Author's Note: This is my first-ever story! Please leave feedback. <3
Joe
18 years old
6' 0"
150 lbs
Brown, curly hair
Green eyes
Joe and I were everything to each other. We were attached at the hip: inseparable. We spent five nights a week together, perched on the countertops of his parents' kitchen, warm summer air wafting through the open windows, whispering about poetry and politics. We were odd kids. We argued like siblings. He defended me to his friends, and I defended him to mine. We loved each other, and we told each other so often.
Joe was dating Allie, one of my best friends. I knew it was weird that he and I were so close, and I worked hard to make sure that we were never *too* close. Allie was sweet, she loved us both, and she never seemed to mind.
Joe asked me often, over the years, whether I'd ever had a crush on him. He was constantly worrying that he'd led me on, that I'd become too attached. I reassured him, over and over again: We were just friends.
We were just friends, but I was desperately, embarrassingly, irrevocably in love with Joe.
I tried to hide it. I drew lines in the sand of our relationship: no dinners with his family, no day trips. I kept secrets from him. I spent hours agonizing, worried that every one of our friends knew, but him. I tiptoed around my feelings day in and day out, but I couldn't stay away. Like a moth to a flame, begging to get burned.
So it was summer, our last summer home before college. All of our friends spent every possible minute together, covered in some combination of sweat, sunscreen, and lake water from dawn 'til dusk. Joe and Allie were going to the same school; I was leaving the state, moving halfway across the country. Our time together was running out, and Joe and I both knew it. We wrote each other poems and letters, waxing eloquent about the people we were and the people we'd become, drawing out the days until I was scheduled to leave.
I knew my time was running out. I knew I could either make a move, and regret it the rest of my life, or not make a move, and regret it the rest of my life. Staring down the barrel of a lose-lose situation, I let the time tick by, until my very last night in town.
I was scheduled to leave early, four in the morning the next day. We had a party, ran around our suburban neighborhood like hooligans long into the night. It was raining, but it was warm. We were soaked through by the time we started saying goodbye. One by one, we hugged, exchanged well-wishes, said we'd see each other in a few months, until it was just me and Joe, standing in the dark at the end of the cul-de-sac, and I knew this was my last chance.
Our friends' headlights faded into the distance as he hugged me. I'm small, 5'2", and I'd always stretch to wrap my arms around his neck, hoping somehow maybe he'd feel my soft chest and tight waist pressed up against him, and think of me as something, anything, other than just some kind of kid sister. I pressed my cheek against his, felt the scratch of stubble, the warmth of skin. My nerves were on edge. I couldn't breathe. He was saying something, "You're going to have a great time. Don't be scared." If I could just get up the courage to kiss his cheek -
I turned my head, lightning-fast, and pressed my lips against his face. Just once, just a moment. He pulled back, smiled at me, and kissed my cheek, then pressed his forehead to mine. Damn him, he didn't get it. I felt like I might cry, panic blossoming in my chest. Committed now, and with our noses almost touching, I pushed on and kissed him full on the mouth. Eyes closed, I held myself there, held my breath, held everything, fucking terrified to move. He stood stock still for what felt like forever, and I finally pulled away, dropping down off my tiptoes, staring at my bare toes against the wet pavement.
He used his hand to lift my chin, *fucking asshole*. "Hey, what was that?" he asked, eyes searching mine.
My face flaming red, my breath coming out in a rush, "It was nothing! I'm really sorry. I'm really sorry. I should go."
He put his hands on my arms. "No, come on, we can't just not talk about it."
"I think we definitely can, and we will. It's late, and I'm sorry. I really need to go home." I pulled my shoulders away, milliseconds from crying. "Please just let me go home."
His hands dropped to his sides. He was already tired. "I'm sorry. Maybe we can talk about it later."
I nodded, already walking toward my car. "Later, yeah. Okay. Love you! Text me tomorrow, okay?"
He stood, rooted where I left him. "Love you. Yeah. Okay."
I leapt into the car, turning off the overhead light so he couldn't see me cry. *FuckfuckFUCK.* Stupid. It was so stupid. I could see him in the street, turning around, walking to his car. I sat, watching, waiting for him to leave so I could break down in peace. Then my phone rang.
I picked up, and tried to pretend some semblance of normalcy. "Hey, Joe, what's up?"
There was a long pause. "Do you want to come over?"
I long-paused back. Thought about the pros and cons of hashing out my all-consuming love for him on the futon in his basement, versus spending the next three months obsessing over what he thought of me and whether I'd ever see him again. Like a moth to a flame, "Yeah, alright."
"Cool. See you there."
I watched his car pull away, waited a beat, then followed. The entire drive across town was torturous. Dark, empty, dimly lit streets. Lonely stoplights. My heart beating out of my chest, rehearsing what I'd say: *"I'm really tired; I'm just gonna miss you." "It wasn't supposed to be weird." "I promise: I just see you as a friend."*
I got out of my car, still barefoot, hair wet. Opened the back door to his house, quietly slid it shut. Tiptoed through the house and down the stairs to the basement, where the light was on. He was standing, back to me, arms crossed.
"Hey." I said, feigning innocence, and flopped down onto the futon, curled up against the armrest, awaiting judgement.
He turned. "Alright, hey." He came and sat in the corner opposite me, then met me with some devastating eye contact.
I couldn't handle the eye contact. "I'm really sorry." I said again, and laughed, trying to play the thing off. "I was just really tired. I'm gonna miss you. I didn't mean to make you uncomfortable." I grinned, trying to convince him I meant it. *Please believe me, please, please believe me.*
He squinted, gave me a half smile. "It's alright. You surprised me, is all. It's okay. You don't need to be sorry." He looked away, then smiled brightly. "You know I love you, right?"
I smiled and nodded enthusiastically. "Right!"
"Good." He sighed and relaxed, stretched out. His arm on the back of the futon. "Will you come over here, then?"
"Okay." I scootched closer, facing him, my knees between us.
His arm around my shoulders, he leaned over, and, softly, kissed my cheek. My eyes fluttered closed for just a hairbreadth of a second. He was warm. He smelled like rain, and sweat, and Joe. I smiled as warmly as I could as he pulled away. *Just friends.* But he was looking at me, still leaning in, still leaning forward. Just inches from my face. And then he kissed me. The warmth of his lips just barely pressed against mine, not moving, not pulling away. I gasped (I couldn't help it) and froze, not daring to move, not daring to breathe, just sitting there, under the feather-light weight of it. He pulled back, just a little, and looked at me, squinting, judging my reaction. I must have looked completely terrified, because he seemed to find it a little funny, and moved his hand to hold my face. "Breathe." He smiled, his thumb sliding across my cheek, then he kissed me again.
That broke the spell. I kissed him back, pressing myself into him, sliding my arm around his neck, pulling him closer. His face was rough, his skin was soft, his chest was hard and solid. I was so, so desperate for him, and so, so desperate for him not to know. It was everything I could do not to throw myself at him. His breath came faster and I flicked my tongue into his mouth, my hand pulling at his hip, needing more. He responded, hands moving over my cheeks, into my hair, down my back, over my sides.
He pulled away again, clearly intending to say something, but I couldn't let him, not now. I pressed forward, sliding into his lap, twisting my hands into his hair, pulling him back for more. He made a sound in his throat as his hands found my hips, trying not to grab my ass. "Wait," he said, grabbing my arms instead, holding me away from him. I obliged, eyes wide, hands light on the solid warmth of his chest. "Why?" he asked.
"Why?" I was practically panting, struggling to focus.
"Why are you doing this?" He was breathing heavy, too, I was encouraged to note.
"Because I want to." I evaded, trying to lean back in. He denied me, grabbing my hands to keep me at bay.
"Why do you want to?"
"I don't know."
"Really?"
"No."
He sighed, clearly not happy with my answer. "Please? Just be honest with me."
I swallowed. "I just . . . " I paused, letting myself deflate, "Please don't make me."
"Fuck."
"I'm sorry - "
"Please? I love you. I love you so, so much. And you've never wanted anything to do with me like this, and I respect that, even though it's hard, and even though you're a pain in the ass sometimes, but I've wanted you for so long, and it's just hard to accept that this is even happening, let alone that you want it!" His breath came out in a rush, still holding me, me still on his lap.
"What?!" I exclaimed.
"What?"
"You've loved ME for so long?!"
"Yes?"
"No!"
"What?"