Caitlyn had been seeing me for about 2 weeks when that fateful night happened. I was 19 years old, and new in town. She was a local prep school girl at Episcopal High, young, but mature in form. That night was the first night we had spent in privacy at her place watching a movie while her mom was out of town. She called me up that afternoon and told me she'd be late from school, but to just come over at 7 pm.
When I showed up she had just arrived and was still in her cute little uniform, with white blouse and plaid skirt which was a bit too short past regulations. We quickly settled down on the couch to watch a movie we had both already seen when she shifted towards me in a manner that put my forearm in contact with her chest. You see, before this we had only engaged in kissing and I hadn't been so forward with this young girl as to try anything with her beyond that. I let my arm stay in that position when suddenly she looked at me with apprehension and I froze, not wanting to scare her off. But she said, "Why don't you take off those jeans and be more comfortable, since we're squeezed on this couch?" Of course I lazily got up and went to the bathroom to remove the jeans.
My hands were shaking from the excitement and I was worried that she would take note of my obvious arousal. When I got back she was leaning on her back with a slight grin on her face. Could this be the prim girl I had been seeing for 2 weeks?
"Caitlyn, move over so I can fit on the couch," I said and she reluctantly acquiesced, turning her face towards the cushion, with her skirt riding up even more to expose her upper thighs. I lay down next to her, spooning her and let my hands drift up where I wouldn't have normally dared, only I was so excited. She took my left hand and placed it on her breast as I shuddered, since I felt that she was wearing no bra. I leaned over and saw it lying on the floor and mentioned it to her. She replied that she was "uncomfortable" in it and decided to undo a few buttons of her shirt as well. I tried very hard to maintain my composure as my crotch began to tighten against her nice bottom.