The email
I sent him an email. We were just friends, but I was attracted to him. I was, and still am, married. I've got two kids, although they're teenagers now, at the time they were just kids.
I'd been writing an erotic story for a while when I wrote the email asking him if he'd give it a read and some feedback on it. It was my story, my characters, my fantasies. I'd been writing it for years. My husband and I have a good marriage and we've raised our boys right but this writing was my outlet. It gave me a place to go in my mind when the same-old-same-old got to be same-old. Anyone who's ever been married or in a long-term relationship understands the lulls and swings of it. Our sex was good, we'd developed our tricks and ways of meeting the other's needs but I wrote my stories and when rare moments of privacy occurred I would secret away on my iPad and indulge myself.
My husband didn't know I wrote this kind of stuff, only a couple of my girlfriends knew. I only ever shared it with one or two of my closest friends. I never had a problem sharing with my girls, but, at the same time I knew who I could trust and they know who they are.
When I emailed Otto and asked him if he'd read it, I suspected he'd be into it, but I was terrified nonetheless. I considered him a close friend and I didn't want that part to go away, but at the same time, I wanted him to see this other side of me. I wanted to show him. These were my personal and intimate fantasies and I was about to share them with a man I'd secretly imagined touching me in ways only my mind would ever make happen. I never imagined any of it would be a reality. It was all in my mind. Outing myself to him would change everything, but I had no idea how it would look or feel.
The first email I sent was just to ask him, "Hey, I've been writing a story for a while now and I know you write too, so I was wondering if you might give it a read. I totally understand if you're too busy."
He replied pretty quickly. I know nowadays people/friends/family get an email or text and can take days or weeks to reply, but we were pretty good friends. He was single and I think he was attracted to me in some way, although he never ever acted upon it. It was because he always replied within 24 hours, and always with something witty or interesting, I felt from the beginning he liked me. Plus, he told me his theory on friendships between the sexes.
A man and woman cannot be friends if they're attracted to one another.
I thought he was being a misogynist. But he meant that men and women, who are attracted to one another can be friends, but the friendship stems from their attraction. That actually may be a misogynist viewpoint now that I think about it, but he never struck me as such, I would never have been friends with him if I'd suspected otherwise. He said if a man and woman remained friends for a long time and nothing ever transpired sexually between them it was because one or the other wasn't attracted to them. The friendship would be a passive one, without intimacy, without compassion or care.
It was because he'd shared this with me and behaved as if he did care, and he was there for me and I was there for him that I knew he must have been attracted to me. If I hadn't understood this innately, I would not have sent him the email.
And true to that belief, he replied within 24 hours that he'd be happy to read it over and even offered notes if I so wished.
The moment came. I attached the story as a Shared Doc and wrote that he could make comments in it if he had the time. I was literally trembling when I hit send.
Directly after sending it I read the email 20 times, re-read the story a dozen times, each time measuring it for his reactions. In my mind, I'd just made the first move. I had held his hand. We were having our first kiss. I was thrilled and touched myself that night despite the anxiety, or maybe because of it.
The characters were Luke and Lacy. I know...so cliche, but I never could get names right in my stories. Luke was like him outwardly. Rugged, strong-willed, sensitive, and compassionate. Lacy was like me...sort of. She was my alter-ego. She and I shared traits like our love of a good showerhead and our desire to be taken by a strong man. We both know what we want and like. We both won't stand for any BS, but we are both forgiving and loving. We want our men to want us, we want them to respect us, and we build our relationships on trust and reciprocity.
But Lacy was an aggressive woman too. I don't know if I secretly, unbeknownst to even myself, am an aggressive woman, but I wanted Lacy to be more dominant. I wanted her to experiment for me.
How it started
I met Otto at the school where I'd been working for 3 years. I taught English and so did he and on the first day of school while teachers all stood in their hallway during break he walked down and introduced himself. He was older and this was his first teaching job. He was really nervous and every question he had was about the students and the school. He was very nervous.
That day we had lunch together in the small break-room in our hallway. Our school was remodeling at the time and subject teachers were out in pods separate from the main buildings. English teachers all shared one pod and we had our own little room with a fridge and stove/microwave and table and chairs.
I walked in and saw him sitting eating his lunch and joined him. We hit it off directly. He was funny and kind of rough around the edges. I'd come to learn he was quite a polarizing person, people at the school either really liked him or they didn't like him at all. I enjoyed talking with him about pedagogy and classroom management. Even though he was older, I had more experience than him in the classroom, but talking with him about the students and lesson design reminded me of when I'd first started teaching. It was refreshing. We arranged pretty quickly after that first lunch together to meet on a weekly basis and grade papers, talk strategy, and discuss philosophy.
We'd meet every Sunday at a coffee shop near my house. Many times though, instead of talking about school, we just talked. He was single, and it seemed to me, a confirmed bachelor. He'd had some long-term relationships, but as he put it, he could never find anyone to marry him. He said it was a great wish of his to have kids of his own.
He would go on an occasional date now and again but nothing ever came of them. I even tried hooking him up with my friends. I enjoyed being his sounding board. It felt like I was talking with one of my girlfriends if I'm honest.
I had my girlfriends too. I had my boys and my husband of course. Most of my time, I devoted to them so whatever time I had with the girls was precious. I made sure to balance it all, and most of the time my husband was pretty good about taking the boys when I needed time. He knew I was meeting with Otto every week, but I assured him he was not attracted to me. I honestly didn't think he was. I might have told my husband Otto was gay just so he wouldn't freak out, but I never introduced the two of them. That was a bad move on my part in hindsight. If I'd not told my husband he was gay, I would have, but he would have known Otto was straight as soon as they met, which is why I never introduced them.
Otto and I started hanging out more as our friendship grew. We'd go shopping or to school functions together. I found out he was a writer and read some of his stories. They were good stories, some tragic aspects to them but with humor and playful sexual undertones. I liked his stories but they were unpolished and wandered off into nothingness often.
Shopping was fun with him. I'd never met a man who enjoyed shopping. He smoked weed so I think that had a lot to do with it. He was a great shopping buddy. Like I said, a lot like one of my girlfriends. I think he saw himself that way too. He just enjoyed hanging out, talking, and laughing. We would get lunches occasionally too. We would go to school plays and musicals. We'd dress up and go for a drink after and talk about the performances. We lived in a small town in a culturally starved part of the country so this was about as intellectual as we could get without actually making a real date.
One week, at our Sunday morning meeting, he was hungover pretty bad and we were just talking. He was telling me about a date he had with this Japanese woman with two teenage kids. He was very forthcoming and it was turning me on. I liked him as a friend. I definitely thought he was handsome, but something about the retelling of his night's debauchery got to me. I led him down the path and assured him that I was enjoying his account and he revealed more. I felt as if I was "leading" him. And he followed. That day he was wearing an old pair of sweat-style shorts and a loose-fitting t-shirt with flip-flops. He got up to use the bathroom and I swear I caught a glimpse of satin pink material that had slipped up above the waistband of his shorts.
"Was he wearing panties?!?" I thought to myself, impossible. This overt man, this rough-around-the-edges man was definitely wearing panties.
When he came back from the bathroom I started asking him questions about his writing. Like, had he ever written stories for his girlfriends? Had he written erotic stories? I remember the look on his face, deciding how to respond, or even if he should, but he told me he had and if he believed what they'd said about the stories, they were quite good.