Mary Ellen & Sue

I was 18, a freshman in college, and still a virgin. I had gone out of State to an engineering school that was predominantly male and lived in an all-male dorm, so I was pretty unhappy with my circumstances when I came back home for spring break.

I had been home for a couple of days when I noticed a girl that I had never seen before getting out of a car at the house next door. She was tall, had a cute figure, and long straight light brown hair. I asked my mother if new neighbors had moved in next door, and she told me that they had moved in a couple of months ago and that they had a daughter named Mary Ellen, who was a senior in high school. That evening, I was up in my bedroom and glanced out of the window at the house next door and I noticed Mary Ellen in her bedroom, directly across from mine, looking over at me. When I saw her, she turned away and closed her shades, but it was obvious that she had been checking me out.

The next day, I saw her in her yard, so I went over and introduced myself. She seemed shy, but as we chatted, I could tell that she was interested in me. Finally, I said, "My parents are going out tomorrow night. Do you want to come over and hang out with me? We could watch a movie, or something."

"Sure. What time?" she quickly replied.

"Come on over about eight."

"OK, I'll see you then."

The next night, shortly after eight, Mary Ellen showed up at the back door of my house. "Come on in," I said, "I was just watching TV."

I took her into the den, and we sat on the couch together. We talked while the TV played in the background; she seemed interested in hearing about the college party scene. After a while, I leaned over and began kissing her. I didn't have a lot of experience, but she seemed really inexperienced and nervous, so I took it slow. After making out for a while, I slid a hand across her blouse and cupped her breast. I began to gently massage her boob as we continued to make out. She didn't stop me, so I ran my thumb over her nipple and began to play with it. I could feel its hardness trying to poke through her bra as I teased it with my fingers. Mary Ellen gently moaned into my mouth.

Feeling bolder, I ran my other hand under her blouse and up her back to the clasp of her bra. I struggled to unhook it with one hand, so I removed my hand from her breast to help. Once her bra was unhooked, I slipped my hand under it to continue massaging her breast. Her nipple was hard to my touch, like a pink eraser at the end of a No. 2 pencil.

I was thinking about moving things along further, when Mary Ellen broke our kiss and asked, "What time is it?"

"A little after ten," I replied.

"I have to go. I told my parents that I would be home at ten," Mary Ellen said as she hurriedly put herself back together.

At the door, I told her that I had to go back to college in a couple of days, but that I would like to get together with her when I came home for the summer in a couple of months. She said that she'd like that and left.

When I got back a couple of months later, I was talking to a friend who was also a Senior in high school, and I told him that I wanted to get together with Mary Ellen. He told me that he had seen her at a party and that she was fucking another guy in our neighborhood named Chris. I was disheartened by this news and put off calling her.

A couple of weeks later, I was driving by Mary Ellen's house, and she was standing outside with a friend, so I stopped the car to say hello. She came over to my car and I asked her what she was up to. She introduced me to her friend Sue. Sue was a little shorter than Mary Ellen and she had beautiful brown eyes. Sue seemed more outgoing than Mary Ellen and exuded a certain sexiness. Mary Ellen said that they were going to the drive-in that night and she wanted to know if I could get some booze for them. I told her that I could (the drinking age was 18 in my State at that time) and she reached into the car and hugged me. Then she said, "Do you want to come with us?"

I said "That sounds great. What time are you going?"

"We're leaving at 8:00. My Dad is letting us use his car. It has a big front seat that we all can fit in to watch the movie."

"We can stop on the way and pick up a bottle of rum," I replied, "We can buy Cokes at the drive-in to mix with it."

I went over to Mary Ellen's at 8:00 and the three of us loaded into a Detroit-made sedan that was as big as a whale; with Mary Ellen behind the wheel, me in the middle, and Sue on the other side of me. We made a quick stop at the liquor store, where I purchased a bottle of Bacardi 151. When we got to the drive-in, we parked the sedan away from other cars so no one would see us with the alcohol and bought three large Cokes on ice at the concession stand. Pouring some of the Coke on to the ground, we added the 151 rum and settled in to wait for the movie to start.

It was a sultry night, and the rum and Coke went down fast. Sue, in particular, drank like she wanted to get wasted, and by the time the movie started, we were all buzzed.

As the movie was playing, I put my arm around Mary Ellen and began to kiss her. Sue looked over at us and exclaimed, "Hey, what about me?"

I shrugged, turned towards Sue, and began to kiss her. As soon as my lips met hers, she shoved her tongue in my mouth and began kissing me passionately. It was electric, and I kissed her back passionately as she moaned into my mouth. I remembered Mary Ellen on the other side of me, broke my kiss with Sue, and began kissing her again. I was going back and forth between the two girls, making out with each of them, but I found myself spending more time with Sue, who was on fire. Then I felt Sue's hand slide up my thigh and she began to rub my hard cock through my jeans. In response, I slid my hand up to her crotch and began massaging her clit through her jeans. Sue's jeans were well worn and had a hole in the fabric near her crotch. I slipped my middle finger through the hole and found that she wasn't wearing any underwear, giving me easy access to her pussy. I began stroking her slit. She was very wet and my finger easily slipped into her warm pussy. Sue moaned into my mouth and began to slowly move her hips against my hand as we made out, forcing my finger to penetrate deeper into her.

Suddenly, Mary Ellen spoke up. "I think we need to go," she said. I looked over at her and she was looking straight ahead.

"I'm sorry Mary Ellen. Sue and I were just having a little fun. I heard that you've been seeing Chris, so I didn't feel like I should get too heavy with you."

Mary Ellen looked embarrassed that I knew about Chris and blurted out, "We're not exclusive."

"Besides, you're behind the steering wheel so it's kind of hard to make out with you, but if you want, we can all get in the back seat and I'll make sure that both of you receive an equal amount of attention," I said as I leaned over and kissed her gently. Then, as I slide my hand up her thigh, I said, "Let's get in the back seat."

Sue chimed in, "Don't be mad, Mary Ellen. We'll take turns. Come on, it will be fun."

As I massaged Mary Ellen's upper thigh adjacent to her crotch, I kissed her again, a little deeper, and said, "How about it?"

Mary Ellen said, "OK" and reached for her door handle. Sue said, "Yes!" and reached for hers, and we all scrambled into the back seat of the big sedan, with me in the middle again.

I didn't want Mary Ellen to think that I wasn't neglecting her, so I turned towards her first and began to kiss her. It was very difficult to concentrate on her because Sue was on the other side of me, and she was again rubbing my hard dick through my jeans. I felt Sue reach over with both hands, unbutton my jeans, and pull down the zipper. Then, she slipped a hand inside my pants and began stroking my cock.

I decided that I needed to give Mary Ellen the same treatment, so I unbuttoned her jeans and snaked a hand beneath her panties to find her pussy. She was wet, and as I ran my middle finger along the length of her slit, she began to moan.

Sue whispered to me, "Lift up your ass." I did and she yanked my pants and underwear down past my knees. With my cock standing at full attention, Sue give it a couple of more strokes, and then, I felt her warm mouth close around it. I had never felt anything that good in my life. Sue continued sucking my cock, her tongue swirling around the tip, as I was finger fucking and making out with Mary Ellen. I thought I had died and went to heaven.

After a few minutes Sue spoke up, "I think it's time to switch. You can suck his cock now, Mary Ellen."

As I turned towards Sue, I saw her unbutton her jeans and pull them halfway down her thighs. We began making out and I began finger fucking her as Mary Ellen's head descended on my dick. Sue's pussy was soaking wet, and as I fingered her, she moaned in my mouth. Her pussy was making a squishing sound as I continued to fuck her with my finger. Suddenly she stiffened and exclaimed, "I'm cumming!" as she bucked against my hand.

Once Sue calmed down, she looked over at Mary Ellen and said, "Your turn."

I turned back to Mary Ellen and pulled her jeans and panties down to her knees. I began to finger her as we made out. Her pussy was now very wet, and her breathing became ragged as my finger plunged in and out of her.

Sue began to suck my cock again, but with more of a sense of purpose. Her tongue swirled around the head as she bobbed up and down on it. Occasionally, she would take it out of her mouth and give it long strokes with her tongue, before putting it back between her lips. I was leaking pre-cum, which she lapped up like a kitten. I was moaning into Mary Ellen's mouth and I knew that I wasn't going to last much longer.

Mary Ellen began bucking her hips against my hand that was fucking her, and then began cumming, letting out a long low moan.

After Mary Ellen had calmed down, Sue looked up at me with her big brown eyes and asked "Whose mouth do you want to cum in?"

I couldn't believe what I just heard. I looked at Sue and simply said, "Keep going."

Sue turned to Mary Ellen and said, "I'll save some for you, so be ready to take over." Mary Ellen moved her head down next to Sue's.

Sue put my dick back in her mouth and began stroking my shaft as she sucked on the head; using her tongue to massage the frenulum. In a matter of seconds, I was shooting my hot cum into her mouth. Three powerful blasts flooded her mouth, and then, removing her mouth from my cock, she pulled Mary Ellen's head over to my cock.

As Mary Ellen's mouth closed around my cock and she began milking what cum was left in my balls out of me, Sue raised her head up and pressed her lips against mine. She forced her tongue between my lips, and the mouthful of cum that she had been holding followed. She hadn't swallowed. We made out, our tongues dancing in my cum while Mary Ellen continued to suck the last drops out of my cock.

The next day, I really wanted to see Sue again, but I didn't know where she lived. I called Mary Ellen and she told me that her and Sue were busted by her Dad when they came home drunk. She said that her dad told her that she was grounded for a month and that she wasn't allowed to see me anymore. I didn't have the nerve to ask her for Sue's number.

It was my first blowjob and my first cum kiss. I would never again have two women at the same time, but it was an experience that would shape my view of sex for the rest of my life, and "Whose mouth do you want to cum in?" is still the most erotic thing a woman has ever said to me.