The following is a work of fiction. All characters participating in sexual activities are over 18. Any resemblance to real life persons is merely coincidental.
This story is part of a series and it is advised to read the story from the beginning as each chapter continues directly from the last. This story is split between the different perspectives of his and hers. To get the full story it is suggested to read both sides.
The Nosey Neighbor - His Story
By: VanillaUnicorn
After some restless sleep, Paul finally woke to check the time. It was already 10 in the morning. He got up and got a shower before heading downstairs to start his day. He put some coffee on, needing an energy pick me up. He just finished up his first cup when he saw a shadow by the sliding glass door leading out to his backyard.
Opening up the door, he saw a startled Emily frantically looking for something. He asked her if everything was alright. She was clearly embarrassed by something as her face was bright red. She seemed to look around before telling him, "Umm last night when I was here, I uh, I uh forgot my things. I swore I left them right here but they are gone."
Paul tells her, "I took your stuff inside so they wouldn't get lost or so no one would steal 'em. I was going to drop them off when I was done with my coffee actually. I figured you hadn't realized you left them here and probably needed your purse at least but since you are here why don't you come on in and grab 'em."
Emily had a look of relief on her face as she followed Paul into the house. Paul eyed the girl. She was visibly deep in thought about something. He didn't want to scare her but when he touched her hand it made her jump.
"About last night i'm sorry if I seemed threatening when I caught you in the pool. I shouldn't have grabbed you like that and i'm sorry you were forced to watch that video." Paul tells her.
She looked at him for a minute and then grabbed up her stuff and started to walk out. Before she reached the door she stopped and like a blur she was up next to him and pressing her lips to his. He quickly kissed her back, before he could put his arms around her she was gone and out the door. He didn't want the kiss to stop and he thought maybe he had done something wrong.
The rest of the day blew by. Paul still hadn't finished up the fence like he had planned and it needed paint badly. Instead he just sat around trying to get Emily out of his head. He didn't know what it was about her but ever since she came into the neighborhood, she was all he could think about. He knew she was connected to the Mitchells somehow but he wasn't sure how other than he had seen her kiss the Mitchells' son. He didn't see a ring on Emily's hand so that meant they weren't married yet but she had kissed him so he was feeling conflicted.
As night crept up, a small knock came to the glass of the back door. Paul got up to check it, no one was there. Looking down there was a small box. He grabbed it and took it inside. Using a box cutter, he cut it open. Inside was a note on the top and below that was what appeared to be the same pair of panties Emily had left the night before. He looked at the note and it read:
Dear Paul,
I'm so sorry about what happened last night. I know I should've asked before just coming over and using your pool like that. I totally freaked when you caught me and I thought the worst. I thought you were going to cause me some form of harm. That couldn't have been farther from the truth though, under the circumstances you were a gentleman. I don't know what I was thinking turning on your tv like that, I had no idea what I was about to see. I saw the blue light coming from the dvd player and the curiosity got the best of me and turned it on I guess. I don't know who that woman is, if it was your wife or partner but I know she's a very lucky woman. I also have to confess that I spied on you a few times over the last few weeks and there is no excuse for that. I can understand if you are angry about it. If you want to punish me for it, in the box is the pair of panties I left there last night. You can show those to Brent as proof that i've been unfaithful to him. I don't know what else to say that would make what I did alright but I am truly sorry.
Emily
P.S. I wore the panties all day today so they should be proof enough for Brent.
Paul set the letter down and grabbed the panties out of the box. The scent on them was indeed stronger than they had been from the previous night. Her sweet smelling pussy was evident on the material and Paul's cock rose in his shorts. He tossed the box in the recycling bin and took the letter and panties with him up to his bedroom. He settled in on the bed, her panties still in his hand smelling them as he stroked himself.
He thought back to her conversation with her friend, did she really fall in love with him he thought. He regretted not writing down her phone number when he had her phone open but knew he would then have to justify how he got it and she would know he looked through her phone. 'What else had she had on the phone' he thought. Did she have naked pictures of herself on there?
"God just imagine if she did. Seeing her naked would be too much. I mean I saw most of it under that white suit but I bet it looks even better without anything on. I'm stupid, I should've looked." Paul said out loud to himself as his hand was becoming a blur as it rapidly stroked his painfully hard cock as he thought about his beautiful plump visitor.
She mentioned in the letter that she had spied on him and that got his mind turning. He was curious what she meant by that. She seemed to enjoy what she saw on the video that he carelessly left there for her to turn on. Of course he hadn't been expecting her to turn the television on either. He just thought she would stay there quietly while he went to get her a towel.
His brain started to play out every possible scenario and how it ended up like it had. Her conversations with her friend had been so graphic and mostly about him. What other conversations had she had with others about him. He drifted off to sleep after masturbating to release, hoping he might find her in his dreams.
Paul woke the next morning with Emily still fresh in his mind. Grabbing the letter she had sent he went through it again and again. The letter almost confirmed his suspicions of her being with the neighbor kid Brent but what she was tempting him to do wasn't something he would ever consider. He barely knew the kid so why would he go out of his way to help the kid out once his girlfriend had kind of cheated with him.
Laying next to him on the bed was the soiled panties almost calling out to him to pick them up again. He thought about it but he knew if he did he'd spend the morning jacking off to the delightful smell that was contained on the article of clothing. Forcing himself out of bed, he went to find a decent sized nearly empty wooden box that his father had given him. It was made to hold cigars but Paul didn't smoke and he always wondered why his father gave it to him in the first place.
Lifting the lid on the box, Paul looked inside and saw the collection of Polaroid pictures along with a few souvenirs he had taken from the different women he dated throughout his life. Most of the items inside the box belonged to Lynn but there were at least one or two things from each of the women he'd been with. While that number wasn't more than you could count on both hands, it was still enough that he had accumulated a nice stack of photos.
Grabbing the letter and the panties he tossed them inside the box, closed it up and then slid it under his bed. Seeing the things he'd collected brought back vivid memories of the moments he'd been given each item from the women and of the impromptu photo shoots that each of the women volunteered to do for him.
Trying to shake those mental images from his mind, he grabbed some clean clothes and headed in for a nice cold shower. The moment the chilling water smacked against his skin it completely cleared any thoughts he had been stewing on in his mind. It wasn't the most refreshing shower but it was doing the job he wanted it to.
Once he was dressed he went down stairs to gather up something to eat from the kitchen. Just as he was putting away his dirty dishes, he heard what sounded like the back-up beeps from a large truck out front of his house. Moving through his house, he approached his front door and opened it up to see what was going on.
Slowly backing up and almost blocking his own driveway, he watched as the large moving truck inched closer to the house next door. The house had been vacant since he saw a different moving truck loading up Marge and Chet's stuff. Now that he thought about it, the for-sale sign that had been placed out in the front lawn was missing.