Cream In The Dark

Editor's note: this work contains scenes of rough, reluctant, dubiously consensual, consensually non-consensual (CNC), or non-consensual sex or scenarios.

*

"Stop!"

I bumped into the back of Eric as he did exactly what he shouted.

"Did you see that?" he asked as another couple passed us.

"What?"

"In that room we passed."

"What was I supposed to have seen?" shouting at him over the din of noise that was part of the annual house of horrors.

"In that room we just passed."

"They all look the same."

We had just passed a room that wasn't very large and most everyone missed it on the way down to the OR, an exhibit that was supposed to be really gross.

"I'm getting a headache with all these crazy strobes," I whined.

"What?" he shouted in my ear, leaving a little moisture on the side of my face.

"Yeah that too.

We were halfway through the community college fun house, House of perpetual fright or whatever you wanted to call it.

Actually the name of the event was Scream in the Dark. It was the annual haunted house that the church and local college threw together for Halloween and was fun, I guess... if you were twelve.

"Let's go back for a sec, I wanna check something."

I reluctantly followed him running into the few that were walking in the right direction.

Eric suddenly stopped at the room I had already ignored. The place was nearly empty and I was beginning to wonder why we showed up in the first place. We were at least five years older than most of the kids that went too these things anyway and I was already beginning to feel a little out of my element.

"What did you see?"

"I could have sworn that Gina was in one of these rooms. It was the room that had the old fashioned stocks." You know, like the ones we made in wood shop last year."

"Why did we make those again?"

"Because we got an A in the class and didn't have to go to PE."

"Right."

"The school was having a play about the Salem witch trials, remember?"

He stopped ahead of me and peeked around the corner.

"Yep, this is the place. He reached back me and pulled me up beside him at the same moment I looked around the corner and into the room that looked pretty much like everything in this place dark with green strobe lights going off intense and blinding. It gave me the impression that I was looking into a dirty fish tank.

There in the middle of the room was a double set of stocks from the 16th century, the kind they placed people in for petty crimes or suspected witches until they went to trial.

Now that set of stocks looked familiar to me,

Both women were in the stocks that trapped their hands and heads. The two were right beside each other.

Two women, made up to be witches. Heavy makeup, rubber noses, bad wigs. Beside them stood a guy in a dark, hooded outfit with a whip in his hand. He had a hood on and was supposed to be whipping them occasionally or at least pretending to whip them as they screamed out their innocence.

It was obvious that none of the three were going to win any awards for acting.

The guy with the whip was leaning against the stocks and looking at his phone. The two women seemed to be in a conversation and laughing about something that probably had nothing to do with the state of 16th century punishment.

"If that is Gina then the guy with the whip has to be Travis, her boyfriend.

"You mean, current boyfriend," I said, "or flavor of the week."

Gina was that one girl in school who was popular with the entire football team, either one guy at a time, or in most cases, the entire team at one time. It was a wonder that the team won any games at all.

Most of those who were going through the maze simply ignored the exhibit, and walked on to the next one.

"That's Gina," Eric insisted. "And I bet those are the stocks we made last year in woodshop class for the play, The Crucible."

"I peeked around the corner. Despite the heavy makeup, he was right. It was Gina.

"What about the other girl beside her?"

I looked again and pulled my head back.

"That's Ms. Marks, from English Lit class. You know the hot teacher, MILF with the best ass in the state."

"No way, Diane Marks would never do something dumb like this," Eric said. "I spent two years jerking off thinking about what I would do if I had my hands on that woman's ass."

Travis in monks outfit, looked up briefly and pulled his hood back then spotted us. It was Travis, star running back for the Panther's football team and he spotted us looking in. He immediately scowled and flipped us off.

"Nice," I said pulling my head back around the corner. "That's Travis all right."

"See, That' is Gina. If she's here then you know Travis will be here just to keep an eye on her."

"With tits like hers everyone has kept an eye on her."

"Yeah I know. She must have fucked just about every guy in school."

"Not every guy, just the jocks and the guys who give her free pot."

Gina was one of those girls who lived in a world where guys like us were invisible.

"What the hell is she doing here?"

"And why is Diane in there with her?"

"This is sponsored by the church. Believe it or not, Gina goes to church."

Hope she doesn't use the confessional," Eric joked, "she'd be there all week."

"But I'm sure that the woman beside her is my English teacher."

"Okay, so if that's them, who cares?" I started to turn and head back in the direction of the exit when Eric grabbed me.

"Is there another way into that room?" Eric asked.

"Yeah. Through the door your standing right next to," I pointed to the barely visible door.

Eric twisted the knob and was surprised when he found it was unlocked.

"You wanna have some Halloween fun?"

He pushed open the door and disappeared inside grabbed me by the shirt and dragged me inside with him and before I could say anything, he closed and locked the door behind us.

Most nights we were at my house playing the popular games on Xbox and talking about getting the girls we knew we would never have a chance with.

Tonight, that was going to change.

Now we found ourselves standing in a larger room but not as dark as the hallway we just came from. There was a small light on in the room, not bright, but just enough see.

"Check this out." Eric pointed to the other side of the room.

There in front of us was the back half of the two girls we had just seen. There was a heavy plastic sheet dividing the room in half. The only part of them was visible to those passing through, just heads and hands, and the stocks themselves.

We now had the best view. We just stood there for a moment to assess, as it were, the situation in front of us.

"Do you fucking believe this?" I almost shouted.

"No need to whisper, he said leaning closer to me. "There is so much noise in this place; they are never going to hear us."

The two were beside each other, with their knees resting on a padded bench. Diane was wearing a pair of black super tight spandex yoga pants that showed off her shapely ass and the faint outline of a thong beneath.

Gina was wearing shorts and long bare legs and tennis shoes. Both women's behinds looked incredible.

"Oh my God," I said. "I think I'm going to cum just standing here."

"Save it because you're going to need it." Eric said. "We're going to have some fun this Halloween."

"They are using the stocks we built for this thing," he said. "You remember building them?"

"Sure, it seemed to take forever."

"So you remember what we did to those stocks when we were making them?"

"Oh shit," I said as it just suddenly hit me.

"We can just lock them in those stocks and do you remember the hidden latches we built into them?"

"I almost forgot about them."

"Yeah but we never got a chance to use them."

"Well now we're going to get that chance."

"One thing I want to check. Eric walked over to the small table on the other side of the room where the women had placed their purses and coats.

He checked the purses and ID's that were inside confirming the identities of the two of the women.

"Look what I found in Diane's purse," he said, holding up a foot long black rubber penis that was at least an inch and a half round.

He had an evil grin on his face.

"Is that that what I think it is?" I asked, staring at the huge black vibrator in his hand.

He turned the dial at the other end and it came to sexual life in his hand.

"I would hate to be on the receiving end of this." He grinned.

We crossed the room and stood directly behind the two perfect asses, knowing that there was a slim chance of pulling this off and if not, we would die trying.

"You got your phone right? Might as well get it out and push record."

We snaked our hands under the curtain, knowing that they were not going to be noticed and pushed the wooden pegs in as far as they would go, and securely locking both women in. There was a slight click.

We stood up and got behind them.

"No turning back now," Eric said, staring down at Gina's curvy butt.

"On three. One....two...."

There was a surprised yelp from the other side of the curtain as we pulled their pants down at the same time. Eric pulled Gina's shorts all the way off and tossed them into the dark corner of the room. I did the same with Diane's tights.

"I can't believe we're doing this," I breathed, standing there behind my dream girls whose bare ass was less than a foot away.

"Beat's the hell out of Xbox," Eric laughed.

I agreed.

We dropped our pants and grabbed the two best asses in town and slid right into our Halloween treats.

All of a sudden their legs started kicking out and I heard faint shouting from the other side of the tarp.

Then both of them started struggling at the same time.

It was no use; trying to get out of those stocks would be impossible. That of course is why they were built.

But then of course, they couldn't kick at us anymore than they could free themselves as they had to use one knee for support.

I heard a shriek and their feet started moving on the bench. They were both trying to pull themselves out of the heavy stocks but it wasn't going to do them much good.

"God damn look at this ass!" I groaned, and almost came as soon as I slid into my teacher's tight pussy.

Eric did the same with Gina's cunt and we were off and running.

"Now you see how useful these fucking stocks are," I managed as I started aggressively hammering in and out of her the struggling woman.

The two of them were kicking out with one leg at a time, and struggling but getting nowhere. To the amusement of everyone on the other side of the curtain, it was part of the act.

We continued hammering into them almost in unison and couldn't believe this was happening at all. Within three minutes I had already cum hard but there was no way I was pulling out. I continued to pound Diane's clenching pussy as I hammered into her, shoving all eight inches of solid flesh and muscle inside the woman. Hers was the tightest cunt I had ever been in, but it was the fact that just a thin curtain away, was a crowd watching the effects of my intense fucking and enjoying every scream from the sexy witch.

Eric must have been feeling the same intense euphoria as I was experiencing I glanced over at him and his eyes were closed and he had a huge grin on his face.

I reached forward and slid my hands under her loose fitting top and played with Diane's large shaking tits and pulled on her nipples, making her scream that much more. These were the same tits I had to stare at all through her class, sitting at my small desk with a boner just hoping that she wasn't going to call me to do a problem at the board.

I wasn't even paying attention to what Eric was doing to Gina right beside me. All I heard was him groaning and repeating,

"I can't believe I'm doing this," as he hammered himself into the girl's legendary pussy.

Then I heard a high pitched scream and turned and saw that Eric had forced the first three inches of Diane's black vibrator into Gina's anus and turned it on the highest setting.

"See, they are possessed," came the booming voice of Travis on the other side of the curtain. We didn't know he had a small mic and started really getting into his character now that the two women were doing something more interesting than just chatting.

"My friend's" he continued, "they are clearly possessed by the Devil himself,"

With all the other noise and his amplified voice booming out over the girls, there was no way we were going to be heard.

If only he knew that on the other side of the thin curtain, we were driving our stiff cocks into the two women we had only masturbated to before.

"See how they scream and beg for mercy, they are truly possessed by the devil," shouted Travis, "and the devil is inside them at this very moment."

That last statement had both of us laughing because; we were inside them at that very moment, both of us fucking the girls that had been our high school fantasies and now, with just a few months left till the end of school, we were living those fantasies.

Eric pulled the vibrator out of Gina's ass and handed it to me. I pulled my cock out of Diane and easily inserted it all the way into her, then moved the head of my cock slightly upward and pushed it into her brown knot and slid all the way in. I heard an immediate scream and felt her constrict around my shaft.

I looked over and saw that Eric had pulled out of Gina's cunt and pushed the head of his cock into her anus and was in the process of shoving it all into her backend. She was kicking out with one leg and balancing on the other and not really getting anywhere. Both women were now screaming like banshees on the other side and I could only imagine the crowd that had stopped to watch.

The muffled howls and screaming coming from the other side of the curtain must have been a real show.

"Wanna trade?" Eric asked, pulling out of Gina's ass.

"Sure," I agreed. I had already cum in Diane twice and was ready for something different.

I pulled out of her stretched ass hole, leaving the humming black dick inside her and traded positions with Eric, then slid easily inside Gina's slippery cunt.

It's a real turn on knowing that just a thin black curtain separated me from the crowd of mom's Dads, kids and just about anyone else that might venture into a place like this on Halloween, all completely unaware that I was fucking the same girl they were completely captivated in watching.

"Oh my GOD!" I heard her scream from the other side of the curtain as I started hammering into the girl.

I pulled out of her after I shot my last load and peeked around the curtain's far edge. There was a large crowd gathered watching and now Travis was pretending to really get into his role, ignoring the girl's pleas to come back and see who was assaulting them. Most of those watching couldn't hear a thing they were screaming because of Travis's amplified voice and the noise of the building.

I slipped back and saw that Eric was now pulling his cock out of Gina's anus, an inch at a time, her ass was shaking all over the place. He gripped her hips and shoved himself all the way in.

I quickly did the same with my English teacher's ass and was well on our way for round two.

Fucking the two of them in the ass brought even more and louder screams from them. It couldn't have hurt that bad because everyone had heard the rumors that both loved being ass fucked.

"And you thought we were going to leave early cause this was boring." he said leaning close to me. "I told you this was going to be fun tonight," he said. "We play tricks and get the treats."

I filled Gina's ass with a few extra ounces of cum that she probably didn't expect tonight, and checked my watch.

The haunted house was going to close soon. I looked at Eric, phone in hand and still recording with his cock fully buried in Diane's anus.

"I think we're done here."

He nodded and reluctantly pulled himself out of her

Just to make sure it all remained where he put it, he shoved Diane's vibrator inside her butt, filling the tight shit chute with the slippery rubber dick and left it on high.

I could still hear screaming but more groans than anything else.

Eric checked his phone.

"This place is supposed to be closing in fifteen minutes."

"Wait let me do something first," he said.

He grabbed a black marker that I found in Diane's purse and got behind her, and wrote on her beautiful cheeks,

Hope you enjoyed the stocks. We did. Happy Halloween!

Then I gave her a grade of A+

He handed the marker to Eric and he wrote on Gina's ass, A++

"That's pretty generous," he said looking at the grade.

"She's got one helluva great ass."

We put our phones away knowing we had the best video ever, then pulled up our pants and got the hell out of there.

The news later that night was brief. Two of the performers had to be rescued from the malfunctioning props at the haunted house in town that took almost an hour to get them free. They didn't go into too much detail.

The next week we started hearing rumors about what happened when the rescue team from fire and rescue showed up. Strangely enough Diane's husband worked as a volunteer and was one of those who responded.

Gina was accusing Travis of planning the entire thing,

Diane and her husband were already having marriage problems and having a giant black cock pulled out of her ass by another of the crew didn't help matters.

It took nearly an hour to get both women out of the stocks, and one of the crew discovered in the process of dismantling the stocks that there was a hidden mechanism built into the frame but no one put the pieces together.