Katie was a flirt. She wasn't shy about it; in fact she even owned a tight, bright yellow t-shirt that proudly proclaimed it, the word printed boldly across her ample breasts in a parody of the "Squirt" product logo.
Justin was quite familiar with Katie's tits. He and Katie had dated for a while in high school. Although she was only a few months older, she was a senior when he was a junior. Their relationship had been a fairly typical high school one, with a lot of making out and groping, but no penetration or "happy endings".
Katie and Justin had e-mailed a few times right when she went to college but they dwindled as the school year passed. That next summer, a month after Justin's high school graduation, he received an invitation in the mail to a pool party Katie was having at her house. He immediately called her to RSVP.
"Hey you, great to hear from you!" Katie exclaimed.
"So I hear you're having a big party?" Justin asked.
"Oh yeah. My parents are out of town, so I'm having some people over. It will be fun, and there will be booze!" Katie exclaimed. They chatted and caught up on what they'd been up to until she suddenly interrupted, "Hey, sorry, I've got another call. I'll see you at my party, ok?"
Justin wore his swim trunks and a Hawaiian shirt to Katie's pool party. He arrived at the ideal time, just as the party was getting into full swing. There were dozens of people his age in swimwear, enjoying the hot summer sun. While there were guys there than girls, Justin naturally focused his attention on the hot girls in bikinis.
One girl caught him staring, but instead of scowling came over to talk.
"Hi," she said. "I'm Lisa, a friend of Katie's from college!" she introduced herself in a bubbly, excited manner.
"Hey, I'm Justin. Katie and I went to high school together."
"I like your swim trunks," Lisa said, pointing in the general direction of Justin's crotch. As their conversation continued she flirted with him shamelessly, asking him if he liked her own skimpy swimsuit, having him inspect her navel piercing, and otherwise drawing attention to her body.
Justin figured things were going pretty well and that he had a shot with Lisa. Unfortunately for him, she waved at a muscle-bound guy who walked over and joined them, whom she gave a huge hug and kiss on the lips. "Justin, this is my boyfriend, Kevin."
Justin felt annoyed and disappointed at her meaningless flirtation. He excused himself quickly, not wanting to endure watching Lisa make eyes at Kevin. He spied Katie, looking fantastic in her bright, tiny blue bikini and surrounded by a group of four guys, all vying for her attention. For being a slightly curvier girl, Katie always was confident, and not afraid to show some skin. She saw him and waved, but he chose to wait until she was less occupied to try to talk with her.
Justin spent most of the party talking with a guy whose name escaped him, but had interesting stories to tell about his recent trip to South America. He watched Katie from a distance, observing her flirt with the guys, touching them, and just plain drawing attention to herself. Every now and then she'd blow Justin a kiss. He'd smile and wave back.
The sun set just as the beer ran out and the party started to disperse. Justin walked over to Katie to finally say both hello and goodbye, but instead she grabbed his hand and said "Come sit in the hot tub with me! I've missed you!" she exclaimed, pressing her practically naked body against his in a warm embrace.
After agreeing, Justin soon found that he wasn't the only guy that Katie had invited to join her in the hot tub, as there was already a slightly older guy waiting for her there. "Justin, this is Clint. Clint, Justin," Katie said, introducing them.
Justin learned that Clint was 23, and seemed to Justin to be a little too full of himself. He admitted that Clint had that air of cockiness that appealed to girls like Katie. Still, Justin didn't feel threatened, and enjoyed being near Katie and was willing to tolerate her choice in company.
The last of the other remaining guests said their goodbyes, and it was now just Clint, Justin, and Katie. "I gotta pee!" Katie suddenly said, giggling and hopping out of the tub. She didn't bother with a towel, and both Justin and Clint admired her ass wiggling as she scooted into the house.
"So, bro, have you hit that?" Clint asked Justin once Katie was out of earshot.
"Me? No. We used to go out, in high school, but she was a virgin then. We didn't go past second base. Why, have you?" Justin wasn't sure how he felt about this guy having gotten the woman Justin wanted but never was able to have, who had filled many of his fantasies during nights of masturbation.
"Not yet, but man, she gives some great head. She sucked me off in my truck outside this bar a couple weekends ago."
Justin wasn't sure what to feel. He was shocked at how casually Clint was revealing this information. He was a jealous, mostly that this stranger had been able to casually get farther with Katie in an evening than he had in months of dating. Yet, he also felt a bit excited at the scandalous confession. He tried to play it cool. "Yeah, I bet she really knows how to use her mouth."
"Oh fuck yeah. Those sorority girls, they really know how to suck like a Hoover. I think it's part of their training or something. I figure she invited me to this party so we could finish what we started," Clint stated, as though it was already a done deal.
Justin shrugged in response. He knew that Katie probably just wanted the party to be as full as possible with guys who found her attractive and would give her attention, and that Clint wasn't particularly special. He could tell Clint wanted him to take the hint and excuse himself, but he was feeling a little bitter and didn't want to make it easy on Katie and Clint. If they asked him to leave it was one thing, but he wasn't going to just leave on his own.
Katie came back carrying more drinks. She slid back into the tub gracefully, grinning wickedly. Once again Justin noticed how good she looked in her little blue bikini, and how much she'd firmed up her body since high school. She hadn't lost those ample tits though, which were dominating Justin's attention.
"You boys are so far away, I'm getting lonely. Why don't you each scoot closer to me?" she asked. Justin was the first to move. Clint seemed a bit hesitant, but didn't want to look uptight, and soon both men were pressed against one of Katie's sides. "See, isn't this better?" Katie said. She placed one hand on each guy's thigh under the water.
Katie turned to whisper in Clint's ear. Justin tried to listen, but was quickly distracted as Katie's hand slid up his thigh to his crotch. His cock became hard instantly as she teased him under the water through his swim trunks. He wondered if Clint was receiving the same treatment. He glanced over and saw that Katie was kissing Clint, their tongues deep in each other's mouths. It was impossible to tell if her other hand was still on Clint's thigh, or was on his package.
The situation was surreal to Justin, but he let his cock do the thinking and just went with it. Katie wasn't his girlfriend, nor was she Clint's. She could do whatever she wanted, and if that involved rubbing his cock while she made out with another guy, so be it. He was euphoric to have her hand rubbing his hard dick. It had been a while since Justin had gotten lucky, and he was ready to take what he could get.
Katie broke her kiss, turned to Justin and winked before lifting both her hands out of the water. "Is it ok with you guys if I get more comfortable?" she asked. Without waiting for a response she untied her bikini top and cast it aside. Justin soaked in the sight of his ex's lovely tits, exposed to him fully for the first time in over a year.
"I'll get naked if you guys do," Katie said. "But you both have to." Clint looked slightly annoyed. Justin could see him doing the math. It was a sort of twisted prisoner's dilemma that Katie had set up: Clint needed to play along to get what he wanted, even if it wasn't heading to his preferred outcome. Justin put the ball in Clint's court by standing up and slipping off his bathing trunks.
The fact was, Justin had a large cock and loved to show it off whenever he could. He'd been made aware of the fact by the second girl who gave him a blowjob, a girl who had gotten around and seen plenty of cocks, who was very enthusiastic about the size and shape of his. As it came into view, Katie smiled at the sight of Justin's erection, licking her lips slightly. She'd felt it rub up against her while dry-humping, but this was her first experience seeing just how well endowed her slightly younger ex-boyfriend truly was.
"Your move, Clint," Katie said to the other man slyly. "Are you in, or are you out?" She stood up and began toying with her bikini bottoms. "My house, my rules, and I say either you get naked or you go home." Katie's navel piercing dangled enticingly, pointing down towards paradise. As Katie pulled her bottoms down slightly it became clear to Justin she couldn't have much in the way of pubic hair, as none had yet made an appearance. Justin was still standing, wanting Katie to get a good long look at his full erection.
Clint sighed and resigned himself to his fate. He quickly shed his trucks and sat back into the water. His cock appeared quite average; neither impressive nor especially small. Justin remembered that Katie had presumably seen it before, when she had given Clint head.
"My turn," Katie said gleefully, finally sliding her bottom off her hips. Justin got a good look at her pussy lips and the almost complete lack of pubic hair between her legs. Only a small patch sat above her clit. "You like my trim job, Justin?" Katie asked. "It's very fashionable you know. All the girls in my sorority either shave most or all of theirs. And the guys love it. Don't you guys love it?" Katie said, thrusting her pussy out slightly to model her haircut, standing unabashedly nude in her parent's hot tub in front of two very horny guys.
"Yes, it's gorgeous," Justin replied.
"Want to touch it?" Katie asked seductively turning towards him and staring into Justin's dark eyes with her piercing blue ones.
Justin nodded and reached out, stroking Katie's tummy, then drifting his hand lower, between her thighs. He glanced over at Clint, who was obviously stewing over the lack of attention but not willing to punt on the situation just yet.
"Clint, I'd love it if you would touch my boobs," Katie said.
'So that's it,' Justin thought. 'Katie wants a threesome. If that's what it takes to finally get a piece of her, so be it.'
Clint seemed to have resigned himself to his fate, and stood up behind Katie to cup her tits, and presumably grind his dick against her ass. Justin simply caressed Katie's outer lips for a bit, allowing her to get wetter and more excited. He had to admit, he felt a strange sense of jealousy watching Clint manhandle his ex's tits. He seemed a bit rough, but Katie looked to be enjoying it. Or perhaps she was enjoying Justin's fingers.
Katie cooed, obviously loving all the attention. "Justin, would you lick my pussy? I've always wondered if you were good with your tongue," she said to him seductively.
Justin slipped forward and extended his tongue to lick her bare lips. He was very aware of the other guy behind her, groping her tits and kissing her. Still, her pussy looked so sexy, and he wanted to show her what he'd learned. Justin teased her gently with the tip of his tongue, brushing it against her clit before lapping once at her swollen pussy lips.
