Disclaimer: All characters, names, places, scenarios are fictional. As this is a continuation of My brothers wife I strongly suggest you read part one first.
As usual those expecting perfect grammar and punctuation, I suggest you don't read any of my efforts.
A who is who of the characters for you,
My name is Andy Holt, I am 18 yrs old 5ft 10in, a bit of a fitness freak, I am the youngest of 5 brothers and am the only one who is unmarried.
My dad is called Peter 65, his second wife who is my mum is called Pam aged 48. Mike 46 my eldest brother is married to Becky aged 46, the twins Chris and Tony are 44, their wives are Liz and Di respectively both aged 36, and finally George 42 whose wife is called Pat aged 43 and the one who this all started off with.
[I will start the story with the ending of My Brothers wife part1]
Monday morning mum rang me.
[Mum] "Are you going to the gym after work?."
[Me] "Yes, why."
[Mum] "Good, can I meet you there."
[Me] "Yes, what up."
[Mum] "Nothing, about 4.30pm ok."
[Me] "Yes fine, what's going on."
[Mum] "Nothing see you later, bye."
I wondered what mum was playing at, what could be so urgent it couldn't wait till I got back from the gym. There was no way she could have found out about me and Pat. I hadn't told her and if Pat had there would have been an explosion.
I was a bit late only 5 minutes but when I saw her people carrier, I pulled up next to it. She wasn't alone, Pat, Becky, Liz an Di were sat in the back, now I was confused.
[Mum] "Get in Andy, I have a question for you and you can be honest."
{Me] "Hi."
Looking at Pat for some clue, she just smiled at me, no help there then.
[Mum] "There is no way to sugar coat this, so here goes, did you fuck Pat while you were away last week."
I looked at Pat again she was still smiling.
{Mum] "Well."
{Me] "Yes, it just kind of happened."
[Mum] "Fuck, I didn't think you would do it."
[Pat] "Told you I could do it, now you all need to do the same."
[Me] "What it was a set up."
[Mum] "Andy don't be upset, it started off as which brother would you fuck if you weren't married, we all said you."
[Me] "What, why."
{Pat] "What I told you was true, the girls are in the same boat, when you said you would go on holiday with me and the girls. Becky thought the girls would have more chance, than me."
[Me] "Whoa, they are underage for a start and you are a lot sexier."
[Di} "So you like the older woman then, interesting."
I looked at mum for some help it wasn't forthcoming, what was shocked me.
[Mum] "Don't look at me to help you, I was next on the list to try."
[Me} "Mum."
[Mum} "Then Di, then Liz and Becky was last because we all thought she had the best chance."
[Me] "All of you, why for gods sake you can't all be getting none."
[Mum] "Your dad is 65 and not interested."
[Becky] "What don't you get Andy, we all want to fuck you, are you up for it or not?"
[Me] "Just the once like Pat."
[Mum] "All depends if you are as good as Pat said."
[Me} "You can't be serious, if they found out, I'm dead meat."
[Becky] "So what if we guarantee they won't find out, are you up for it."
[Me] "I don't know."
[Liz] "So its not a definite no then."
[Me] "Well I suppose so, but I need time to think."
[Di] "Don't take too long or we might just have to make your mind up for you."
[Mum] "Andy you need to go now, we girls have to talk."
I got out of the car and back into mine, not sure whether to drive off or stay and see what happened next.. I chose the cowards way out, I drove home. My mind was racing, could I do it, but more importantly could I get away with it, without getting my head kicked in. Out of all of them, I had already fucked the wife of the brother I was most scared of, he was a definite hard case. They had been spot on, when they said Becky stood the best chance out of all of them. But there was no way I had ever thought of screwing my mother. I love my mum but getting in bed with her no way Jose.
It was a very strange week, I was early to work everyday and left last every night.
I stayed longer at the gym and got home later each night as the week progressed.
I had done a great job of avoiding contact with all of them, but it was now the weekend and Dad wanted a family BBQ Sunday afternoon.
I knew they would want an answer but I still didn't know if I was capable of doing it. My sensible head said no, then yes, then back to no. But the thought of slipping my cock between Becky's tits, was a fantasy I had had for years. Liz and Di were both blonde stick insects, both lookers, who knew how to show off their best bits, which are their long legs, both would be on anybody's fuckable list. My mum was what was the biggest problem, she has a great body but I couldn't think of her that way.
If Saturday was anything to go by then I was in for a rough weekend, mum was the first to call round. As normal with mum she came straight to the point, what had I decided, its was unfair to keep them waiting.
[Me] "Mum, one part of me says hell yes, but then my sensible head says I can't do this to the family, it's just not right."
[Mum] "Your dad will never find out, it has to be better with you than some random stranger."
[Me] "I just need more time, I can't get my head around it at present."
I should have just told her I didn't see her that way but again I chose the cowards way out. She hadn't been gone 20 mins when the doorbell went again it was Pat.
[Me] "Hi"
[Pat] "We need to talk before you see the rest of the girls."
[Me} "Ok. mum has already been round, this morning."
[Pat} "What did you tell her."
[Me} "I haven't decided yet, look can I be honest with you."
[Pat] "Of course Andy."
[Me} "I don't think of mum that way."
[Pat} "But you would screw the others."
[Me] "Maybe, yes oh look I don't know."
[Pat] "You can't tell her that, she would be devasted."
[Me] "So, I would have to say no then."
{Pat] "Do you wish, I hadn't seduced you."
{Me] "Hell no way, even though I'm more scared of George than the others."
[Pat] "Could we do it again."
[Me} "Yes."
[Pat] "Good, but don't tell the girls that, they are already jealous."
[Me] "Do you think they might say something to George."
[Pat] "No, we are safe but if they find out we have done it again, I'm not so sure."
[Me] "Look Pat, I need to think, before we do anything."
[Pat] "I understand, but you can't stall them for ever, see you tomorrow at the BBQ."
{Me] "Do you think I could get away with not going."
[Pat] "No way Andy, that would be a very stupid thing to do."
[Me] "I know you are right but its scary."
{Pat] "The guys won't even notice them paying you more attention, you are safer there than you think. Your mum is in total control she won't stand for any nonsense. see you later"
[Me] "Bye Pat"
Becky was next up, thankfully it wasn't a visit just a phone call.
[Becky} "Andy you need to make a decision the girls are getting restless."
[Me] "Hello Becky, nice to hear from you."