I was so excited I nearly felt sick. Tonight, for the first time, I was going to watch my girlfriend play with another man's penis. An older man. My mind was racing the entire drive there, and we didn't speak a word to each other.
We met Michael at Paul's Steak House in Newark. My girlfriend and I had agreed it would be best to travel at least two hours away to minimize the chances of involving anyone we or our families knew and, knowing we were poor college students, Michael offered to pay for a nice dinner.
He was already at our table when we arrived. He was dressed in a tailored suit and he greeted us with a firm handshake. For a man in his fifties, he wasn't very grey.
"Brian, Kaylee, it's good to meet you. I'm Michael. Shall we get something to eat while we get to know each other?"
The truth was that I was so excited that I wasn't hungry, but I didn't want to say no. I was hoping Michael would take the lead in the conversation - how do you talk about sex with a stranger you just met? -- but he seemed as nervous as I was. The three of us ordered appetizers and I talked about the menu simply to keep the awkward silence from growing. Kaylee obsessively sipped her water and nodded in agreement at every trivial thing Michael and I said about the food. I wracked my brain for a way to break the ice. Finally, Kaylee asked Michael about his family.
"My son and daughter are both out of the house now," he said. "My son graduated from Fordham and my daughter is going to school out west. Besides that, I've been divorced for years. Never remarried. When my daughter went to college that's when I started to dip my toes back in."
"You mean, into cuckolding?" Kaylee asked.
"Yeah, well, being a bull for couples. I was really into it when I was a bit older than you two, especially when I was doing my MBA. I dialed it back when my career picked up and I had my family. I did meet my wife at a swinger club though. In retrospect... I think might have been a bad idea. Having the same kinks doesn't necessarily mean you're compatible in other ways."
I'll admit that I had stalked Michael online before arranging today's meeting. He didn't do much to hide his online presence, and although there was no information about his kinky activities to be found (at least, not by name), I did find plenty of details about his personal life. I found the advertising agency he worked for. His name also appeared in a Fortune article about white collar crime, but a quick Googling didn't return any arrest records. I'd thought about paying for a background check but decided that I was being paranoid and that it might freak him out. I'd also learned that he was 51 years old and that his daughter was a year older than us and a junior at Arizona State.
"Well, water under the bridge!" he said, stretching his arms and sliding down his seat. "What about you two? You don't look like you can have been in the lifestyle very long."
"No!" we both said. "In fact, this will be our first time bringing in someone new."
"Well! I'm honored. Like I said, I'm just getting back into the swing of things too. You'll only be my third couple since I've become an empty-nester. I still get butterflies like it's the first time. Of course, sleeping with new people makes it so exciting!"
"I'm sure sleeping with college co-eds makes it exciting too," Kaylee said with a wry smile.
Michael blushed. "Well, I can't deny that. In fact, my other two couples are also college students. I suppose you could say I'm going on a college tour."
This was actually how I had learned about Michael. I'd read someone's post on Reddit called "Watching my girlfriend bounce on dad dick" and I reached out to the poster, who gave Michael a rave review and put me in touch with him.
None of us were eating our food, and Michael asked for the check. He had offered to pay for the hotel too, but I had gone ahead and booked it myself. Felt safer that way, I don't know why. It wasn't far, and we went up to our room together.
Once in the room, Michael took off his shoes and jacket and sat down on the bed. Kaylee sat down next to him. "Hello," she said, beaming. Her dimples appeared when she smiled. They were undoubtedly one of her cutest features.
Michael smiled back. Then, without a word, he gently brushed back her hair, leaned in and began kissing her neck. I saw Kaylee's arms break out in goosebumps and she took a big breath, tilted her head slightly back and closed her eyes. While one hand held back her hair, his other hand went up her shirt and began feeling her breasts. He discovered that she wasn't wearing a bra, and that her breasts were round and fuller than he had expected. He took turns holding each of them as he kissed Kaylee. He gave them a squeeze with both hands before pulling her shirt over her head. With her top now off, Kaylee moved to sit on top of him, straddling him with her legs, and gave him a deep kiss.
"Here, hold on," Michael said as he pulled her closer and slid to the edge of the bed. With her arms wrapped around his neck, Michael grabbed Kaylee and stood up, lifting her up with him and cradled her by her butt, standing with a wide stance and knees slightly bent. He rotated and slowly laid her down on the bed.
"You don't skip leg day!" she said.
"Back up on the bed a bit, okay? Is it okay if I suck on your tits?" Michael asked.
"Of course!"
Michael laid down next to Kaylee and began to kiss and suck on her left nipple, caressing her right nipple with his free hand. Kaylee closed her eyes and said "that feels nice."
He looked up at Kaylee and gave her breast a squeeze. "At dinner, I had no idea you had such perky tits! Back in my day, we called these torpedo tits."
We all laughed. "We still call them that," I said.
"Enjoy them!" he said. "College tits are the best."
"Oh, I don't know about that, but believe me, I do." I felt pride swelling inside of me. It's true, Kaylee's breasts were phenomenal.
Michael got directly on top of Kaylee so he could motorboat her. Lying on top of her, her arms behind her head, both of her breasts cupped in his hands, he began sucking wildly on her nipples. Kaylee's chest was rapidly rising and falling, and when she opened her eyes to smile at me her dimples appeared.
"I love it," she whispered to me. She rested her arms on his broad shoulders and stroked his hair as he continued to nurse at her breasts. Kaylee and I had shared a moment like this many times before. It was a beautiful thing to watch.
Eventually, Michael stood up and lifted Kaylee from the bed.
"Ready to change it up?" he asked.
He moved one of the chairs so that is was facing the end of the bed and told my girlfriend to kneel in between them. He took off his pants and I watched his penis bounce as he removed the rest of his clothes. He sat down on the bed's edge and pulled some pillows behind him for support as he set his feet on the arms of the chair so that his erect penis was directly in front of my girlfriend's face. She instinctually grabbed hold of it with both of her hands.
"Good girl," he whispered. "Not too tight, not to start. I'm going to talk you through it."