Author's Note: The first two chapters of this story are dub con about reluctance. This and any chapters I write are less so. This is a story about slowly giving, not about being used and abused. I know that will disappoint some readers. I have rewritten the early part of the story, essentially doubling the length of the thing in my (unposted) version.
There wasn't any use in denying it anymore if there ever had been in the first place. She might not know why, but she definitely knew that she wanted to fuck Jay again, in the worst way, because it was impossible to ignore the way her pussy throbbed the rest of the day.
Even after she cleaned off his cum, and sat there in class listening to a lecture on Prussia, of all things, all she could do was squirm and squeeze her thighs together as she wished he'd cum inside her pussy instead of all over her face.
What's wrong with me? She asked herself over and over again, but there were no answers. There was only need.
She should be furious, and truthfully, she was, but it was for all the wrong reasons. She didn't hate him for using her mouth. She hated him for not using her pussy so she could cum too.
Ryan wanted to hang out after school, but she couldn't. Not with the taste of Jay's cum on her lips. That was doubly true when she saw Jay eyeing the two of them from the parking lot. He probably wants me to kiss him, she thought with a surge of anger.
She denied him that pleasure at least, and instead, she went home. She intended to wash her face and take a shower, but instead, she ended up laying in bed frustrated. Soaking in the smell of Jay's cum, all she wanted to do was finger herself, but her tampon prevented her from doing that properly, either.
Oh, she could play with her clit, but it wasn't as rough as she felt like right now. What's wrong with me, her mind repeated again. Even after she came on the shower head a few times, she wasn't at peace with any of this.
She should have felt grateful that she'd gotten her period at all. Someone had cum in her without any protection and with no regard for her future, but instead, she resented it. If I'd missed my period, I would have gotten fucked earlier at school, she complained silently. If I'd missed my period, I could have basked in the smell of cum and played with myself in bed.
It was stupid, of course. She knew that. When she got like this, nothing would make her happy. The very last thing she ever wanted to happen was to miss her period. Sucking dick, though, well, that was something she could definitely do.
That evening, after dinner, she told her mom she was going to go hang out with her friend Anna. That was a lie, though. Instead, she met Ryan in the mall parking lot and then did her very best to suck his soul out through his dick.
He wasn't particularly enthusiastic about it at first, but Grace was unwilling to take no for an answer. "We can do it here, or we can sneak into one of the disabled bathrooms and--"
"What's gotten into you lately, Grace?" he asked.
"It's what hasn't gotten into me," she complained. "I just want to try new things. Is that so wrong?"
"It is if someone catches us, and we become sex offenders," he answered automatically.
She ignored that very sensible argument and said, "Well, then you'd better keep a good lookout," as she bent down and started unzipping his pants.
He didn't stop her then. Not once, his dick was out, and she could feel it throbbing in her cool hand. She smiled at that and jerked it experimentally a few times, noting how different it was from Jay's. It looked and smelled different. Ryan was circumcised and smelled like soap. He still had a masculine scent, but it was drowned out by other body products, which was just the opposite of what had happened with Jay. His musk had been all but overpowering.
Moments later, she found out how differently they tasted, too, when she took the first few inches of her boyfriend's cock in her mouth. She gurgled in delight, determined to enjoy this experience. Earlier in the day, she'd tried to go as fast as she could with Jay, but she'd treated Ryan better. She worshiped his dick.
Grace spent a couple minutes looking for the little spots and motions around the tip of his dick that made him moan and focusing on those, trying to gauge his reactions. She tried to express her love to him then, in the rawest possible way. It was a moment of pure eroticism that was made that much better when he praised her.
"God, you're getting so good at that baby..." he moaned. "I'm not going to last long at this rate."
"Cum as fast as you want, baby," she purred, lifting her lips from his head just long enough to speak as her spit-slick fist continued to pump up and down his shaft. "This is all about you. I want you to explode for me..."
He moaned aloud at those words. Then, as she started sucking again, he did something unexpected. He rested his hand on her head as he groaned audibly, and for a moment, she thought he was going to force her head down.
No, she didn't think he was going to. She hoped he would. She loved being a good girlfriend, but what she wanted was for him to take control. She could worship him all day, and it would make her nearly as wet as it bottomed out in her mouth and fucked her tight little throat until she was on the verge of suffocation.
That didn't happen, though. Instead, he continued to moan and groan as their windows fogged up, and then, suddenly, he growled, "Watch out baby, I'm... Oh, fuck... I'm cumming!"
Her throbbing pussy practically wilted at that moment. She didn't want to be warned. She wanted to be used. Still, there was nothing she could do about it now, and tried to make the best of it as she felt his hot, sticky cum fill her mouth.
She was tempted to swallow his load at that moment, just as she'd wanted to do with Jay's, but she resisted. He'd find it strange if she did that unsolicited. Instead, she lifted her head, hoping he would ask, only for him to hand her a Kleenex instead, ruining the moment. So, instead of fulfilling one of his fantasies, she spit it out.
She had to. It would have been weird not to then, but that was just one more disappointment on a night of disappointments. He didn't even notice her sour face as he started the car.
It's just not the same, she thought in disappointment, even as she smiled at him, and they started to drive home.
It wasn't even down to the taste that she'd greedily swallowed or the way he'd told her he loved her afterward. It was everything else. It was the fear in his eyes and his eagerness to start the car when they were done. It was the way he was more concerned about being gentle than about taking his pleasure from her. It was everything.
Grace was fast coming to the conclusion that what she really wanted wasn't even to make out in public like she'd first thought. Instead, she just wanted to be out of control. She spent the next few days thinking about that and hoping that something out of control would happen to her, but nothing did. It wasn't until Wednesday, the day after her period finished, that she even heard from Jay, and that was delivered in the form of dm.
She waited until no one was around to open that, and she was glad that she did. It wasn't even pornographic. It was just a few terse words, but somehow, it still made her blush.
'Ready for your big day tomorrow?' he asked.
'Tomorrow? Why not Friday? That's no notice at all.' she answered. She realized immediately she didn't protest what he said, or even bring up her concerns. She told herself she would get to that. She almost even believed it.
'That was the plan, but Thomas' parents come back on Friday, so Thursday night it is.' He sent her an address after that. '7pm! Don't be late.'
'Don't be late?' asked immediately. 'I'm going to need more than that. We still haven't talked about safety and stuff like that.'
Reading back, that message sounded infantile to her, but there was nothing she could do. She'd been unable to write anything that was sexual or incriminating, and every time she tried, she just deleted it and started over.
'We'll have protection available at the party if you want to use it,' he messaged back. 'Anything else, you can come find me after class, and we can talk all you want...'
She sent him two more messages after that, but he didn't even bother to leave her on read. He just ignored her.
That angered Grace, but not enough to seek him out and continue the conversation in person. That wouldn't end with any talking, though. Images of getting fucked against a wall behind a convenience store briefly flooded her mind before she forced them down. As much as she'd wanted to get fucked the last couple of days, getting this message had knocked the wind out of her.
"This is really happening," she told herself. She didn't even try to tell herself it was about Liam anymore. She didn't even resign herself to her fate. By the time she got home that day, she was looking forward to the whole thing enough that it made her head spin.
"Why?" she asked herself for the hundredth time. "Why can't I just be normal?" There was no normal. There was only a slow countdown and a growing obsession with deciding what to wear.
When she got home from school the following day, Grace took her time getting ready. She'd already lied to everyone that mattered. She told Ryan she couldn't go out because she had to study, and she told her parents that she was going to go study for an upcoming test with Ryan and a couple of her friends. The only tests she faced, though, were to her dignity and endurance.
In the end, she decided on a slinky black dress that practically fell off as soon as she let its spaghetti straps slip from her shoulders. She opted not to wear a bra with it, both because she was just going to lose it and because she thought the dress looked hotter with her nipples pressing against her sheet fabric.