"Logan?"
I glanced up to see Ava grinning down at me.
"What?" I smiled half-heartedly.
"You're advertising." She smirked with a glance down.
I followed her eyes and saw, much to my embarrassment, that I was aroused. I didn't have a full-on erection, but it was enough to show through the thin, dark fabric of my trunks.
I tossed the towel over it. "I doubt anyone saw it." I retorted with a frown.
"I highly doubt that." She said and looked to where my gaze had been. "Still crushing on her, huh?" She questioned as she moved to plop down into the chair beside me. She handed me the cold beer that she'd gone to get.
I looked once more upon Allison Daniels who stood beside the pool talking to Amelia James and Paige Mathews, two girls we've known since our freshman year. "She's made her choice."
"Yeah, with Jameson Carter." She smiled and then reclined back so she could resume sunbathing. "The school's star wide receiver. Everyone knows that."
I sighed. "It's her choice." I muttered and drained half the bottle before reclining back too.
"A lot of girls made that choice." She said. "He loves blondes."
I shook my head and tried to push Allison from my mind. I tried to think of a million different things, including the real reason for my hard-on. It wasn't Allison. But how could I tell Ava the truth? I tried to ignore my sister's body, the smooth, beautiful skin that her simple, black two-piece bikini revealed, but I couldn't. It was impossible, and my cock reflected that forbidden desire...well...on my part that is. But Allison wouldn't leave me alone either. Ava was right. I've had a crush on her since high school. Now, here we were, in our senior year of college and I still carried a flame for her. Even now, I still yearned for her. Not even catching her in the act last year had dampened that yearning, that salacious and ultimately foolish hunger.
I closed my eyes, and the memories of that evening came flooding back. The game was over. The stadium was empty again. And yet, she'd lingered, and I'd been curious as to why. I followed her as she snuck around to the backside of the stadium. The cement wall that had long stood there was called the lover's hideaway. It was called that because of the trees and the angle of the support beams that held up the seating created a secluded spot in the otherwise open space around the football stadium. Students came here to make out once the sun went down. The shadows that resulted from it and the stadium lights after nightfall made it perfect for hiding out and doing wicked things without the risk of being seen. That was what I'd always heard, at any rate.
I remember there had been light. Unlike the claims I'd heard, the stadium lights penetrated quite well here, certainly enough to see Allison clearly. Despite what the rumors had been back then, it wasn't Jameson Carter she was waiting for. It was Jamal Johnson, the school's favorite linebacker, who awaited her in the shadows. He was still in his jersey, but his pants were off and only a thick, black cock dangled between his legs as he took her in his arms and kissed her. I hid behind some concrete slabs and a steel column, but I was close, really close, close enough to see the sweat on his naked ass, an ass over which she slid her hands before squeezing each cheek. I watched as he pushed her against the wall and hiked up the skirt of her cheerleading uniform. She was naked underneath, for I caught a nice glimpse of her flesh has he pushed it up past her waist and even a greater view as she wrapped her long, gorgeous legs around his. I heard her gasp as he slowly entered her. Once he was fully inside, he let it linger there, just for a brief moment or two. That was my technique, and I was shocked to realize that I wasn't the only man who did that. Then again, I was also pissed, hurt, and strangely turned on...what with seeing the girl I was in love with get taking by another man.
I knew I should have left, but I couldn't. I was too enthralled, too sexually aroused. I had stay and see it through. I had to see her getting fucked by Jamal. Most considered him a brute, and even a bully, and yes...many on the team had also said it too. But with Allison, he was being gentle, unexpectedly so, and he started off with simple, slow thrusts. It was Allison who seemed to urge him to fuck her hard. What appeared to me as them making love quickly devolved into pure, animalist lustful fucking. It was dirty sex and she wanted it. She begged for it. She wanted his black cock, and she wanted it hard and fast. He more the willingly obliged. I found myself faint by the time they stopped. I watched in stunned silence as she pushed him against the wall and took his large, girthy cock into her mouth. What troubled me the most however...well it was the strange and new urge that came over me. I wanted more than anything to replace her. It was him that I found myself desiring. It was his cock that I wanted to taste and to swallow, as she was doing now, right before my ravenous eyes.
He gripped her head and pressed his dark fingers into her long, light blonde hair as she swallowed him over and over in quick succession. He was moaning and bucking against her and towards the end, towards his obvious climax, he held her head firmly against him till she began choking, till she began gagging as his cock's head pressed hard into the back of her throat. He only relinquished his hold seconds before he spewed his semen into her mouth, which caused her to gag all over again. Once he withdrew, I saw nearly every inch of his glistening cock that came away from her mouth, trailing long, translucent strands of semen and saliva. God, I wanted that cock!
Then he nodded and receded into the shadows as another figure emerged. It was Jameson Carter, and from her expression she'd known he was present. In fact, she looked as if she'd expected him. He came to her and, much to my astonished pleasure, completely nude. She wasted no time and reached for his offered cock. Almost immediately, she began sucking and licking its swollen head and its long, slender shaft. Jameson was much leaner in build than Jamal and he had a perfectly shaped ass, exquisitely tight and compact, and in the harsh light from above, beautifully complected. He was that perfect shade of black, light, almost mocha colored, and strangely enough, I yearned to run my hands over his smooth, hairless skin, and even to kiss it, tasting the saltiness of his sweat. I couldn't. She could, and she did. She lived out my fantasy before my eyes as she brought him to a quick climax. Like Jamal, he too spewed his masculine goodness into her mouth and unlike her erstwhile lover, he shot it all over her face and throat.
I nearly came in my pants as I watched him pull her up and pin her against the wall. Neither her nor Jamal tasted the juicy nectar of her pussy, which surprised me. I would have eaten her till she couldn't walk straight, but that was me. He just wanted to fuck and in one quick move he shoved his still aroused cock deep into her swollen and well-used pussy. She grunted and writhed from its presence, much more so than she had with Jamal, and he wasn't as thick as him, at least from what I could see of its beautiful profile. He didn't hesitate, not like Jamal had. He began fucking her, and he didn't take it easy either. He pounded her and she took it. She begged for it, and like Jamal, she squeezed his tight little ass cheeks, as if that somehow made the fucking better.
"Logan."
Ava's voice brought me back to the present. I turned to see her astonished eyes as they aimed low again. "What?"
"Logan!" She exclaimed in a whisper.
I looked down to see that I'd partially moved the towel and now my head was peeping out from beneath the waistband. If others could see it, I didn't know. What I did know was that I was already seeping pre-cum, and it was pooling. I didn't feel any of this. I didn't know how or why. Regardless, I quickly covered up again and pushed it back into my trunks again.
"I guess she's gotten under my skin..."
"You haven't missed your chance, not yet." She said. "She's heading for medical school in California. Jameson is headed for Virginia. He'll be out of her life soon enough."
"I don't know, Ava." I felt embarrassed and I knew she could see the blushing of my cheeks. I knew John could, for he offered playful grins my way as he sat at the bar talking to Morgan and Dannie.
Ava obviously caught what he was doing too. "While you've been lusting over Allison, he's been lusting over you."
"Ava...please."
"Please what?" She brightened gleefully.
"Not this again."
"Yes, this again." She persisted. "There's nothing wrong with...you know...experimenting, dear brother."
"It is, especially when John is dating Dannie."
"He dated Dannie, as in past tense. He's long dealt with his confusion about his sexuality, as if you haven't known that." She retorted. Her voice sounded like an admonishment, but then again...I wasn't exactly the right state of mind. "She saw the writing on the wall, Logan. John may like girls, but he loves guys more, and he's got it bad for you."
"I need some air." I said and got up.
"Dad's about to start the burgers." She looked at me confusedly, which transcended quickly into a searching gaze. She knew there was more that I wasn't saying and that nearly killed me.
"I won't be long." I promised and headed for the beach.
I could feel her probing eyes boring into my back as I walked away. I knew she wasn't going to let this go. We were twins. We've never allowed secrets to linger between us, festering till they poisoned the love and trust we shared. However, there was one secret that I never dared to tell her, one that has tortured me since I was old enough to understand its true and illicit nature. That was what drove me from the party to wonder alone along this long stretch of desolate beach. The waves crashed relentlessly before me and the water's cool touch caressed my feet, and yet not even the power of the enchanted sea could soothe my troubled soul. The gulls flew about me and called laughingly to each other, but not even their cheerful banter could lighten my heart. It was far too shadowed by fear and doubt, and I had to confess...unrequited love and raging, forbidden lust.
I walked about a mile, almost to the point where I could see Hatteras and its fabled lighthouse in the distance. There were a few people out now. Most had gone down to the big music festival on Cape Fear. We didn't. We spent out last summer of freedom here at Hatteras Island, at my grandparents' house. It was the last summer for staying at the house too, for they'd moved to Florida last year and the house would be placed on the market as soon as we left. Our parents were moving too, but down to Charleston, South Carolina. My dad had friends down there and now that he was retired from the bank, his future lay on the golf course. Mom's future was with her society friends, shopping and attending parties. Boring I know, but that was what she loved. Who was I to question her choices?
I took a seat in the sand and fought back the tears.
"Logan." I looked away and wiped my eyes as Ava sat beside me and pulled me in close to her. "What's wrong?"
That was the way it had always been with us. We were so in tune with each other that there was no hiding our feelings from each other. She sensed the pain and the turmoil inside me, and it was reflected in her tears.
"I can't bring myself to tell you." I couldn't face her.
"It's not about Allison, is it?" She quickly perceived, and that scared me. "Is it about your confusion?"