Below is my entry for the Halloween 2020 Contest. Not gonna lie, it gets weird.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The party goes well, as far as everyone else is concerned. Halloween potluck, we provide drinks and desserts. I'm the host for the murder mystery, and it goes off without a hitch. Ellie is my gracious co-host, and everyone raves about the time they're having. Once the murder is solved, no one wants to leave, so we turn on a movie. Only four days from Halloween, so we go with a horror movie, of course. No one remarks about Ellie and I sitting on opposite sides of the room. Once the title screen comes up, I move to the kitchen to get a jumpstart on the dishes.
I'm not really close to anyone here, these are mostly neighbors and acquaintances. A few friends we've kept in touch with since college. Closer really to Ellie than myself. I knock out the bulk of the dishes, try to stay quiet. I head back into the living room just in time to see Ellie cuddle back into Avery as something jumps out on the screen. He doesn't react. She shoots me a look of guilt and and something else. Accusal? She moves away from him a moment later. I settle back into my chair in the opposite corner. Everyone laughs and screams at the appropriate times, and the movie ends shortly after 11.
We say our goodbyes, everyone thanking us for hosting, praising the murder mystery, saying it should become a tradition. It's all smiles and hugs. Then the door closes, and the silence drops between Ellie and I like an axe. We stand on opposite sides of the foyer, my hands in my pockets and her arms crossed tight against her chest.
"Thanks for cleaning the kitchen," she says. "I'll finish it in the morning."
"No worries," I reply. "I'll finish it up right now."
She's already walking towards the stairs. "Thanks. I'm heading to bed."
There's not much left to do in the kitchen. As I finish up the final dishes, I think over my situation, and how the hell it got to this point. Ellie and I both 29, met in college, married just under three years. Got jobs right after graduation, have risen fairly quickly in each. Good incomes, nice house, no kids yet. Enough friends to keep us busy on the weekends. On paper, we look perfect.
So what the hell is wrong with us? I can't say how long it's been going on. I wouldn't say our marriage is on the rocks. We come home from work too tired to do much more than watch tv, and we can go days without much more than exchanging pleasantries, not breaking the surface. Sex? Once a week if we're lucky. Not that long ago we couldn't go more than a few hours without getting under each other's clothes, now approaching sex seems like a chore. Seems like I have to beg her for it, and nothing makes me feel lower. I hate it. I hate where we are.
But I adore her.
With where we are though, I just don't feel like I know what to say, know what to do. I finish up the kitchen, turn on the dishwasher. Lean back against the counter, listen to the machine hum.
Maybe it's simple. Maybe all I have to do is go up there, take her face in my hands, kiss her like I used. Tell her how much I love her. Make love to her, fall asleep in each other's arms. Tell her I love her until my voice goes hoarse. Feel her skin beneath my touch.
I know it won't work out like it is in my head, but I like this plan, feel good about it. I'm ready to make this marriage better. I hear the tv on, I'm ready to turn it off and sweep her off her feet with my love. I go through the bedroom door, my heart swelling.
Ellie's asleep.
Some trash reality show is on, she's asleep. I get it, it's late. But damn. I was ready, I was so ready, to make things right. I still want to. But I'm frustrated, and I feed that frustration willfully. I think of the look she gave me tonight with Avery, I think of all the unspoken words between us.
I look at her phone. We trust each other, have never gone through each other's devices looking for something untoward. We know each other's passwords. I think again of her snuggling against Avery. He's a good guy, we met him back in college. I invited him into our friend group, but in recent years him and Ellie seem to have gotten on better. Tonight, I cannot rest until I know for sure. I walk to her bed stand, pick up her phone, enter the passcode. Go to her messages. A conversation with Avery is her most recent.
My stomach drops. From tonight:
Avery: Thanks for a great party! Great seeing you guys!
Ellie: Thank you soo much for coming. See you again soon!
That was... innocuous. I keep scrolling. I find nothing. From the looks of these messages, they're friends and nothing more. They don't even text that much. I feel a mix of relief and foolishness.
"What are you doing?" Ellie asks, looking up at me in confusion. I stand motionless over her, her phone in one hand. She sits up.
"Are you going through my phone?" She rubs her face. Squints against the bright light. My face has already given away my guilt, so I confess.
"Yes."
"Why?"