Sunday morning started like the day before, with some awesome fucking. Henry was in high spirits. He was beginning to believe in Grace's idea that genuine love added to anything created the very best of everything.
Their plan was to get to Stephen's house after ten, since he should be playing golf by then. They talked over the possibilities of what could happen, and Grace created a short list of missing items: bicycle, Brahmin handbag, CZ ring, and a beautiful hand-painted silk scarf she had bought at a craft fair. Then she put copies of their receipts on her phone, and also on a thumb drive. All told they added up to $2300.
The ring in particular would be a sore point with Stephen. He had tried to pass himself off to Grace as a jewelry expert, but he had sneered at her opal ring, which consisted of a single opal, a triplet, costing Grace $400. Yet at the same time he raved about her "real" Diamonique ring, a brand created by the online shopping giant QVC, which Grace had only paid $85 for at full price. "Of course it's real," she had told him, "I'm holding it!" He laughed at the time, thinking she was joking. Looking back, Grace realized she
wanted
to believe Stephen, but she knew he was lying about being an expert. He probably lied about everything else as well. At first he even thought Grace was some sort of heiress, when she simply turned out to be a thrifty woman who loved pretty things. He probably decided to kick her out after he tried to sell the ring, or if he had tried to get it sized. Then he gave it to Belinda, telling her it was real.
They ate a healthful breakfast and planned everything out one more time, even up to discussing whether or not Henry should let himself be seen. They decided if Belinda was alone, Henry should stay in his truck, watching. If Stephen was there, Henry should stay near Grace as a male presence for the coward to see. His rugged demeanor might just make Stephen shit his pants. Grace almost hoped that would happen, just so she could laugh at him.
Henry knew Grace was nervous. As they drove near the house, Stephen's red Subaru was not there. There was just an unfamiliar silver Camry, probably Belinda's, which probably meant she was home. Grace walked up to the door and rang the bell.
The door was opened by a statuesque blonde woman. She seemed to be about 25 years old, wearing a beautiful kimono-style robe. Grace introduced herself and told the woman, who never mentioned her name, why she was there. When Grace voiced the four items without even looking at the list, at first the woman had an angry look on her face. Then Grace showed her the receipts, and the look became one of dismay. She knew where all four of the items were. It seemed to Grace that Belinda was angry at the monetary value of the receipts. When she saw how much the ring actually cost, her intake of breath and an almost silent, "That's all?" told Grace that she was a golddigger, and that she had thought the ring was a true diamond, not man-made. She asked Grace to come inside, but Grace wisely declined.
Belinda, since who else could she be, went inside and came back with three items. Ring, scarf, and handbag. When Grace asked about the dust bag for the purse, Belinda looked perturbed but she went to get it. She handed it to Grace, and then she went to open the garage door for the bicycle. Grace looked at it in disbelief. It was broken, covered in mud, and missing one wheel.
"What happened to it? That brand new bike cost me $1500." Grace was appalled. Belinda admitted she didn't even know how to ride a bike, and things got 'out of hand.' Grace turned and gestured toward Henry's truck. He drove to the driveway and got out. Looking at the bike, he took pictures of it, then looked at Belinda as if she was a bug. Belinda squirmed under his gaze, and tried to apologize.
Henry's hand on Grace's shoulder was the only thing restraining her. Finally, even that didn't stop her. She couldn't help herself, and said, "You and Stephen deserve each other. You'd better hide your valuables from him." Then she turned and got in the truck. Henry put the pieces of the bike in the truck bed, and they drove off.
Grace was crying. "I only rode it one time. I was going to ride it across the new Bay Bridge the weekend after the Bay to Breakers."
Henry could think of nothing consoling or helpful to say, so he just stayed silent. But his engineer mind was already trying to figure out how many hours it might take to make the bike like new again. He never even considered that he might not be able to repair it. Of course he could.
I needed a hobby anyway. Looks more and more like Grace is my new hobby.
He made a spot for it in the garage. Grace told him to just throw it away, but you never say that to an engineer. All that means is free parts.
She remembered that the Brahmin dust bag still felt heavy, when it should have been empty. She opened it, reached her hand all the way down to the bottom, and pulled out an old wallet of hers. Also Brahmin. "Henry! My old wallet!" She opened it and found her old driver's license, which she thought she lost, a credit card, and cash. $2000. They looked at each other, trying to decide who the money legally belonged to.
"She had a strange look on her face when I asked for this. I think she knew what was in it. I also think she had to get it from Stephen's room. It must be mine."
"Maybe Stephen knew, also, and was stashing money in it. Were you ever missing any cash?"
"Oh my gosh, yes! Why that lying bastard! He was gaslighting me from the very beginning."
Henry thought,
Google gaslighting. I'm really out of touch with all these new terms.
"What about this credit card? Were there any charges you couldn't explain?"
"No, as soon as I couldn't find it I contacted the bank. They canceled that card and issued me a new one. So this one is dead."
Suddenly Grace's mood lifted. She was relieved, happy, and resolved. They did it! She was finally free of Stephen! Even though it cost her the bike.
He decided he had to ask. "What does gaslighting mean?"
She smiled at him. "You are out of touch, aren't you? Do you like old movies?"
"Yeah, why?"
"I take it that you've never seen the 1944 Noir movie Gaslight, starring the beautiful Ingrid Bergman and the handsome Frenchman Charles Boyer as her husband."
"No, I have never seen it."
"We should rent it. Or buy it! It's about a woman who thinks she's going insane. It's set in the time period before electricity, when homes were lit with gas lamps. Every time she's alone she sees the gas light fade and return, fade and return. He tells her they're fine. He's lying. He wants to commit her to an insane asylum so he can have her inheritance. And that's where the term gaslighting comes from. The movie was based on a play called Gas Light. I'd love to see that play if it's ever done by a community theater somewhere."
Idly, Grace turned the dust bag upside down and two pieces of paper dropped out. She shook it, and a third dropped. She picked them up. The first one was a note in Stephen's handwriting, listing some things that Grace still owned, and which were now in Henry's house. All jewelry, all family items passed down from her mother. No receipts for these, but Grace had them appraised once. The black pearl necklace was worth the most.
"When we lived in the Philippines a friend of my Mom was going to Hong Kong on a shopping trip. Mom asked her to get her some pearls. This three-strand necklace cost her $250. When I got it appraised three years ago it was worth $2,000. These other two items were also bought on the same trip.
Another piece of paper had a name and phone number. Cryptic, but Henry had a suspicion that it was the name of a buyer. A fence. When the third piece of paper turned out to be a check written to Stephen for $5,000, Henry said, "Okay, that does it. I'm going to call the police."
Grace thought of the changing looks on Belinda's face.
Was she in on it? What if she wasn't, and Stephen was simply going to gaslight her the same way he did me? She could be in trouble when he finds out I've got this stash bag. Or I could.
She told Henry her concerns. "Now that we suspect him of other things, we have to notify the police, Grace. Or we could be accessories to his crimes." She agreed, even though she was afraid of what Stephen might do. He had a temper. Henry made the call.
"Where did you meet him, Gracie? Stephen, I mean."
"At a party. He was a friend of a friend, so I thought he was safe. He was charming. He dazzled me. And now that I think about it, that friend hasn't contacted me since... since I moved in with Stephen. Hm. Some friend."
Fifteen minutes later, a dark unmarked car pulled to the curb in front of Henry's house. Thank God Henry had the presence of mind to tell her to get dressed, so they both met the man at the door when the doorbell sounded.
The man introduced himself as Detective Hooker, and showed his credentials. He said Henry's information had been forwarded to him because he was working on a puzzling set of burglaries and thefts, and this might help his case.
Grace and Henry told Detective Hooker the whole story, starting from last Friday when she got that dump text from Stephen. He recorded the whole thing. It took a long time. He took copies of the texts, pictures of the belongings that she retrieved that morning from Belinda, even the ruined bike. He looked at the jewelry, and took the three pieces of paper, the list, the name, and the check.
"Grace, these things on his list. Do you still have them? Can you check?"
She looked shocked. "I didn't look in my jewelry box." She ran to get it.
"I'm afraid to open it. You do it, Henry."