I've got a few ex girlfriends that I still talk with and like a lot of guys I've got more that I don't. Janet was one from the "don't" category. We'd dated for about 4 yrs and now I hadn't spoken to her for almost 6 months. The last thing I'd heard her say was "the only way you could make me happy is to kill yourself"
Ok, I know it sounds a bit harsh but considering about 10 minutes before that she'd caught me fucking her younger sister Kim, I guess I deserved it. The two of them were very similar but still different. They were both about 34B, slim hips and firm cup-able asses but Janet had a sweeter, more innocent look where Kim made you think hot, dirty sex right away.
I'd tried telling Janet that it was a one-time thing, that her sister was the one that seduced me and my final statement that I'd do anything to make her happy was what prompted her last words to me. She'd previous told me more than once that her sister was a bitch and from as far back as she could remember they'd been very competitive. Of course none of that really crossed my mind when her sister popped in that night crying that her boyfriend had broken up with her. We had a few drinks, she calmed down and told me how much of an asshole he'd been, that he'd never been any good in bed, he didn't think she was good looking enough to be seen with him and so on. Of course I fell for it hook line and sinker and when she looked at me and said that she needed to feel like she was sexually attractive and could show me how much I'd been missing by dating her sister instead of her, I ended up fucking her right there on the living room floor - which is where Janet found us. Needless to say Kim & I never went out again because now that she'd broken her sister and I up and proved to herself that she was the better of the two she moved on to new conquests.
I'd had a few more girlfriends since then but I still had strong feelings for Janet and was quite surprised when she called one Saturday night out of the blue. She told me she'd gone out with a few of her friends and her sister was at the same bar - totally drunk. Seems that she was drunk enough to brag to Janet that she had in fact seduced me that night and that it just proved that she was the sexier, better looking one. Janet still wasn't impressed that I'd cheated but wanted to let me know that she'd somewhat forgiven me. We started talking again and after a few conversations I told her I'd loved her before, still had strong feelings for her and if she was willing to give me another chance I'd like to date her again. It took some convincing but she finally agreed to go out with me the following Saturday night.
Thursday night, I got a call from her sister telling me that Janet was just fucking with my mind to get even and not to fall for her supposed change of heart. Kim went on to say that she was sorry that she'd dumped me and would I consider taking her back.