When I woke up the next morning, my first reaction was confusion, then the realization of where I was, and then immediately a deep sense of regret and heartache. I checked my phone. 7:30 am.
I reached behind me. Empty. Carly must have gotten up early to take care of the kids. I rolled onto my back and stared at the ceiling. I listened to the scampering of kids running up and down the hallway and the calls to breakfast from the more responsible adults in the group. The events of the previous night were still fresh in my mind.
The moment Rachel walked in. The way she seemed so bitchy, yet so vulnerable at the same time. The way I treated her body. Fuck, I thought, she had a great body. When she asked -- no --Β begged me, with that quiet little voice... to choke her. The way my fingers wrapped around her soft neck. The way she responded. The way my dick looked sliding in and out of her incredibly tight pussy.
My hand reached for my growing erection. I squeezed my cock, like Rachel had done only a few hours before. I slowly stroked my dick under the covers. I remembered cumming on her face and tongue. How she looked when she was on her knees, begging to cover her with my seed.
FUCK.
What had I done?
I released my grip and covered my face. My mind was spinning. Thoughts came crashing in from every angle.
I had cheated on my wife. I literally cheated. I was a cheater.
I was that asshole that I always prided myself on never being. The guy I looked down on and pittied.
And, obviously, Carly knew. She had to know. It's her best friend, you asshole. That's why she left the room. And now she's going to leave you. And she's going to tell everyone. And Rachel is going to cry and tell everyone that I raped her and it was my fault.
FUCK.
I'm going to lose my family. My kids are going to grow up hating me. What the fuck have I done.
My skin was crawling. My heart was racing. I couldn't get out of my own head. I couldn't leave my body. It wasn't all a terrible, erotic dream. And what made it worse, we had two full days of vacationing together ahead of us. Obviously, that would have to be cancelled. Everyone would know why. My reputation will be ruined. All our friends will know...
Suddenly, a knock on the door. Tap tap tap. "Honey?" Carly called from the other side of the door as she slowly opened it.
"Uh... yeah sweetheart." I croaked. "I'm awake. It's okay, you can come in." I tried to sound nonchalant. Was I overdoing it, I wondered?
Carly slipped into the room and closed the door with a click behind her. She was wearing the pajama set we all wore Christmas morning, a red and black plaid long sleeved button-down shirt and matching pants. "You came to bed so late, I figured I'd let you sleep in a bit." She came towards the bed and pulled the covers back before slipping in and cuddling up next to me.
She laid her head onto my chest and draped a leg over mine. I wrapped my arm around her and squeezed her shoulder as I pulled her in closer. Carly snuggled into me, and I kissed the top of her head.
I felt a sense of peace for a moment, before dread come over me again. Maybe she doesn't know. This isn't the behavior of a woman who has just been cheated on. Is it? Is this a trick? Maybe it's a trap to get me to confess?
FUCK.
Carly sighed. It felt like contentment, not despair... but my brain was such a mess it couldn't decipher the difference.
"Everything okay honey?"
Carly giggled. "Of course. I'm so happy. I love this place! The kids are all getting along, Erin and Bob are doing breakfast today, and they kicked me out of the kitchen and sent me back in here with you."
She hugged me and kissed my chest.
FUCK.
I was riddled with guilt. My heart was beating so fast, I was sure she could feel it. And she did.
"Wow, your heart is racing... is that because of me?" Carly looked up and smiled at me. Her blue eyes stared deep into my soul. The little consolation I felt being held by my wife drained out of me as a pang of anguish and guilt washed over my body.
"uh huh," I smiled back. It was all I could get out.
"Oh really?" Carly had that mischievous look in her eyes. The kind she gets when she's horny, which was candidly not often. Most times it was me instigating sex. Actually, every time it was me. Carly called that my perceived reality, but not actual reality. Maybe that was true. But the rarity of that look was something I had instinctually learned to respond to. When Carly was ready, I was going to take full advantage.
And my body reacted instinctively. Carly reached down and found my still semi-hard cock and rubbed it over my shorts.
"Mmmmm... is this because of me too?" she asked coyly.
"Ungh... yeah." I managed. She didn't know... she couldn't know. Could she?
My dick came fully back to life now. Carly stretched her neck up planted her lips on my chin. I tilted my head down and kissed her. She tasted like coffee. Her tongue darted out and met mine.
Her tongue was quick. She didn't linger and play with mine. Not like Rachel. My mind slipped away, remembering how Rachel's tongue felt. Soft, slow, sensual yet desperate. I leaned up a bit more and sucked Carly's tongue, trying to coax her into kissing me like Rachel had. But Carly pulled away. "Whoa there... someone's excited!"
Carley reached under my shorts and found my bare cock. Thank God I showered last night, I thought. She stroked my cock harder, but not tighter. Again, my mind slipped away to Rachel's perfect grip, the way she knew exactly how much pressure to use, and how to wrap her hands over the head.
Carly was propped up on her elbow, stroking me with her free hand. Not her dominant hand. I looked up at her. I smiled. She was trying. She wanted to please me.
FUCK.
I tried not to go away. I tried to stay in the moment. I tried to lay down and enjoy this pleasure, enjoy the fact that my wife wanted to touch me. Willingly. That she was in the mood.
I reached up and started to undo the buttons of her shirt. I fumbled with the first one, and then made quick work of the rest. Carly stopped stroking me for a moment as she let the shirt fall away from her. She was wearing a sports bra underneath. I reached in and cupped her breast. Smaller than Rachel's I thought.