We were sophomores in college, but were both dating other people at the time. Katie and I had gone to a fraternity party but left around 1:00 AM because she had to work in the morning at the school cafeteria starting at six a.m. As we were leaving the party, she asked me if I could drive her to work in the morning. Although we had never explored it, there was definitely a sexual tension between the two of us and I lusted after Katie day and night. So needless to say, her wish was my command; driving her would be no problem at all.
She was your average looking white girl from New Jersey; 5'3" in height, a slim build with small breasts (probably an A cup) and a cute little ass. Long brown hair and a cute nose turned heads, but it was her personality that really got to me. She was outgoing, fun and supremely confident in herself as a woman. Basically, she was the most sensual person I knew.
We walked back from the party with a nice buzz, oblivious to the freezing Pennsylvania temperatures. Katie had managed to snag a large 3-person dorm room but only shared it with one other girl who spent most of her time at her boyfriend's off-campus apartment. Katie's palatial digs were the envy of all of her friends.
As we walked into the all-girl dorm, she double checked the bathroom was clear so that I could use the bathroom and get rid of some of that watered down frat beer. I came back to her room and fell into the bottom bed of one of the bunks. I had a nice buzz going, but had not passed out yet. When Katie got back from the bathroom, she must have thought I passed out and took her shirt off just a few feet from me. Being modest, she turned away when doing this but my heart still quickened its pace as I saw her sexy form through mostly closed eyes. Next, she bent over to take off her pants and the cutest little butterfly tattoo was revealed low on her hip. My God, I thought, she is the epitome of sexy.
Flash forward six years
Katie and I were the only two from our group of college friends that work in New York City. Now in our mid-20s, we regularly meet up for after-work cocktails. But just as that cold night several years ago, we always were seeing other people.
Knowing that we were both going to get engaged in the near future, and with a desire for Katie that burned with intense heat, I finally built up the courage (with the help of several scotches) to tell Katie of my intense crush on her.
At a local bar right near our places of employment, the crowd buzzed with the normal Thursday night excitement. After a few drinks, I leaned over to Katie and told her there was something I needed to get off of my chest.
"Sure, you know you can tell me anything." she said. I took a sip of my Johnnie Walker Black and a deep breath.
"Since the day I met you, I've been madly in love with you. I was the one that sent you the anonymous love letter during our junior year."
There, I blurted it out, off my chest. She sat there stunned, obviously piecing what I had just said with my actions and the anonymous letter, now five years old.
"I don't know what to say," I told her about my massive crush on her and how I think about that cold night all the time.
Still stunned, she said that she had similar feelings but was frustrated that we had always been seeing other people.
With that, I leaned in and said "Before either of us gets married, I want you. I booked us a room at the W hotel in Times Square tonight."
Now even more stunned, Katie didn't know what to do. I leaned in and our lips connected for a sensual, electric kiss that had been years in the making.