"Detective Miller, I'm special agent Blanc, this is Dr. Cohen."
The seasoned detective looked around to what he couldn't quite pin down as either a military installation or laboratory facility of some kind. The ceilings were so tall he gathered they could easily accommodate three to four commercial airliners stacked on top of one another. It was hard for him to imagine that this was only the first of six levels of basement under the federal building -- at least according to the buttons on the elevator he took down.
"Thank you Mr. Blanc. Please don't get me wrong, I know the stereotypes about cops, and the NYPD in particular. I'm not here to throw any kind of fit, but I have to admit that when the feds get involved, it's usually clearer why a matter is outside our jurisdiction."
Dr. Cohen looked away, not knowing just how much agent Blanc would let the detective in on, but knowing that that information had no job coming out of his mouth.
Agent Blanc smiled and gave the detective a friendly pat on the shoulder as his hand remained there,
"Call me Eric. There's really no need for all this pretentious role-play formality bullshit."
"I appreciate that. You can call me John,"
he said as he moved a bit forward until Eric's hand was off his shoulder. John had no problem showing some token friendliness, but he wasn't here to make friends.
"Where is the girl?"
John asked. Eric let out a subtle sigh under his breath as John began to brace himself for what he expected to be a pre-recorded message Eric was about to parrot to him.
"She's under observation. Dr. Cohen is her treating physician, and he can tell you that she's doing much better now."
John was short-lived confusion was quickly overshadowed by his suspicions. After spending eight years in homicide, he had a keen sense for bullshit.
"Look, Eric, she's a suspect. Right now, she's our only suspect in an ongoing murder investigation. As far as I know, the responding officers didn't say anything about her having any kind of medical issue or even being in any kind of emotional distress. So, unless you tell me she's some kind of terrorist or threat to national security, or there's something else here that I'm not seeing, you guys have no reason to be holding her."
Eric recognized that look in John's eyes; it was the look of someone serious about his job and simultaneously pissed off about being lied to. Eric knew his next reaction was a split-second speed round of chess. One wrong move and nothing was stopping John from waking up a judge in the middle of the night asking for an emergency
habeus corpus
petition, or worse, getting the press involved.
Dr. Cohen stepped forward,
"I think detective Miller is anxious about the clock ticking."
John respected Dr. Cohen's understanding of homicide cases. The first 48 hours were absolutely critical to any homicide investigation. After that time, the chances of closing a case dropped by more than half.
"Thank you Dr. Cohen. Exactly! So, unless you have some good reason to hold my only suspect in captivity while my clock keeps ticking, I'm going to have to ask you to turn her back over to us."
Eric knew his game of mental chess with John was going poorly. He found himself in quite a difficult position. Letting John know what was really going on had now become inevitable; the best Eric could do now was to have John agree to keep what he would find out private.
"Dr. Cohen, why don't you explain?"
Eric sighed in defeat as he gave license for the good doctor to speak.
Dr. Cohen clicked on a remote he had inside the pocket of his long white lab coat. What initially appeared as a white padded wall began to retract upwards, exposing a thick plexi-glass cell. As the wall retracted further, John noticed the young girl sitting on a cheap sterile white chair -- her arms and long smooth black hair covering her face as it faced down onto the stainless steel table.
"If you think you feel upset over all this, I can assure you that your colleagues over at forensics were almost at arms when we took her husband's body away. The girl may look normal, or ordinary, but after determining her husband's cause of death, it became clear pretty quickly that this wasn't just another homicide case."
John's confusion remained in place this time as his mind searched frantically throughout his eight years of experience to make some sense of what Dr. Cohen was telling him. Maybe, he thought, the good doctor was approaching his case as a medical doctor, and not as a homicide investigator.
"A cardinal rule of any investigative work is to never speculate and look for answers first. You have to keep an open mind, exhaust all possibilities, and only then can you put the puzzle pieces together to arrive at whatever conclusion they support. There's still a lot we need to do in this investigation, it's way too early to be coming to any kind of conclusions."
Dr. Cohen let out a comforting and understanding smile as he looked down to a manila folder filled with neatly organized papers.
"Unfortunately detective, with the kind of work we do here, we don't have the luxury of letting investigations drag on forever. Don't misunderstand me. That doesn't mean we do a shoddy job. That just means we do better work in NASCAR time."
Dr. Cohen began flipping through several pages until he firmly secured any remaining loose pages back.
"Lola Sorrenti, 18 years old, studying psychology, works at a doctor's office, and married her high school sweetheart. Greg Sorrenti, 19 years old, no higher education, and works in construction. His phone, e-mail, and Facebook accounts all flooded with messages and pictures from other women, almost all of whom he was sexually involved with during his relationship with Lola."
"Fantastic work doctor,"
John said with an exaggerated sarcastic tone in his voice, "
You saved us about 2 hours of waiting until a judge signed a warrant for us to go through that information. So she had motive to kill him. That still doesn't explain how he died, or if 'she' was even the one who killed him. There was no sign of blood on the scene."
Dr. Cohen smiled at the detective, admiring his zeal to get to the bottom of what he still believed to be just another routine homicide case.
"All in due time detective,"
Dr. Cohen flipped over to the next page on his chart.
"An autopsy of the victim's body showed that he was in excellent health. 5'11", 218lbs., muscular, nearly perfect cardio-vascular health, except for the huge tear through the right ventricle of his heart. The penis contained recent ejaculate inside the shaft, and traces of the victim's sperm and Mrs. Sorrenti's DNA on the outside. The consensus is that the cause of the victim's death was a massive heart-attack he suffered while having sex with his wife."
"Wait a second,"
John paused as he became visibly angry. He held his falling head up with one hand as he slowly paced and sighed.
"After all this time, you're trying to tell me that we don't even have a homicide here? If that's the case, then why are you guys holding . . . ,"
Dr. Cohen politely cut John off.
"Oh no, there's no doubt in my mind that the victim was murdered. Greg's toxicology report showed three drugs in his system, neither of which he was on according to his medical records: Agenerase, Sporanox, and Viagra. Coincidentally, the doctor's office Lola worked at had free samples of each medication, which Lola had access to. Each medication alone carries the risk of bringing about a heart-attack. The drug-drug interaction of combining all three together creates a serious risk of causing a heart-attack, even in a young male with excellent cardio-vascular health."
John quickly put all the pieces of the puzzle together.
"So, the victim never had a prescription for any of these medications. He also didn't need any of them, because he had excellent cardio-vascular health." "Nearly in perfect condition,"
Dr. Cohen added.
"Yes,"
John continued,
"So, we have motive, access to the drugs found in his system, the cause of death . . . I think based on what we know at this point, there's probable cause to put her under arrest for her husband's murder."
Eric looked at the good doctor as he shook his head up and down slowly,
"It's okay, you can tell him."
John looked at both Eric and the doctor wondering what else there was left to know.
"Tell me what? This is open and shut. Why are you still holding her here? Let me inside that room. I'm putting her under arrest and taking her to central booking."
"I'm afraid that's not possible detective,"
John said as he opened his palm, using his whole hand to politely give the good doctor a chance to explain. Dr. Cohen cleared his throat.