Megan and I had just finished a steamy, sweaty hot fuck in the shower when we realized we weren't alone. Ashley, Megan's sister, had walked into the bathroom and caught us having sex. She probably would have left quietly without saying a word, but before she could leave, we stepped out of the shower and stood before her. We were both completely naked, dripping wet from the shower, and Megan was practically leaking my cum from her snatch. I immediately turned red in embarrassment, not yet ready to handle even more unwanted attention. Megan on the other hand just looked at her sister in fear. It probably had something to do with Ashley's comment.
"Ashley, what the hell are you doing in here?" yelled Megan as she coldly stared at her sister, not attempting to hide her nudity or swollen pussy. Ashley was grinning and looking all over, letting her eyes rest from my cock to her sister's moist body. Ashley was wearing just her bikini, so her hard nipples were clearly visible beneath the insignificant strip of cloth.
"I could hear the shower running, but I knocked and came in. I figured it was just you Megan since I didn't think he would take that long of a shower. To my pleasant surprise, you two were loudly and humorously fucking each other. Don't worry, I'll keep the secret of your forbidden fuck, but at a price," Ashley said devilishly, letting her gaze lock onto Megan's eyes. They stared at each other for a while, then Megan finally bounced back to reality and tossed a towel at me and grabbed one for herself.
"This isn't a time for modesty, Megan. I've seen your stud's throbbing dick and I've seen your body arch back in probably one hell of an orgasm. That frosted glass doesn't stop a persistent eye," taunted Ashley. Megan realized the futility and dropped her towel. I never bothered to cover myself with the towel. At this point I wasn't concerned about being seen naked when I had been caught jacking off and having sex within the same hour. My humility threshold had already been broken long ago.
"Fine... what do you want Ashley. I knew you'd be that cold hearted bitch and try to ruin my firs..." she suddenly stopped herself, afraid to admit she just lost her virginity. It was too late, though.
"Your first time!? Ahahaha!" Ashley burst into laughter, almost crouching over from the intensity. Megan pouted in response, but her fear was falling away. She started to stand upright and looked at Ashley with a confident and challenging stare.
"Yea? So what?! I know your first was with that trailer trash jock at school. At least mine cares for me! He cares enough to give me three orgasms!" Megan replied in retaliation. Ashley strained to keep up her appearance of a calm and domineering individual, but her eyes were lit with furious fire.
"Shut the fuck up, Megan! Listen, you two each owe me a favor in turn for not saying a word. We all know if his parents and our parents found about this, they'd fucking freak out. I don't think you two want to spend the rest of summer vacation with no car. Wouldn't that be sad for two college students to get grounded like middle schoolers?" Ashley laughed again as she looked Megan in the eyes, then briefly winked at me and left. Megan and I each let out a sigh of relief, but Megan saw the look of concern on my face.
"Megan, I can't have my parents find out. She might have been joking, but my parents really would punish me somehow for fucking the neighbor girl. They're weird that way. I really can't lose my car!" I moaned in dismay. Megan just gave me a look of sympathy, then a look of frustration.
"What the hell is the matter with you! Both you and Ashley are overreacting! If our parents found out, who gives a shit? We had sex, that's it. They might be disappointed and my Dad might be a little angry and question if you raped me, but that's it," Megan said angrily.
The shock was beginning to wear off and I realized it really wasn't a big deal. Except for the rape part. "Wait, if your Dad does think that, you'll tell him the truth right? That wasn't rape."
"Yea, yea, that definitely was not rape! Rape wouldn't feel that good! Look, Ashley can be a bitch sometimes, but she won't go back on her word. If you're so scared of my Dad, we'll play along," Megan's voice rang with determination. I guess losing her virginity gave her a new sense of confidence.
She walked over and hugged me tightly while passionately kissing me. I can't imagine what she was thinking, but getting caught during the first time must be some sort of system shock. Both of us were still naked and my dick was half hard, so it pushed into her belly. She looked down and said, "Damn, hard again? You could probably do a fucking marathon... literally!" She lightly laughed at her twisted pun. I was starting to calm down, but I still felt concerned about Ashley's plans. Even if Ashley had something to gain by tattling, she agreed to not say anything if we did her favors. Still, part of me wondered if she would play fair. Would she keep this secret over us forever?
Megan and I dressed and finished the rest of the day. Any contact with Ashley was superficially normal, but Ashley did try once or twice to scare us by slipping hints in conversations with her parents. Fortunately, they never caught on, so Ashley just toyed with Megan and me for the evening. Dinner felt like an eternity because Ashley would not shut up. I couldn't eat without choking at random emphasized words. I was really growing to despise Ashley and her cruel tactics.
That night after my parents and neighbors settled into bed, I heard some activity in the room next door. Finally I heard a knock on my door. I opened it and saw Ashley grinning at me, beckoning me to come. I turned around to grab something to wear since I was only in my boxers, but she gestured to not bother. I knew where that was going, so I reluctantly followed her into the bedroom down the hall.
Inside was Megan waiting for us. She was completely naked and kneeling on the floor with her hands tied behind her back. Ashley saw me staring, so she coolly said, "Megan's going to get a special show tonight, but like a real audience, she can't interfere. She gets to sit on the floor and watch the fun, but she won't get any for herself. She also can't say a word or I'll have to dish out some punishments." Megan squinted angrily at that line, but she obeyed by not saying a word.
Ashley spontaneously ripped my boxers off, leaving me completely nude and hard for her to look and mock at. She laughed wickedly and starting rubbing my body while looking at Megan. Ashley then leaned over and whispered into my ear, "I have nothing against you, this is all against Megan. It's revenge for all the times she told my parents about my drinking habits in high school. Just play a long and you'll have a good night."
I was surprised by Ashley's sudden cooperative nature. I thought about tossing Ashley onto the bed and ending her game of revenge, but I had nothing to gain. Besides, if all I had to do was fuck to end the blackmail, there were no negatives besides Megan's feelings. Still, it wasn't like we were going out, so she couldn't blame me too much. I decided to play along.
We both turned and looked at Megan, who returned Ashley's gaze with more angry looks. Ashley began stripping, taking off her pajama top and bottom, revealing her naked body underneath. She kept her bush trimmed in an interesting heart shaped and had a tattoo of her sorority's Greek emblem above her patch. She was a little taller and leaner than Megan, but Ashley was also more athletic and muscular. Ashley head a boob job done for her 21st birthday, so her breasts were large and eternally perky, but definitely fake to the touch. To make a crude comparison, Ashley was more like a porn star while Megan was the girl next door type.
Ashley then looked at her sister sympathetically and said, "well, I suppose you can have a little fun, but under one circumstance: if your fuck buddy agrees to it." Ashley turned her gaze to me and asked, "will you give Megan some pleasure, too?"
"What's the catch?" I asked, instinctively knowing that Ashley didn't do this for free.
"Haha, aren't you a paranoid one! You guessed right, there is a catch. Whatever pleasure I give to Megan must be equally given to you!" It sounded sincere and normal, but Ashley's mildly wicked tone warned me. Regardless, pleasure was pleasure, so it wasn't much of a threat.
"Ok, sure, what the hell. This is your game, Ashley. Do what you want," I said with a lazy tone. I really didn't care anymore, I just wanted to have sex. All this build up was starting to become a strain on my balls.
"Haha, great! You two will love this!" Ashley walked over to her dresser and pulled out a small bag. She reached in a pulled out two bright pink sex toys and some lube. Ashley was grinning the entire time. Megan continued to stare angrily and I just watched in curiosity.
"Now, as you both know, every sorority girl has plenty of these. Today they're going to be your best friends!" I did a double take as I looked at the toys. It finally dawned on me what Ashley was planning. Megan was going to get a vibrator to stimulate her, but that also meant I was getting a toy! I was about to object and say hell no, but Ashley beat me to the punch.
