directed at Nina. He asked her about her husband's background and where they came from.
When he had explored all his avenues of investigation with the woman, he once again apologized for grilling her. Nina smiled her understanding, claiming she was grateful for his thoroughness and willingness to help. She admitted that she hadn't expected to find Tony, but by pure luck she had discovered him in the outdoor market.
Tony had remained silent for the most part, concentrating on the detective's questions and Nina's answers. When the interview was concluded, he slumped back in his chair, letting out a long sigh. The meeting had been very intense.
After Polikoff had left, John turned to Nina.
"Have you got a place to stay tonight?"
"Yes. I booked into a hotel uptown." She studied him for a moment. "Are you going to stay with me tonight?" It was a hopeful question.
"No. I'm sorry, but I'm not ready for that. Today has been a big shock and I don't think it would be a good idea just yet. I'd like you to go home tomorrow and find the pictures that Martin wants. I'll call you. I have a new life here and I can't just abandon it."
"But Tony ... you're my husband. I need you back with me, in our home, with our children. Don't you want that?"
"Of course, but ... it's not that simple. Give me some time to work this out, Nina. You've found me now, so you can stop worrying about that. But I have a lot of lost memories to recover. It isn't as simple as just going back to my old life and picking up where I left off. There are too many gaps ... too many things to learn. I'm sorry. I don't want to hurt you, but ...." He stopped, gazing at the woman before him.
"I guess I understand, Tony. But ... please ... please ... come home soon. I need you. We need you. We'll help you remember. I promise," she begged.
He nodded. "Just give me a chance to get a grip on things. We don't know if I'm still in danger - and that would mean that if I'm in Westport, you and the children might be in danger too. I can't let that happen."
She sighed and closed her eyes, covering her mouth with her hand. Tears formed in the corners of her eyes. She nodded her understanding. It may not have been what she wanted, but she appeared to understand.
-0-
Detective Sergeant Martin Polikoff phoned Muriel Bartlett's apartment promptly at eight the next morning, almost asking for Tony before remembering to call him John.
"Good morning, Martin. I expected your call."
"Yeah. So tell me ... what's changed?"
"I've begun to get more of my memory back. It was happening throughout the day, especially when you were interviewing Nina. I have a lot of new information for you. I was going to call you to set up a meeting. There's a lot you need to know."
"Does Nina know?"
"No. And that's intentional. I'll explain when I see you. This afternoon OK with you?"
"Yeah ... sure ... two-thirty?"
"See you then," Tony said, signing off.
Martin arrived at two-fifteen. Tony smiled as his friend entered the tavern.
"I didn't think you'd be late."
"I've been waiting a long time for this. I brought my pocket recorder. I don't want to miss anything."
"Well ... where to begin. First things first. My name is Anthony Milano, but almost everyone calls me Tony. I am forty-four years old, and my birthday is December 11th. I am married to Nina Novak and I do have three children. I have a home in Westport, Connecticut and I am financially very well off. I have a summer home on Nantucket Island and we vacation in the Caribbean in winter.
"I am Vice President of Carbutt, Mellows and Davidson ... or at least I was when I was last there." He paused at that point.
"So far, that confirms what Nina told us yesterday."