Eight-day Hanukkah Challenge
From the time she tried to blow me at my Bar-Mitzvah to now, our second year in college, I always knew Susie to be wild. She wasn't Jewish like me, but since we hung out together from childhood, she knew many of our traditions and celebrated our holidays with me, except for Yom Kippur, the holy day of atonement. She insisted that since she wasn't religious, she didn't have to ask forgiveness for anything she did.
Shortly after Thanksgiving break, we sat around with friends, smoking weed and contemplating some fun after the semester's final exams. The conversation turned from holiday traditions to sexual proclivity.
"Your problem, Randy, is that you've only ever fucked one girl," she teased me. Susie was the only girl I did have sex with. Although our relationship was more of a friendship than a romantic coupling, she sometimes took pity on me and insisted on reliving my sexual tensions.
"Is that a Jewish thing?" Jenny asked. As evident from our earlier discussion of holiday traditions, I was the only Jewish boy in our circle of friends. Jenny had adopted celebrating Kwanza, which, like Hanukkah, took place over many days. "I mean, being so unsure of yourself that you can't just enjoy sex for the pleasure of it?"
"Wow, Randy, she's diggin' into you hard," Susie shot at me.
"I'm not a whore like some people I know," was my lame response.
"So, I've got a new spin on celebrating the holidays this year," Susie said excitedly. "This year, I challenge you, Randy, to fuck a different girl on each of the eight days of Hanukkah."
I was stunned. What a crazy thing to propose for me. I couldn't get one other girl than Susie my whole life, and she only fucked me out of pity. It wasn't that I was ugly or fat. I always worked out and took care of my body. I was just so unsure of myself. Girls were not attracted to my lack of confidence. I suppose I just accepted that, and someday, I'll meet someone who will understand me and want me anyway.
I watched Susie whisper something in Jenny's and Karen's ear. They seemed to perk up all of a sudden.
"I'll take day one," Karen called out gleefully. Her boyfriend gave her a dirty look. "Don't get jealous, Kenny. It's just for fun and to help Randy gain some confidence," she told him, though I don't think he was all right with it.
"Then, I'll do day two," Jenny chimed up. "I'll give you a taste of chocolate you'll never forget."
I was still speechless. What did Susie get me into? I couldn't back out, not with the peer pressure on me. I must have had a fearful expression when Susie tried to reassure me.
"I'll be your
shammash
. Isn't that what they call the helper candle on the Menorah?" she asked innocently. I didn't know what she meant by being my helper. Was she going to help me get girls to have sex with? Was she going to coach me? How was this going to work?
Later, when we were walking home, I asked Susie what she had whispered to the girls to make them volunteer so readily.
"I told them how thick and hard your circumcised cock is. I told them how good it feels to have my pussy stretched," she responded casually.
**************
Christmas and the first day of Hanukkah fell on the same day, December 25
th
. As my 'helper' in the challenge, Susie arranged for us to meet with Karen and her boyfriend Kenny, at Karen's apartment near the campus. I was concerned that Kenny would be there, but he insisted, stating that if Karen was going to have sex with someone besides himself, he needed to be there. Susie and Karen didn't mind, but I wasn't sure how comfortable I'd be in that situation.
"You've been naked with other men in locker rooms. So, why are you freaking out about Kenny?" Susie tried to calm me down.
"Yeah, but we don't have hard-ons in the locker room," I told her.
We smoked weed to get relaxed. Then Karen took the initiative to come on to me. I assumed she had discussed the seduction details with Susie and maybe with Kenny; he seemed to be taking it easily.
Karen knelt before me, pulling down my pants and boxers, taking my cock into her mouth. She felt different from the way Susie sucked me, and I quickly got hard. I gestured for her to pull back so I wouldn't come quickly.
I finished undressing, watching Karen strip. Her body was thicker than Susie's, enticing differently. Her large, malleable breasts were fun to play with. I sucked on her nipples, eliciting soft moans. Susie and Kenny were already making out naked on the bed when we joined them.
"Eat her out," Susie whispered in my ear. I didn't require encouragement. Her sopping wet pussy tasted good. Her clit was easily found, having swollen to a discernable nub, begging to be sucked on.
Susie came several times, bathing my face in her hot juices. "Fuck me, Randy," she cried out. "I want your thick cock in me," she begged some more. She spread her legs, beckoning my cock to fill her hot pussy. I thrust into her out of an uncontrollable desire to feel myself inside her juicy, hot cunt.
"Fuck me hard. Come inside. Fill me up," Karen called on me. I relentlessly pounded her instinctively. I felt my balls tighten up. I was ready to explode. I thrust my cock as deep into her cervical opening as far as I could push, shooting my sperm in several plunges.
"Oh my god," Karen sighed when she came down from her orgasm. Kenny was banging Susie from behind as she bent over the foot of the bed.
"I borrowed a bottle of wine from my parents," Karen said as she poured some into four glasses. "Cheers to your day one," Susie toasted. We chatted for a while, and everyone seemed satisfied. I was, and I felt somewhat more confident.
"You should get circumcised, Kenny," Karen said to her boyfriend.
"Yeah, Kenny, girls like Kosher dick," Susie added to the chiding fun.
**********
Jenny didn't have a boyfriend. She dated but never got serious, relishing the romance rather than the rigors of maintaining a steady relationship. Her parents were very conservative, and although she didn't necessarily share their views, she was wary of random, free-wheeling sex. She let Susie know that she wanted sex with Randy on a one-on-one basis, privately.
Susie arranged a hotel room for me after a legitimate date with Jenny. Her aunt Kelli, in her early forties, was Susie's 'more adult' source of alternative behavior. Kelli was relatable to the free-spirited Susie.
"Can you get your parents' car? Kelli needs to register the plate number for your stay," Susie casually demanded from me late Thursday morning, the second day of Hanukkah. I approached my mother and father with some trepidation since it was unusual for me to make such a request.
"I have a date tonight," I explained. "Can I use one of your cars?" I asked my parents.
"Susie has a car. Are you going on a date with somebody else?" my mother asked nosily.
"Well, yes. I have a date with Jenny. I met her in my biology class at school," I told them.
"That's great," my father exclaimed. "Take my Mercedes. Impress the girl," he told me with pride in his voice.
I texted Susie and told her I would be in my father's Mercedes. I hoped the hotel was not in a seedy area of town where it would be stolen. She texted back and assured me Kelli would ensure it was safe for us.
That evening, I picked Jenny up from her home. Her parents questioned me, trying to ascertain my motives, but were impressed that I was well dressed and driving a Mercedes. We went to a nice restaurant for dinner. It was a wonderful evening, and after all my apprehensions, I was comfortable being with Jenny.
Jenny confessed she was not sexually active and had little experience with men, only once before having had intercourse. "I don't know what I was thinking when I offered to do this," she told me after dinner. "Now, I feel safe and comfortable with you."
Susie had given me the room key earlier after her aunt Kelli had checked in. Jenny and I went to the room. I thought the situation should have been awkward, but it wasn't. We kissed. The contact of our bodies was natural and easy.
"We should enjoy the shower," Jenny suggested. I watched her undress. Seeing her perfectly formed, black body made me think of a goddess. We subtly enjoyed each other's bodies as we washed in the warm water. My arousal was evident but not impetuously demanding.
Slowly, we kissed passionately. Our hands caressed each other, touching every accessible area of each other. "We don't need to go all the way if you don't want to," I told her. "This is beautiful as it is," I said sincerely.
"I want to make love to you," she said softly. She guided my hand to her wet, dripping pussy. I inserted a finger gently and began to rub her clit softly. Jenny exploded in a series of orgasms, her body writhing to my touch.
She motioned for me to roll over on my back. Jenny straddled me and easily lowered herself, her hot pussy engulfing my throbbing cock. Steadily, she rocked back and forth and then up and down. I opened my eyes to behold her perfectly formed breasts bouncing up and down to her rhythm.
"Don't come in me," she softly cried as she reached another orgasm. I felt her pussy clenching on my cock, and I felt about ready to come. Gently pushing her off me, she understood and grabbed my shaft, lubricated with her cum, and finished me off.
I called my father, letting him know I would be late, the car was fine, and we were safe. He thanked me for calling and told me to continue having a good time; he wasn't concerned when I got home. I kissed Jenny and held her body close to mine as we lay naked in the bed.
"I will always remember this moment," she told me softly.
"So will I," I responded.
*************
"Randy, I'm not getting good responses for tonight," Susie told me late afternoon on day three. "I can't find any girlfriends who can take care of you."