D'Amcico's Corner Lounge was as full as it ever got on a Thursday afternoon. Pete D'Amico, owner and bartender, was in his usual spot, behind the bar talking with Lou Abitante. Lou was in his usual spot, end stool farthest from the door, beer in hand and words pouring out of his mouth. The only other person in the joint was an older gentleman, impeccably dressed, seated on the stool nearest the door. He sipped cognac while staring intently out of the front window towards the street.
"Ask him!" urged Lou. “Go ahead, Pete, ask him!" The "him" Lou referred to was the well-dressed man who was so obviously out of place in such a seedy gin mill.
Pete shook his head. "Lou, I tol' you a hunnerd times I don't bother my customers."
"But, Pete," Lou pleaded, "Look at him! This ain't his neighborhood! An' he's here every Thursday, same time, same stool, starin' out the frickin' window for the last six weeks! What is he, a cop on stakeout? Jus' ask him is all I'm sayin'. If you don't I will."
"Sit right there and shut up!" Pete said. "Leave the guy alone, he ain't hurtin' nobody. He wants to look out the window, let him. It's none of my business". Still, Pete had to admit to himself that he was curious. The guy didn't fit in here, he never talked except to order his drink, he always showed up by 5:05 PM and he always left by 6. And he always stared out the window.
Lou drained his beer and stood up. "I'm gonna ask him!" and he strode towards the man at the end of the bar. Pete tried to grab his collar and stop him but Lou was moving too fast. Pete scurried along the bar parallel to Lou.
"Hey, pal!" Lou called out when he was two steps away from the man. As he sat down beside the stranger Lou tapped his shoulder and continued, "Hey, pal, lemme ask you somethin'."
Pete caught up with Lou and spoke to his other customer. "Hey, listen, I'm sorry, sir, I tried to stop him from botherin' you. You want I should throw him out?"
The well-dressed man never turned his head but kept staring outside. "No, no please do not inconvenience yourself. Indeed, I have been expecting an inquiry from you gentlemen for some time. You desire to ascetain the reason why I frequent this establishment each week. May I ask you please to move here to my right side so that I may answer your question as I watch the street? I would be very appreciative."
He talks like a dictionary, thought Pete, as he and Lou exchanged puzzled looks. "Sure, pal, we'll move," said Pete as he and Lou moved around to the man's right side.
The stranger looked to be about fifty, maybe a little younger. Handsome guy, expensive suit, camel hair topcoat, silk tie, gray hair perfectly combed. He spoke in soft, measured tones, his voice a little hesitant as he told his story.
"You see, gentlemen, nothing like this has ever happened to me before and I...oh my, please excuse me gentlemen, won't you join me in a drink?"
Pete hastily poured a cognac and two beers. "Thanks, pal" said Lou.
"You are welcome. I really am embarrassed to tell you this, it is not at all the kind of thing one gentleman divulges to another, yet I feel that I shall burst if I do not tell someone! This tale of mine, well, it falls somewhat under the heading of boasting, don't you see?"
Lou, the tavern savant, chimed in with "Hey, no problem, bub! Guys boast in here all the time, don't they, Pete?"
Pete just rolled his eyes and stayed quiet. The stranger kept his eye on the street, never turned his head at all as he told his story.
"Well, regardless of the behavior of others I am not in the habit of bruiting about such tales as this." He sipped his drink and continued.
"This happened to me on Thursday, December the 15th of last year, at just about this time of day. I was returning home after doing some Christmas shopping. I had a large bag in each hand and a package under each arm, very difficult to walk when so burdened, I’m sure you will understand. Well, I made my way onto the subway; it was crowded, of course. When I got onto the train I had to stand as every seat was taken. Oh, it was very inconvenient, but what could I do? The train moved off and I waited patiently for my stop.