No one in my real life would ever consider me slutty. I am shy until you get to know me, rarely take risks, didn't lose my virginity until my 20s, and have never had a one night stand.Β The kind of girl who doesn't text a friend's boyfriend without making it a three-way chat. The kind of girl whose male coworkers apologize for swearing in front of. 5'1 on a tall day.
The thing about shy girls, though, is they can be very slutty for the right person. For someone who puts them at ease.
Last August I had just ended a long-term relationship with the person I thought I'd marry. I was sincerely missing regular sex but lacked any desire for a casual hookup. I reacquainted myself with masturbation (something that was discouraged in my former relationship) and quickly found myself on the naked side of Reddit. I left thirsty comments on pictures of well-endowed men, anonymity emboldening me in a way that would never happen IRL without fearing for my safety. I got a boatload of messages.
On my second day of this honest work, a man we will call "J" DM'ed me. We immediately hit it off with easy banter and great sexual chemistry. He had plenty of pictures up to curb any catfishing fears and they showed he was my type: older than me, much taller than me, dark facial hair, slight self-proclaimed dad bod, big thick veiny cock with a fat pink head, the cutest bubble butt. A total hunk, in the neighbor-next-door kinda way. I learned he was married but sometimes liked talking to women on Reddit.
Here I will say I have always been staunchly opposed to cheating and have never understood the appeal of it. My dad had an affair when I was a kid and it was life altering for him (and me).Β J confided in me early on that he had made a mistake one time with a female friend. Something about that made me feel more comfortable talking to him. Anything we did virtually and anonymously would pale in comparison to an in-person transgression, right? Almost like it wouldn't count. Ever heard of girl math? Well this was slut math, if you will. A very flawed rationalization for behaving badly.
Hearing his confessions paired with my past experiences, I'll admit I became curious...could I talk to this man a few times and understand what motivates a seemingly good person to look outside their happy relationship for sexual gratification? Maybe I could recognize the signs and prevent it from happening to me? Maybe I could help him get out some debauchery so that no other Redd!t encounter was ever hot enough and he could get back on track with his wife? #slutmath and probably also #daddyissues if I am being self aware about my curiosity. God forbid a girl be a scientist.
I've never looked at a married man as a challenge or a conquest. Ick. Instead, for me, there's an ease about being around most married men. When the prospect of a romantic relationship is off the table, I find I can let my guard down and be fully myself. And with J, that was no different. I quickly forgot about my initial intentions and we talked daily about a slew of topics, both NSFW and SFW. He was interesting, funny, patient, positive, unpressured, unwaveringly supportive. For the longest time I only replied to his messages and never initiated conversations so I could tell myself he was pursuing me. He was consistent in his communication but where other men from NSFW Reddit were consistently begging for my nudes, J never asked once. We talked a lot about sexual preferences, roleplayed sexual scenarios, and shared links to hot Reddit posts. We touched ourselves while talking to each other, often. It was a way for me to channel the boundless horniness and lack of intimacy I experienced being newly and unexpectedly single. I may be naive but I truly felt like J wanted the best for me and was quick to respect the boundaries I communicated early on. He wasn't desperate and that was super attractive.