*Obviously not reality for so many reasons.
This was hard to categorize. I ended up with Erotic Coupling because that's the most common theme here. But (and sorry for some spoilers) there is also a little bit of anal, group sex, and light incest/taboo themes. I know some of these things aren't for some people, so I wanted to give warning!
I hope you enjoy the fantasy.*
Everything was going great for Greg Fuller until the Barry twins arrived.
Greg was the most athletic, confident, and popular member of the Elite Sports program at Cinderdale High. This was especially impressive considering that the Elite Sports program was already made up from the most athletic, confident, and popular students in the school. He had entered the program in grade 9 and spent the entire time becoming the king of the class. Now that it was the final few months of the final year, every student catered to his whims.
The program took a rare 5 years of high school to complete, but none of the 18 and 19-year-old students complained. Anybody able to make it to the fifth year was guaranteed a great sports scholarship at a prestigious school. Greg had played a slow, patient game of politics, wits, and manipulation to finally get to the point in which he was able to use sex as the ultimate weapon. He had all the girls under his thumb, and none of the boys challenged his role as king because Greg kept them plenty happy using his personal harem that he affectionately referred to as the Elite Sluts.
Sure, it was easy living for Greg now that all the girls of Elite Sports thought that their only reasons for existence were sports and cock, but Greg felt that he had worked hard to get to that point. Why not enjoy it?
But everything about the Barry twins rubbed Greg the wrong way. They were like a weird alternate version of Greg and his own twin sister, Melissa. Whereas Greg and Melissa were both blonde-haired and blue-eyed, Ted and Connie Barry countered with dark brown hair and eyes.
Ted at least seemed very intelligent, just like Greg, but Connie was too quiet to tell and Melissa was - to put it nicely - pretty stupid. Both the Barry twins were - of course - in the Elite Sports program whereas Melissa was repeating the standard 12th grade.
Greg had practically forgotten that a transfer was even possible. He knew the Elite Sports program was country-wide, but it was so hard to get in and to stay in that he never thought he'd actually be around for a transfer; there seemed to be too few people overall. Greg's own fifth year program had been whittled down to 13 people. The program was prestigious for a reason.
But, rare or not, transfer the Barry twins did. Forced to move because of their single mother's job, and now part of the Cinderdale Elite Sports program that had been otherwise largely unchanged in 5 years.
The night before the arrival of the Barry twins gave no sense of the impending trouble they would provide. It had been business as usual...
***
Cindy bounced on Greg's dick, letting out breathy moans into his ear. Greg sat with his phone on one ear while he looked at a piece of paper over the naked, skinny teen who was clearly enjoying his 8 inches.
"Sorry Roger, Kyle booked out Sophie all week."
Cindy clawed at Greg's back.
"I know I don't usually book out full weeks, but Kyle had his fourth or worse pick for two straight weeks, so this is my olive branch."
Cindy pulled at Greg's hair as she shuddered into an orgasm.
"Keep fucking, slut," Greg said to her, "What, Roger? Yeah, it's Cindy. Oh stop your whining, you had Cindy last night. Why did you want Sophie? Her tits? Because Rhonda is free tonight. ...What? Oh fuck off, just because being dom is her specialty doesn't mean she can't suck your cock as good as any of the other sluts."
Cindy fell into another orgasm, shaking violently on Greg's huge dick.
"Jesus Christ, Cindy," said Greg, "Look. Roger. I don't know why I'm arguing. Rhonda AND both Indian Princesses are free tonight. Fuck all three if you'd like, but Sophie's with Kyle. Hm? Okay, I'll text her. Now fuck off, I need to dump a load in this whore."
Greg hung up and started to text Rhonda, but grinned at Cindy first. She was the one with whom he had started it all, so Greg admittedly had a bit of a soft spot for her. She was almost the only one he fucked these days. If he considered anybody second in command, it was Cindy.
"Turn around and ride me backwards," he commanded, "I don't want to see your face when I empty into you."
"Uh-huh," Cindy consented with her trademarked pouty lips. She oozed so much sexuality that she couldn't open her mouth without making any straight guy want to stuff it full of his cock and cum.
'Roger needs ur fat tits, slut. Go over asap.'
Greg pressed send on the text to Rhonda as Cindy turned around and used the desk to support herself as she lowered her pussy back down onto Greg's hard prick. He put his phone down and finally let himself appreciate the incredibly toned teen athlete pleasuring him.
"Uggh, not long now, slut," he said. Cindy giggled.
Greg saw Rhonda's confirmation light up his phone as Cindy's masterful thrusting pushed him over the edge.
"I'm cumming, slut! What do you say?"
"Thaannk youuu," Cindy moaned as Greg shot streams of his thick cum into the tight teen.
The moment he was finished he stood up without warning, causing Cindy to collapse on the floor.
"Clean and leave," he said. Cindy giggled again.
"Of course!" she said before obeying. She expertly and quickly cleaned the mix of her and Greg's cum off his dick with her tongue before swiftly getting dressed. Greg threw himself onto his bed.
"See ya," he said lazily, but kindly.
"You bet, stud," said Cindy, "fuck, I always sleep so good after a fuck like that."
Greg smiled at her and watched her fit ass twitch in her short shorts until she was out of his room. He heard her say bye to his parents and grinned. They had long stopped giving him grief for his actions. His mom was a pushover who hated conflict and his dad was an easy bribe. It only took a single titjob from Sophie to shut him up. It had probably been the most action he had seen in a decade.
How two busty girls were able to make fifth year Elite Sports was a mystery to Greg, but he wasn't complaining. Rhonda was unusually chesty for a tall girl, but was still the track and field queen. Sophie, despite her short height and giant tits, was an all-star soccer goalie. Greg figured they both paid a fortune for sports bras strong enough to hold their DD and F cups respectively.