As a male teacher in the Midwest, I am quite used to the innocent, gossipy, sometimes meddling nature of my female colleagues. Having been raised by a strong woman myself, I do not feel threatened by smart women, and I'm often surprised by those who are. Being one of only five men in my entire middle school has made me feel like something of a rarity. Other than Robert, who is nearing retirement, us male teachers are viewed with peculiar curiosity, like a sketchy science project, by the women. As one of only two single teachers, their interest in me has ranged from perfunctory coworker to savage flirting to friendship to those relationships where I get asked advice as to what their mate might be thinking. I try my best to always act professionally. I take my job as an educator seriously.
My name is Alex Stator. I'm twenty-nine years old and recently divorced. My ex-wife and I were together for seven years, married for five. We met in college, both education majors before she switched to psychology. Our marriage was good the first few years. Laney went into social work then private therapy. With my summers off we were able to go on some amazing vacations to Australia and Japan.
The last year we were together, I felt a shift. Suddenly, we were arguing more. We'd always argued, who doesn't? But this was different. Once she started making more money in therapy, she wanted me to pursue a more lucrative career. Public educators get paid more than private ones, but still not in the realm of what a "normal" job would be for my age. But I was happy with my career choice, and felt I was doing important work, so I held my ground. Our arguments grew more cutting. And afterward, we'd be cold and distant to each other for days. In the past, we'd have sex after fighting and ultimately feel closer together. Our isolation had become more frequent.
As in a lot of relationships, there was no one thing that precipitated to its demise. We just sort of slowly ground to a halt. Two years before our divorce, Laney asked me for an open relationship. I didn't really want to, but I didn't want to lose her. So we tried it. I guess I was willing to try anything. I got the suspicion that she already had someone in mind because she had a date the very next week, though it's much easier for women, I think. I went on a few dates myself with women I met through an app geared towards polyamorous connections, but my heart just wasn't in it. Every time I saw Laney getting ready to go meet some guy she was in such a good mood, like I hadn't seen her in years. It didn't help that she also looked great. A petite brunette with an athletic body and attractive face, Laney never really dressed sexy to go out until we opened our marriage.
I never asked to know any details of her other men. I didn't want to know. It would drive me crazy. I tried to focus on myself. After a few flings, I was left unsatisfied. I told Laney about my feelings. She was mostly receptive, but somehow made me feel like it was all my fault. After a few glasses of wine one night, she suggested that we try a threesome. She said she'd always dreamt of two men making love to her at the same time. It would be a great test for our relationship. The very thought made me sick to my stomach. It wasn't just the
being-naked-with-another-guy
part. Even watching her leave for dates made me sick to my stomach. What bothered me the most is I felt like she could see this was tearing me apart and wanted to push me further. In a way it felt like punishment for not being the person she wanted me to be.
I read somewhere that if something scares you, you should do it. So in the end, I agreed to a threesome. We set some boundaries. The other guy could not be one of my friends. Either one of us could stop the sexual activity at any point. The other and myself would both wear condoms. We agreed that Laney would be the "leader" of the threesome, and so do most of the initiating contact and activity. To keep things neutral, we would meet at a hotel. The other guy was not allowed to cum on her face. I know all of this sounds businesslike, but I wanted to make sure that everyone was protected, especially myself.
My wife found somebody rather quickly. We met him at a bar. I admit I was standoffish, but the dude and my wife clicked right away. The three of us had a few drinks to loosened up.
"Okay, boys. Let's do this," Laney said, slamming a shot.
They both stood up to go.
"What?" I asked. This was only our first meeting. "You mean another time, right?"
Laney smirked. "I already got us a room next door. Let's go." She put her arm around the other guy, Brad or Chad or something. "I'm ready."
"Yeah, she's ready, man. It'll be cool."
I didn't really want to, but I did want to try a new experience, and I knew if I didn't go along it would be an issue later. I slammed a shot myself. "Ok, fine."
Things started awkwardly. They were obviously both really into each other, and I felt like the third wheel. I suggested we keep the lights off. As we progressed, I relaxed a little. We started out on the couch. Laney sat between us and took turns kissing us, growing more passionate with each inning. I started rubbing her leg, then her breast. I figured my territory would be my side and Brad's his.
Laney became increasingly aggressive. I'd never seen her like this before. As uncomfortable as I was, I was sort of glad to see her having a sexual awakening. It was a chance to see her in a different light. As my eyes adjusted to the dark of the room, I saw a certain mad brilliance in her eyes that I hadn't in some time. Despite my thoughts working overtime, I got hard.
Laney instructed Chad and I to stand on either side of her while she knelt between us taking turns sucking and stroking. Each time she went for another round, she went deeper and faster until she was gagging and spitting on our cocks bottoming out on the back of her throat. I couldn't even remember the last time she'd given me a blowjob.
"Okay boys, your turn to work," she said, after we were sufficiently hard enough.
The three of us moved over to the bed. First, I massaged her breasts while Brad ate her out. Laney writhed and moaned. After a while, Chad went to fuck her and I had to remind him to suit up. He did, and started fucking her while Laney teabagged me. Laney flipped over and he fucked her from behind while she blew me.
I wasn't having the best time, exactly, but Laney seemed thrilled. So it put me at ease, somewhat, to know that she was being pleased. ChadBrad was a similar build to me. And our dicks were about the same size. Silly, childish, I know, but it mattered to me that this guy wasn't some super hung, buff dude. Laney had always been an attractive woman. Wavy brunette hair, slim figure, nice face, good ass. As BradChad thrusted, her smallish tits swayed. I reached down and squeezed them while she worked my length with her mouth.
Things were going well until they weren't. Due to my tension, I was sure that I wasn't going to cum first. Another inane triumph, but one I wanted to win. But it didn't matter. Brad pulled out and started to put his dick in her ass. I also noticed that he'd somehow managed to take his condom off.
"Whoa, whoa, what the fuck?" I said.
"Take my ass, Brad," Laney demanded. "Stick it in."
I retracted. "Wait," I said. First, I addressed Laney. "We didn't talk about this. We didn't go over anal." She'd never expressed any interest before, so I didn't even think it was on the table. I knew this was semantics, but I felt like I'd gone out of my way to be accommodating, now it was my turn for some consideration. Now I spoke to Brad, "And
you
are supposed to be wearing a rubber."
"Chill out, man. It fell off."
"They don't fall off. You took it off."
"So what?"
"So it's part of the rules," I said. "Not to mention we weren't even supposed to be doing this tonight."
Laney was visibly irritated, having been taken out of the moment. One minute she was getting pounded from both ends. Now she was in the middle of an argument. "It's not a big deal," she said.
"It is to me," I said. Suffice it to say, my hard-on had softened a considerable degree. "That's it. We're done. I'm calling it."
"Dude, like she said, it's not a big deal. We've done it before," BradChad said.
His words stopped me like a punch. My stomach dropped. This was allegedly the first time we'd met. Laney had told me that she'd just found him on one of her apps. They were even acting like this was the first meeting in the bar downstairs. "What?"
Laney was still on all fours, looking like she hoped we could just keep going. She sat back. "Alex, honey. We, Brad and I-"
"We're done here. Get your clothes on. That's it." I knew we had an open relationship. I knew we were trying something new, at least, something new for me. But all I wanted was some consideration, some honesty. I felt betrayed, taken advantage of. Before I was uncomfortable, now I was outright repulsed. "We said from the beginning that any one of us could end this thing. I'm ending it. Right now."
"No way, man," Brad said.
"Stay out of this, asshole," I replied.
"Maybe you should just leave, then," he said.
I was filled with rage. I'd been pushed past my point. I try to be even-keeled about things, but I'd had enough. I'm not a violent person. I'm not into conflict, but I felt the heat in my face move to my fists. I started toward Brad, ready to lay him out. Laney jumped in between us.
"Alex, stop it," she said. She put her hands on my chest. "Honey, you're getting all worked up."
"And why do you think that is? You lied to me. You lied about tonight. You lied about this guy."
It was absurd that we were all standing there naked. Suddenly, I felt very conscious of myself and grabbed my boxer shorts and put them on.
"Let's just have some fun," Laney said, in an attempt to salvage the passion. But I was past the point of no return. I couldn't get hard now if I wanted. No one else made any attempt to dress, which only amplified my anger.
"I think we should just go home," I said. "This wasn't how this was supposed to go. I just want us to go home now." I put on my pants and shirt.
Laney and Brad looked at each other, then back to me. "You're stressed. Why don't you just go home and relax," she said.
"What about you?" I don't even know why I asked. At the time, I thought maybe I'd heard her wrong. "Let's get your stuff."
Brad was still stroking himself to stay hard.
"I think I'm going to stay," Laney said.
I was upset, also heartbroken. As I said, our relationship had been on a downward spiral for a while, but this made me feel both unlovable and inadequate. I tried my best to stay calm. The writing was on the wall. I needed to get out of there before I did anything I'd later regret. I picked up my shoes.
Brad started, "Hey man, why don't you-"
I couldn't take it anymore. I shoved him into the wall,