(Usual Disclaimer Time: Even though this story almost entirely takes place in a high school setting, all the characters in this story are 18 years old or older, and since we're living in the wide wonderful world of porno-land here, where clichΓ©s roam free and things might get a little unrealistic from time to time, please remember it's all in good fun. This story is highly serialized, and though it's not 100% necessary to have read the whole story up until this point to enjoy the content of the chapter, it's definitely advisable to understand some of the ongoing plots.)
(Author's Note: I know it's been a long, hard road to get here, but at last the Christmas arc of SYM comes to an end. Thank you all for your patience in this long, strange arc; going forward I'm aiming to have some less complex arcs so I can get chapters out to you sooner. I'd like to again thank MisterWildCard for acting as a second set of eyes on this chapter and for his honest editing and fantastic suggestions, especially for this chapter that had some language I definitely needed to clear up. Please check out his story, "Brooke's Wild Ride" in Erotic Couplings, as it acts as a canonical side story to Senior Year Memories starring Regan Hills High's favorite blonde cheerleader.)
Previously, on Senior Year Memories: 18-year-old Ryan Collins' quest to do something nice for each of the nineteen women he's had sex with this senior year before Christmas has continued at a swift pace. When Addison Gonzalez called on him to make a sex tape for revenge against her vile ex, Kyle Bowman, Ryan was all too glad to help. His goth girlfriend Josie Wong revealed that she'd be leaving town for a few weeks after Christmas to spend time with a sick family member, but still promised to help Ryan provide cosplayer Mallory Dourif with quality glamour shots. Wanting to make sure he checked Josie off his list before it was too late, Ryan sought out her estranged best friend, emo rocker Mia Roth, and convinced the two to reconnect. Then he had sex with her, because this is that kind of story. Returning home exhausted, Ryan ended his day by exchanging notes through the window with the pretty and mysterious new girl who moved in next door.
With four names remaining on his list for good deeds, will Ryan be able to finish in time for Christmas?
Names Remaining on Ryan's Christmas List: Jade, Kaitlyn, Nadia, Sophie
***
I'd been at this for almost a month now, and with only a few days left to do my last few good deeds before Christmas, I was finally seeing a light at the end of the tunnel. I'd spent a lot of money, run myself ragged and had some pretty amazing sex, but with a few days left and still time to screw something up, I was being careful.
Unfortunately, the words "careful" and "Kaitlyn Pruitt" very rarely went together.
As usual when we were together, Kaitlyn and I were in my room, and we were naked. With her tight cheerleader's body, round ass, DD tits that just begged to be sucked on, and straight, silky black hair, she was a knockout by all definitions. The kind of girl I'd have never dreamed about seriously being with, to be honest. We shouldn't have been in the same room together, let alone naked in the same room together, and yet here we were. If it weren't for that fateful tutoring session back in early September when she tried to take a shortcut out of tutoring by offering me a handjob that escalated into so much more, I'd have had a much different year.
To say I owed her a lot would be an understatement, and on any other day I'd have had her on the bed, screaming with pleasure as I gave her every bit of my ten-inch long, thick cock. She loved it, I loved it, we both looked forward to those moments when we'd get to fuck each others' brains out.
I don't think she expected that today's "tutoring" would involve me handing her a hefty multiple choice test, one that I made her take and then graded in front of her. The Kaitlyn I'd started out this experience with would've probably been flirting with me, distracting me and trying to play to my sympathies to get some extra points. That I'd seen Kaitlyn completely naked and laid bare, that I knew her as well as I knew any of my other best friends these days, let her know that none of these would work.
While I sat and graded her test, she sat on the edge of the bed looking worried.
Utterly gorgeous and lusciously naked, of course, but worried.
When I finally tallied up her results, I set the test down.
"So, I graded your test..." I said, my voice completely even.
Without even waiting for me to finish, she darted up from the bed angrily. "And I failed, right? I fucking failed your goddamn history test because it's bullshit, right? It's bullshit that I'd ever learn anything because I'm not the kind of girl who learns anything, because all I've got is a hot body and some slutty skills and that's all that I'm made for, right? You tried to teach me and I didn't learn shit about your precious American Revolution or Civil War or New Deal because I can't learn! I'm stupid and I suck at this and..."
She trailed off, but I could see that she was on the verge of tears. This wasn't exactly what I intended when I made this test as her Christmas gift, but knowing Kaitlyn this was something that I should've expected. She was bright, but had a tendency to underestimate herself as so many others had. I wanted this test to be hard, but also a way of showing how far we'd come in our tutoring sessions together.
That's why I smiled when I tossed the test onto my bed.
"Ninety-two percent," I said.
Kaitlyn looked down at it. "You're joking."
"I'm not joking," I said.
She looked down at the test, then flipped through the pages looking for all of my red marks to verify that I had indeed graded her down.
"With the exception of one question I gave an extra point on because I fucked it up while writing it (since this is the first test I've ever written), you got ninety-two percent. It's not quite an AP exam, but I tried to make it close, and you need to brush up more on your Cold War history, but if this were a real test, you'd have gotten an A," I said.
She looked down at the test, then back at me, then back down at it so she wouldn't have to look at me. "I bet you're proud of yourself, aren't you? Accomplishing the impossible?"
"I'm more proud of you," I replied. "When Mrs. Lynn first told me I was going to tutor you, I thought you'd be hopeless. When you and I first started for real, I knew you had it in you even when you were fighting me every inch of the way. Somehow, despite your best efforts otherwise, you managed to learn something from our time together other than how many orgasms you were capable of having during a study session."
I meant this last part as a joke, but not the rest of it. Kaitlyn, for all of her arrogance, was someone I knew to have a lot of doubts about herself. The gift of a test where she could show herself how much she truly knew was admittedly one of my stranger ideas, and one that I didn't fully know how she'd take, but it was one I felt a great fit for her.
I watched her look at that test a while longer, formulating the rest of her words before she fully knew what she was going to say.
"Thank you," she whispered. Her eyes, still uncertain, had a brightness to them that I liked. Maybe she still had a hard time believing in herself, but having someone else believe in her was a step in the right direction.
"No problem," I said. Then, deciding to end on a joke, I added, "Now if only we could get your grades up in your other classes..."
"One battle at a time," she said, her voice brightening by the moment as she approached me while I sat in my desk chair.
"I did it. I did it. I can do it. I can do it... FUCK YEAH!" she cheered with greater enthusiasm as her victory sunk in, jumping up and down and twirling around excitedly. Tits bouncing with every step, she jogged over to me, hopping into my lap and kissing me enthusiastically.
"Thank you! Thank you! Thank you!" she exclaimed, shaking her hips slightly in my lap. Her pussy, though not quite wet yet, rubbed against my already very hard cock, and she was groaning at the contact.
I wrapped my arms around her, pulling her close and getting a hold of as much of her large breasts as I could while I kissed her. Kaitlyn cooed, especially as I started to grind up against her more, searching for entry.
"This is good, but we can do better," she said, disentangling herself from my arms and going over to retrieve something from the nightstand.
"Better?" I groaned needily.
"Better," she said, proudly showing off one of my extra bottles of lube.
"Right, better," I amended, understanding her logic entirely.
Kaitlyn knelt between my legs, playfully licking and sucking on my cock for a few seconds before squeezing a large dollop of lube into her hands.
I yelped from the cold as she placed her lubed hands on my cock and started expertly jacking up and down. Though her body and individual skills may not have matched some of the extremes of other girls I'd been with, that Kaitlyn was one of the all-around hottest and most skilled girls I'd been with was close to indisputable. Pure porn star perfection, she handled my cock and balls so perfectly that she'd have been able to get me to do pretty much anything then and there.
"I'm gonna fuck your ass, aren't I?" I asked.
"Uh huh," Kaitlyn confirmed, standing up and turning around, squatting down over my cock. I helped hold her cheeks open wide while she angled herself down onto me, aiming her tight, almost cute little hole onto my massive erection.
"Yeeeeeeessssssssssss," she hissed through gritted teeth as the well-lubed head first met resistance, then broke through. I was far less eloquent than her, grunting loudly with pleasure, for there were few pleasures in life quite like fucking Kaitlyn Pruitt's perfect ass.
"Nobody believes in me, nobody's ever believed in me, nobody but you," she moaned as she took inch after inch of my cock in her tight ass.
"That's not true. People believe in you. People love you," I said.
"But nobody ever thought I was better than I thought I was, they always thought I was who I showed them. Why'd you believe in me?" she asked as she settled completely down on me, rocking her ass back and forth provocatively.
Reaching around her to grab her tits, pulling her in close, I kissed her passionately. "Because earlier this year, you took a chance on me. You believed I could be more than just another background nerd, that I was destined for more. You brought me into this new world I never thought I was worthy of. It seems that the least I can do is give you as many of the same opportunities as I can."
Smiling joyfully, she kissed me. It was a long, sweet kiss, the kind bearing a sweetness that would've seemed completely foreign to Kaitlyn just a matter of months ago. It was a sweet kiss of thanks, of promises for many more adventures to come, of want, of desire, and yes, maybe a little love. It wasn't love like what Josie and I had, but it was still nice all the same; definitely something past normal friendship (as if my cock buried in her ass weren't a clue already).
Bracing her feet on the ground, Kaitlyn started to raise and drop herself on my cock. The look she gave me was one of pure lust, one that promised an encounter that was bound to be epic even by our usual standards. I dropped my hands from her tits to her hips for better support, and though I wanted to get lost in the moment, I couldn't help but mentally check her name off my Christmas list.
X - ADDISON - X
X - BROOKE - X
X - HALEY - X
X - HOPE - X
JADE
X - JOSIE - X
X - KAITLYN - X