It had been years since I had thought about Cathy. I guess because she was the only one who ever took advantage of me when I was drunk, and she wasn't. Of course, I just drunk and let her take me to bed, then thought better of it the next day. Okay, so maybe my thinking better of it really didn't sink in too deep when I started to remember what had actually happened.
I knew Cathy through my brother, who had dated her younger sister for a few months. She had gone to high school at the next town up the lake from my hometown. Her school was our archrivals in basketball most years. Cathy had also been in their student council, so I had met her a couple of times. Candidly, I had noticed that she was a moderately attractive girl, slender, maybe a little too much so for my tastes. Still, we had never had any serious connection. She was just a girl from the next town up the road, and the sister of my brother's girlfriend.
I also knew that Cathy had dropped out of college that past spring, after only a year. That was surprising since she had been the Salutatorian of her high school class. She was certainly bright, just not right or ready for college I guessed.
From my brother, I also knew that she had hooked up with one of her high school teachers at the end of the summer, just a few months ago, and lost her cherry. I was surprised that she had gone through a year of college, or high school, without having sex with a guy, but I only knew about it because she went off with the teacher, her mother panicked and called every guy she thought Cathy might be with, including me, at 3:00 a.m. Later my brother filled me in since his girlfriend might have suggested that the mom call me.
A few weeks into the school year, Cathy moved to Ithaca and started dropping by my apartment. That should have been okay. She was nineteen, attractive, a good figure, albeit slender, but still shapely, with brown hair, green eyes and in general All-American girlish good looks. Still, something with her just didn't click for me. She was definitely acting interested in me. I just didn't see it going much of anywhere, not even for a tumble in bed. After a couple of weeks her dropping by whenever she felt like it, I started avoiding her. She was just a girl I wasn't that interested in.
Until that night when she just happened to show up at the bar where I was drinking with friends. I guess that I was already three sheets to the wind when Cathy walked in with a friend of hers. She walked straight in, not at all surprised to find us there, sat down next to my roommate, Jim, across the table from me, told the waiter that she needed a glass and would share our pitcher of beer. Cathy didn't say much, at least initially. She finished off a beer, poured another and moved around to my side of the table to sit next to me.
I turned toward her, figuring to be polite at least. She kind of looked at me, kind of tried to look through me for a few seconds, then she said that she knew I wasn't really interested in her, that I had made that clear. I was drunk and wanted to feel good about everything and everybody. I assured her that I thought she was a good person and very attractive. At that moment, she definitely was attractive. She tried some more "poor me" lines, each time I responded with something positive about her.
It worked. In about five minutes, I had leaned in toward her, trying to make some point. That's when she kissed me. Now remember, I was drunk, happy with the world and suddenly here's this girl kissing me, with her hand just as suddenly resting on my thigh, near the top with fingers lightly caressing me. I guess I responded just like most guys.
Twenty minutes later, we were back at my place with her on top of me, stripped to the waist and working my cock out of my jeans. She had really nice tits, small, yet firm with great nipples that simply begged to be licked. I knew that because I had already spent several minutes licking them. And sucking them, and feeling them, and simply enjoying both nipples and their feel under my fingers and tongue.
She stroked my cock. I was a little surprised that she didn't start to suck me. Most girls I knew would start sucking cock. Instead, Cathy just stroked me, clearly enjoying having her fingers wrapped around my cock. When she first saw it, she mumbled something about it being bigger than she thought. A couple of times she leaned over, seemingly ready to take it in her mouth, but nothing, not even a little touch of the tongue on my cock. It seemed like she really didn't know how to suck cock, or just wasn't quite sure if she dared to put it in her mouth.
After a few minutes, I was more than ready to fuck her. I wanted it inside her when I came. I quickly held her around her waist, then shifted around so that she was on her back and I was kneeling between her legs. I took a tit in each hand, then lowered myself onto her body so I could suck one nipple then the other. Cathy started to moan.
After a few minutes sucking her nipples and fondling her tits, I decided it was time to go for home. I raised myself so I could unfasten her jeans. In a few seconds, Cathy was lifting her hips, helping me pull her pants off her hips. As soon as I had her pants off, I dropped them on the floor. I paused for a second, savoring the view. Then I stripped her panties off.
Again, I paused to enjoy Cathy's nakedness. She shifted a little under my gaze, then spread her legs, giving me a perfect view of her pussy. Her pink pussy lips protruded from between her legs, crowned by the triangle of brown hair. I reached my hand out, gently stroking her pussy. I could feel how wet she was. I slipped a finger inside her. Cathy gasped. I slipped another finger inside her. Cathy started to rhythmically pump her hips as I slipped my fingers in and out of her. She moaned softly as I finger fucked her.
In another minute I could tell that Cathy was about to come. Her moans were building toward a crescendo. Her breathing was rapid. A warm, pink flush covered her neck, spreading across her chest above her breasts. Both nipples stood out, erect and flushed a deeper red than her chest. Suddenly, Cathy exploded, writhing, thrusting her hips up and down, pushing against my two fingers shoved deep inside her. I could feel her juices flowing out of her cunt. I started to thrust my fingers in and out again, loving the hot, slick, wet feeling of the juices pouring out of her.
I think that Cathy came twice more in the next few minutes. Maybe it was just one, single long orgasm. Whatever, it was definitely an experience she was enjoying. I could tell that by the moans, the thrashing of her hips, her erect nipples and the flood of juices staining my sheets.
I was still kneeling between her legs, my hard cock sticking up, and so far still not inside Cathy's pussy. I decided it was time to take care of my own satisfaction. First, I wanted a taste of that delightful pussy I was finger fucking.
I spread Cathy's legs, shifting forward a little. I leaned forward. Cathy still had her eyes closed, trying to catch her breath after her last orgasm. I spread her pussy lips open with two fingers, relishing the sight of the dark, little opening I could see between her wet, swollen pink lips. I leaned into Cathy's cunt and licked from that opening up over her clit.
Cathy startled, exclaiming, "Wait, what are you doing?"
I lifted my head from her pussy and looked at her.
"I'm going to eat you."
"What! No one has ever done that! I'm not sure about it!"
I sat up a little, totally surprised that a girl, any girl that was already naked and who had already came several times would have any objection to getting eaten before getting fucked. Or after getting fucked for that matter. I slipped my fingers inside Cathy again as I looked at her.
"Relax. I promise you will really enjoy it! Really!"
"I, I, I, uh, no one's ever done that to me! I mean, I never thought you would do that!"
"Okay, I understand."
Some place I read that there are either no lies in sex, or nothing but lies. I don't remember which it was. This was definitely the latter of the two. I didn't understand, not at all. My experience was that girls liked getting oral sex as much as guys like getting oral sex, and guys definitely loved getting oral sex.
