Summary: In Chapter 1, Ali tells BFF Nikki about her recurring, sexy dream, where, in ancient times, she is captured and ravished by a brutal, handsome warlord. That Friday, after discussing their most recent nsfw posts to Reddit, Nikki invites Ali to be a last-minute fill-in at a party given by Mu Nu Mu fraternity alums. She and Sean meet and become partners in a very racy drinking game. Driven by the eroticism of the game and a killer libation, the party becomes increasingly wild. As things spin out of control and it becomes an orgy, like everyone else, Ali and Sean have sex. Chapter 2 begins after the party.
***
"OMG, Alison Bibelot! Sean's cock was SO huge! How did you possibly take it all?"
It was Sunday afternoon, and Nikki Nelson had dropped in on her BFF. She wanted all the detes, a play-by-play of her friend's sexual escapades. She also swore over and over that the party Friday night had been SO TOTALLY DIFFERENT from the week before. She hadn't intended to invite Ali to an orgy. There had to have been something potent in the punch, maybe shrooms or ecstasy, because everyone had tripped out and just gone wild.
After each couple had finished screwing and started trading partners and forming foursomes, Nikki and George had quickly left the party. After which they'd basically alternated between making love and fucking all Friday night, then all Saturday, and all Saturday night. Whenever they came up for air, George's balls needing time to recharge, one of them would recall an instance from the party.
There were so many lascivious memories: Mary's high-pitched shrieks when she came; how Juan grabbed tiny Maria and cycled her up and down on his cock, basically jacking off into it; of the long drools of Floyd's cum dripping from Shari's lips; how Don's semen oozed out of Alice's vulva when she laughingly did Kegels just after he pulled out; and especially of Sean fucking Ali like a wild stallion run amok. Reliving any one of them would re-stoke Nikki and George's libidos, and they'd be off to the races once again.
Ali could tell that her friend was in love from the tone of her voice when Nikki gave details of how considerate a lover George was. While he wasn't as good with his tongue as Ali, he took direction well, and when he'd gone out for food, he returned with every one of her favorite treats. And roses! Nikki's eyes were dreamy as she gave each and every detail of how he let her ride him to her heart's content, stopping her whenever he was close so it could go on forever. Nikki had never had so many orgasms.
They kept at it until George had to leave for Sunday brunch with his parents. Having spilled the beans, told Ali all the saucy specifics of what she'd done with George, Nikki wanted her friend to reciprocate. Give a minute-by-minute description of all that had happened with Sean.
Alison was still in turmoil. The party Friday, her continual building arousal as the game became ever more salacious, then being bent over and screwed so massively by Sean - her most incredible sex, ever - had been fabulous. Ali's vagina still tingled from having been so stretched, so thoroughly reamed by Sean's enormous cock. And her cervix occasionally spasmed from how Sean had unintentionally bludgeoned it, lunging against it uncontrollably with each ejaculation. And he had just kept coming. His third eruption burst the condom, and the many others filled her pussy to overflowing. It had been so erotic, so ecstatic, so raw and intense, she'd been transported.
But then came disaster.
Sean had been truly tender and protective after they'd finished, coddling Ali in his arms as he lay back on the couch. Covering her with their peploses to shield her from prying eyes, holding her gently, stroking her everywhere, and kissing her sweetly. Apologizing profusely for breaking the condom, and taking her home immediately when things got out-of-hand.
It was lewd enough that all the couples started trading partners. Ali had been shocked, but because everyone was older than her - except Nikki, who like Ali was 19 - and they were friends who partied together every week, she thought that maybe was de rigueur. She just cuddled closer to Sean and tried to ignore them.
But when Don had sidled over, began to kiss Ali, and snaked his hand under the peplos, groping her still swamped pussy, she'd recoiled, stunned and affronted. Sean had leapt up, pushed Don roughly away, and said, "Let's get out of here, Alison." Only much later did she understand Don's bitter retort, "Don't worry, Sean. A Mu Nu never rats on a bro."
Once in his car Ali had snuggled close, still aglow from their passionate mating. She was totally enthralled with Sean, her heart, mind and soul captured by this wonderful, considerate, strikingly handsome man who had suddenly appeared in her life and swept her away. And fucked her like she'd never, ever been fucked. Though he'd been rough, almost animalistic, she realized that the libidinous atmosphere of the party, the killer punch, and her own purposely flirtatious, seductive behavior had provoked him.
And she'd loved it.
As Sean drove, Alison couldn't believe all that had happened. That, to win the game, she'd actually shown strangers her shaved pussy and plugged butt. And then let herself get fucked in front of everyone. Of course, they were all copulating, too, but still... Nonetheless, she felt totally enraptured, very much in love. As she basked in the rosy afterglow, the wild part of her that had been unleashed at the party reemerged and Sean's penis began to grow under the teasing touches of her fingers. Fortunately, she had the foresight to take it out of his pants before it got too big.
She could only get the head and a couple inches in her mouth, but Sean had seemed to like it. A lot. It appeared there might be a photo finish as they neared her apartment. Just as they arrived, Sean gasped, tensed and abruptly pulled to the side of the road. While savoring his moaning and heaving, images of oil gushers flashed in her brain as the wonderful penis between her lips surrendered to her tongue's commands and spewed fountains of hot semen into the back of her throat. Ali swallowed madly as she kept massaging his testicles, stroking the shaft, and licking the head, making him erupt time and again. She stopped only when he began to wince, after his cock had become too sensitive.
As he recovered, Sean had hugged her affectionately, kissed her very sweetly, and told her she was truly special, incredibly beautiful, and amazingly hot. Then he shook himself, stuffed his penis back into his pants, got out of the car and showed Ali to her door. She held his hand as they walked the short distance, wishing she'd cleaned her apartment before leaving for the party. She resolved that she'd just sweep aside any mess on their way to her bed.
After they'd kissed again, Ali invited him in, wanting, needing this most magical of nights to continue. She'd been puzzled and disappointed when he had said he needed to go, that there was something he just had to do. He seemed suddenly evasive, giving no specifics of what was so important, and worst of the worst, he had just primly kissed her goodnight and walked away. Without so much as asking for Ali's number.
Watching his car disappear, Alison was again mystified, then crushed, and finally devastated. She had felt such a bond with him, as if fate itself had brought them together. She'd been certain of their intuitive and amorous connection during the game, moved by his protecting her from getting too drunk and Don's coarse advance, and though she had violated her rule not to have sex on a first date, it had been the best ever. She truly believed that he loved it, too, both fucking her at the party and the fellatio in the car.
What had happened? Why did he so abruptly leave? What had she done wrong? Let him fuck her? Giving him head while he drove? Had asking him in seemed demanding, presumptuous? Her mind roiled with questions, doubts and angst. And, like massive threatening black thunderheads, looming over all her crisis was the recurring question: was she going to get pregnant?
It had all been too much and Ali had slept only in fits between crying jags in her lonely bed in her empty apartment. It didn't help that the fiery tingle in her anus - the butt plug's removal proved even more painful than its insertion - kept reminding her of everything.
Saturday she was exhausted, hung over, and had been nauseous and dizzy from the side effects of the morning-after pill she forced herself to go out and buy. The cramps had been wicked, and she stayed in bed most of the day, morose and mystified, bemoaning her situation, and wondering why Nikki didn't call.
When she did drop in Sunday, so wired that she just launched into her litany of fabulous fucking with George, Ali had been swept along and had briefly forgotten her heartache. But when Nikki harkened back to Friday night, wanting to hear all that had happened, exclaiming, "OMG, Alison Bibelot! Sean's cock was SO huge! How did you possibly take it all?" Alison's sorrow and pain came flooding back.
Ali had tried to make a joke, saying, "Well, it's not like I had a choice. Sean just bent me over the table, lined it up and..." Her voice cracked as she broke down.
Nikki -- a true friend -- took Ali in her arms and held her tight through yet another good cry. Once Ali had explained all that had happened, Nikki made her keep talking, and every time her friend expressed her doubts, her anguish, Nikki had an answer.
"What did I do wrong, Nikki? I really, truly thought we were connecting. But now I think I must have screwed it up somehow. First off, I threw myself at him, acted like a slut. "
"Well, you did come on to him, but a lot of guys like that. Sean really seemed to..."
"I totally acted like a tramp, was way too forward. I kissed him first. That was a mistake."
"Later on he was kissing you, babe, and I mean really kissing you."