This story is part of the Valentine's Day 2019 contest. Be sweet and vote.
I met Olivia Marchand in a coffee shop.
"Excuse me," I said reaching over her at the cream and sugar bar to grab a stirrer. My arm brushed hers as she sprinkled cinnamon onto her cappuccino.
She looked up at me with these unreal royal blue eyes beneath black haired bangs of a bob haircut that skimmed her lovely neck. The tip of her nose and her matte red lips drew me into her beauty. I don't know why she spoke to me. Maybe a bearded, football loving, outdoorsy, beer drinking lug in jeans, a checkered shirt and tie pouring cream into his coffee was a change of pace to this sophisticated-looking five-foot six woman in her late twenties dressed in a pretty green tight-fitting sundress.
Her gaze never left me. As if in a trance, she said, "You have the most amazing blue green eyes."
"Thanks," I replied, glancing away to stir my coffee.
"This may be bold of me, but do you have a girlfriend?"
I'd been on the Tinder-go-round since my last girlfriend and I broke up eight months ago.
"No," I answered, tossing the stirrer in the trash.
"Hmmm," she replied, intrigued by my shyness she mistook for being aloof. "What's your name?"
For a moment, I thought she was setting me up for a robbery, but she was too beautiful to ignore. Settling my gaze upon hers, I was instantly ensnared within those beautiful blue eyes.
"Jordan. Yours?"
"Olivia."
Someone stepped between us and we moved out of their way to a nearby quiet corner where we made a bit of small talk and exchanged numbers before going our separate ways. A day later, I called her, and we went on a movie date to catch a foreign film she wanted to see. When I drove her home, parking in front of her apartment building, we exchanged glances before nervously chuckling.
"I had a good time," she said.
"Me. Too."
Silence.
I murmured, "Well, I guess this is goodnight."
"You want to come in? I cleaned my apartment and changed the sheets. It'd be a shame to waste clean sheets."
Green light! Go boy!
Once inside her small apartment, I settled onto her couch as she fixed me a drink. We chatted and drank, cozying closer to each other before I felt comfortable enough to give her a tender kiss. She returned it with her gentle lips. Our session had begun. Our kisses grew longer and more intense with mashed lips and flicking tongues and before I knew it, I was grinding on top of her with her legs wrapped around my waist until her lips released mine and she breathlessly said, "Let's move into the bedroom."
I got up off her. She stood up and took me by the hand, leading me to her bedroom where a full-size bed took up most of the room. She returned to my arms, answering my hot kisses with an eager, open mouth as my hands roamed over her lithe body. She broke away again to start stripping off her clothes. I did the same and when we stood before each other completely naked, her eyes darted down to my stiff dick standing a full attention. She smiled a lopsided grin. She liked what she saw. The feeling was mutual. Full, tear drop tits with high set nubby nipples in pink quarter sized areolas, a snatched in waist, beautiful toned legs and when she turned to get into bed, she had this sweet ass with cheeks I wanted to slap and grab onto. She was damn near perfect. I crawled into her bed, into her waiting arms, and gave into the thrill of discovering a new female body.
We fucked. The sex: wow. She did this thing where, when I was deep inside her, she ringed the base of my sticky, wet dick with her finger and thumb, squeezing tightly, and held it that way on top of her pussy as I slid in and out of her. Moving in and out of that tight ring felt incredible and I came...hard. I don't care where she learned it or who she practiced it on - as long as she does it with me.
Sometime later, when we were both limp and sloppy wet from orgasms, she rested in the crook of my arm, and happily said, "God, my head hit all four corners."
"What?"
"Well, in my book, if your head hits one corner of the bed, sex is meh. Two corners, it's okay. If I'm face down on a third corner, now we're talking. But four corners is fucking fantastic."
Four days later, when we fucked again, her head hit five corners as we moved clockwise with a corner to spare. When I awoke the next morning with her sleeping beside me, open mouthed and her make-up rubbed off, she looked so sweet and fresh with a smattering of freckles near the bridge of her nose. And when she opened those big blue eyes and grinned a naughty smile before burrowing down into the sheets to take my sex crusted dick into her mouth, I asked myself how did I get so lucky? There's got to be something wrong with her. Something. But for the life of me, I haven't found it. She's smart, funny. She's down for anything. She says she loves my balls; that they fit in her mouth just right. I love how she tongues and bobbles them with her lips until she sucks them into her mouth and looks up all at me all innocent.
Three blissful months later, in the middle of sex, Olivia was sitting naked on top me with my cock all the way up her snatch and my hands on her hips. I pressed my thumb to her dewy clit, rubbed it around and watched her cum. I came soon after, and with jizz oozing between us, I realized I'd never been so exhaustedly happy in my life. Sweaty, huffing and puffing as I cooled down, 'I love you' slipped out of my mouth.
I opened my eyes, hoping she hadn't heard, but she looked down at me, smiled that mischievous grin of hers, and cooed, "I love you too."
She leaned down and kissed me, pushing her tongue onto mine and I moaned as my arms encircled her to slide her body close to mine. I'm in love with Olivia. She's the woman for me. There's just one thing; she's always unavailable on Friday and Saturday nights. See, Olivia is like a mysterious cat that shows up at your house one day, confident, clean and groomed, stays for a few days and then disappears. I know that she's an assistant editor at a food magazine, but when I try to make dates on Friday and Saturday nights, she's always working. I thought she might be a stripper but she's much too classy for that line of work. I asked where she works but she says she's too embarrassed to tell me.
"Maybe one day, I'll invite you to a show."
I figured she sang at the jazz club on Riverside, but I quit asking for an invite. Let her reveal her secret at her own good time. I'm not going to ruin a good thing. We've been dating for seven months and things are going well. We're sleeping together nearly every night; she at my place or I at hers. I took her to meet my parent at Christmas time where she won over my mother with her cooking after downloading a recipe from her online magazine and baking a pie. Then she charmed my father so much that he took me aside in the kitchen and said, "If you don't marry that girl, I will."
Months went by and after ten months of dating, we finally had our first Friday night date on a chilly Valentine's Day night.
Olivia and I met at eight on a busy street corner in the heart of the city. We strolled arm and arm down the busy city street. I'd made plans for the night but so had she.
"Where are we going?" I asked.