A white Ford Explorer drove up the track to a ranch in Ohio in rapidly fading light. A guy, not yet eighteen in jeans and a blue and white checked shirt, came out of the house and walked over to the vehicle.
Andy Ash, a lean guy with unruly blond hair, had a bleeding lip and swollen eye. Looking concerned, the woman driver rolled down her window and said, "You don't look like a guy who's ready to take my daughter to the graduation dance Andy?"
"No ma'am and I apologize. Please tell Angelina my father forbids me to go."
"And he beat you to reinforce that message?"
"Ma'am I regret I cannot answer your question."
"I understand Andy. Please go inside and get your mom to go to the bathroom and bath your lip. Your brother and sister will be in the TV room I guess?"
"Yes ma'am."
"Then off you go."
Amy Williams sat in her car and waited till she saw a light go on in a bedroom. She then pulled her handgun from under the front seat and picking up a torch went to the door and knocked.
Carl Ash, wearing only jeans and an undershirt and reeking of whisky, opened the door.
Torchlight blinded him. A shot rang out and a bullet ripped into his right shoulder. He fell screaming, not seeing his assailant who'd doused the light and had walked to her vehicle and drove off.
"Omigod your father has shot himself," Andy's mother cried. "This will disgrace the family."
They heard Carl shout.
His wife gritted, "The brutal oaf, he failed to kill himself. Do you want to finish him off or shall I do it?"
Andy was shocked. His father often beat his wife, occasionally when in quite a rage, but he'd not known his mom felt as strongly as this. Jesus if one of them shot him it would be murder.
"We should go and see if he's okay or not," he said. "Finish my attending to my lip later. Common let's go."
They found Carl had dragged himself to the sofa but had been unable to pull himself up. He was pressing his blood-soaked undershirt against his shoulder to suppress the blood flow.
"Try to fix dad up mom, I'll call the County Sheriff Office."
Amy Williams returned home twelve miles away and calmly told her daughter what had happened.
"Please don't cry darling and don't tell anyone, especially your father, what I've just told you. If you do break down, your father will want to know what's upset you and in all probability that could land me in really big trouble and I could go to jail. You're eighteen and it's time to be strong. Take my vehicle and go alone to the ball and just say that damn Andy Ash didn't show up and no questions will be asked. Many people there are used to hearing Andy being called a loser and know he was voted as the student most likely not to succeed whereas you and I know about the terrible time he's had at home because of his violent father."
Amy went to the front room with coffee and the three guys playing poker with her husband Bernie ignored her as usual and so she said, "Who's cheating tonight."
The guys looked at each other suspiciously and then eyed Amy and Bernie said, "What do you mean?"
Amy smiled. "I've heard women say that men who cheat on their wives also cheat at poker."
The guys looked at each other suspiciously.
Amy, in that attempt to establish an alibi that she'd been home all evening, said she'd be back with coffee and cookies in an hour's time.
The problem for the Sheriff was the lack of any evidence. All that Carl Ash could tell them was there was a knock on the door; he was blinded by some sort of light and was then shot. Carl had not seen anyone or even heard and talking or heard any vehicle driving off. His son Andy had been kicked in the face by a heifer and was in the bathroom with his mom attending to his cut lip at the time the shot rang out. The kids Peter and Kate had the TV up loud and had heard nothing untoward.
Next day the sheriff learned that Andy Ash had missed going to the high school graduation ball that night with Angelina Williams and sent two deputies to enquire with the Williams about that.
The Williams family appeared astounded to learn that Carl Ash had been shot the previous night and was in hospital.
Bernie said he had been playing poker at the time and that Amy had been home all night. Amy said that was correct at gave the names of the three neighbors who were visiting for a friendly game of poker.
The deputies then questioned Angelina.
Amy nervously listed to Angelina being question and became proud of her daughter who at the time of crucial questioning, lied with the skill of a much older female.
Angelina had burst into tears when asked had she shot Carl Ash by mistake instead of shooing at his son for standing her up.
Earlier Amy had calmed her daughter faking her reaction at the news while the deputies questioned Bernie. When the deputies turned to question Angelina she'd said, standing with hands on hips, "I wasn't surprised that Andy didn't show up. He's always been a loser and as long as I've known him and his behavior is erratic."
"God I told everyone at the ball last night the jug-head head stood me up. I'm now embarrassed to learn he didn't show up after being injured by a cow. And if you think Andy shot his father then forget it. Andy is a crack shot and if he shot at anything it would be between the eyes."
After the deputies left Amy said quietly to her daughter, "Is Andy a crack shot?"
"I have no idea. I don't even know if he can shoot. But as you know I've always stood by him ever since four years ago when he saved me from probable drowning down at the lake."
Her mum hugged Angelina and whispered thank you for supporting her mom. "Come on darling, let's go over and visit Irene and family."
As the two females drove off, Amy said to her daughter, "This is an unsettling time for them. Now remember, not a word about what you know about last night."
Irene was pleased to see them and was worried that someone might be back to shoot them all.
Amy was quick to calm her.
"Look Irene, we all know Carl is not the most popular guy around. My thinking is it would have been someone from a while back who came off second-best in a fight with Carl and bided his time to come to settle the score with a bullet to the shoulder. Anything else would have risked being caught up in a murder investigation that would have produced evidence of that fight."
"You could be right."
"Well Irene keeps a gun under your pillow."
"No way. I won't allow a gun in the house because Carl loses control at times."
"How do you kill injured cattle?"
"There's a rifle in each of the ranch pick-ups and that's where they stay. I told the sheriff that but he said Carl was shot by a handgun and I said we have no handguns around here."
The women talked on and Angelina went out to meet Andy who was walking back from the barn.
Amy said, "When does Andy go off to work with his uncle thru summer to earn cash to help him at college?"
"Andy leaves tomorrow early, before his father arrives home. Look keep what I'm about to say to yourself. Carl had been drinking for a at least three hours before he was shot and earlier in the evening beat Andy cruelly for no reason at all other than he didn't want Andy to go to the school ball. I lied to the sheriff and confirmed Carl's lie that Andy was kicked by a heifer. I didn't want the sheriff thinking Andy might have shot his father although I knew Andy was beside me at the time and he doesn't have a handgun."
"Yes it's a good idea that you get Andy away from here. Carl will be in a lousy mood now that here's disabled. Um would you mind if I gave Andy a check to help out with college?"
"Oh no please, we can afford to support him provide he works to earn money."
"I suggest this in case Carl becomes mean with the support you guys are giving Andy."
"Oh very well then; you are so kind."
Amy wrote out the check to Andy and handed it to Irene.
"Omigod for one thousand dollars, Amy you can't."
"Oh yes I can and remember Andy refused to accept a reward from us four years ago for saving Angelina from drowning. He didn't need the money then but he does now as he ventures out into the world alone."
* * *