I can't believe how much she hated him.
Hated
him.
Of course, it shouldn't have been a surprise. After all, I did meet them in couples' group therapy. It wasn't as if we had met them under the best of circumstances.
If you've read
Confession Time: Motel Hijinks
, you'll know that I've started to jot down some of my actual experiences and not just relegate things to pure fiction. I love storytelling as a rule, but sometimes there are moments that can be drawn from my life that make for short vignettes worth writing about. Some of them make me look like a hero, other times they can make me look like an utter asshole.
This one falls somewhere in-between, but probably closer on the spectrum to 'asshole', if I'm being completely honest with myself.
Let's face it. If you're in marriage counseling, you're not in a very good mental place to begin with. This was definitely true in my case. I had found myself in a situation that was abusive, but this was before it was acknowledged that men could even
be
abused in relationships. Back then, and even to a certain extent today, if a man is in a physically and emotionally abusive relationship with a woman it was seen as
his
responsibility.
I didn't want to get divorced, though, and was willing to do whatever it took to save our marriage. My wife, whom I'll call Ellen (the only untrue part of the story), claimed that she wanted us to 'get back to good,' as well. So when the counselor suggested we try group therapy, we went.
To be completely truthful, I didn't want to air our dirty laundry to complete strangers. I'm a very private person by nature, and to me it gave me the same panicky feeling of standing stark naked in the middle of Times Square blowing an air horn while flashing lights lit me up like a rave party. I simply felt far too exposed.
There were a dozen of us, plus the therapist, sitting in a large circle. We came in all shapes, sizes and colors. The one thing we had in common was that each of us - to a person - was profoundly unhappy. I think it was the first time any of us had been put in a position to lay all our grievances out in the open for the world to see.
Some of the women took to this new audience like fish to water. They held nothing back, raking their husbands over the coals. Other couples were the other way around, as the husbands were truly intimidating and the wives opted not to participate.
That's probably the reason why we tended to gravitate towards Glynne and Aaron. Aaron, like me, worked in tech. Glynne, like Ellen, had a mischievous, snarky sense of humor. All things considered, it appeared that of all the couples in the room the four of us might just have a chance of succeeding. Of course, we were
wrong
, but we didn't know that at the time. All I can say is that we hit it off very well before the session, and even found ourselves agreeing with each other during much of the hour.
Therapy had a strange effect on me. Ellen had no problem "being Ellen," bringing up any and all of my faults - both real and imaginary. "He's the kind of guy who would cheat in a heartbeat," she'd said.
Everyone turned and looked at me. I hadn't cheated on Ellen. It didn't matter, of course, because now she had managed - in one fell swoop - to paint me as a bad guy with a dozen people and her as the victim.
"Is this true?" asked the therapist.
"No," I said, firmly. I wasn't sure how to handle this. I was livid at Ellen, but didn't want to come across as "the lady doth protest
too
much" by overreacting, either. So, instead, I do what I normally do. I shut down.
"I think," one of the more vitriolic women piped up, "that you better think about why
she
thinks you'd cheat on her 'in a heartbeat.'"
There was general agreement from many of the other women in the room, including the therapist.
"Or, maybe
you
should stay out of it," the woman's husband scolded her. Then
they
were off to the races.
Grateful that the pressure was off me for the moment, I stayed quiet and pretended that the earth swallowed me whole.
"I didn't say that," Ellen suddenly said, snapping me out of my thoughts to the present. She was looking at the woman with unrestrained anger. "I said that he
could
cheat because things have been so difficult between us."
It was pure gaslighting, because that's not what she had said at all. The other woman stared at Ellen, gobsmacked, at her reversal. What about the unspoken wives' camaraderie? Women sticking together? Well, she didn't know Ellen like
I
knew Ellen. She just got a taste of what I had to live with on a daily basis.
Even so, I probably took away the wrong message. As bad as Ellen had been, at least two - maybe three - couples had been far, far worse. By comparison, Ellen looked like June Cleaver, complete with doting attitude and pearl necklace. All I could think about was,
at least I didn't have it as bad as those other people.
I figured that if we weren't
that
far gone, then perhaps we may be able to come back from the brink. I had a terrible habit of trying to look for the light in a pitch-dark room with no windows and latch on to the
possibility
of finding a flashlight as my savior. I'd drive forward with the hope of finding it, rather than simply opening the door and walking out even when I knew exactly where it was.
Nevertheless, after the session we were gathering our things when Glynne and Aaron came up to us.
"Hey guys," Glynne asked. "We were wondering if you would like to go get a coffee or something. We don't often get the chance to socialize with other couples and," she gestured around the room, "it looks like we have some things in common."
After Ellen's performance, I had no idea why they would have asked us out for coffee. Maybe it was a matter of the fact that we were more approachable, comparatively speaking, than everyone else. All I knew was that I was dreading going back home with Ellen and was open to any distraction. Looking back, I wonder if they had the same thought.
I was a bit surprised when Ellen agreed. Maybe it was the vitriol of some of the other couples that made us feel like we were the 'normal' ones, but it turned out to be a great afternoon. Anyone who might have observed the four of us would have thought that we were longtime friends catching up.
It was the first time in a long time that things with Ellen felt like they used to. I think that anyone who has been in a bad relationship or having gone through a long period of tough times can relate. After walking on eggshells for months, never knowing when an innocuous comment will blow up into a full-fledged fight, being able to feel like a 'team' again can be like breathing oxygen after being submerged under water for too long.
Little did we know that it was just masking deep-seated disaster.
At the time, though, we all got on like a house on fire. All four of us interacted together; it wasn't as if Aaron and I talked tech and Glynne and Ellen talked about their own things. We