I had just transferred to another college my sophomore year. Didn't know practically a soul.
So, when I met a really nice, attractive, and smart girl in Psychology class, I zeroed in on her. Christina and I hung out a lot, and I really liked her, but she was not readily giving up the good stuff, putting the brakes on after 2nd base. I figured she had the idea I was a playboy who might fuck and dump her, but I sincerely wanted to be her steady boyfriend, so I was patient to prove my genuine interest. Tough for a horny guy like me who'd not got any since the end of summer, but I was doing what I had to do.
One night I'd invited her over for an I'll-cook-dinner-at-my-place evening, but right before she was due, she called and asked if she could bring a couple of girlfriends, so I said OK, though I thought that was a bit puzzling.
She shows up with another two girls from her dorm I'd heard her talk about but had never met, and my beer, along with the beer they brought, was more than plenty for all of us. We ate, drank, played darts, laughed, carried on, and were having a really good time. Not the kind of evening I'd anticipated--I was hoping it would be THE NIGHT for me and Christina--but nevertheless fun.
I had my arm around her and kissed her several times throughout the evening, though she seemed a bit stiff, which I attributed to anxiety in the presence of her two friends. They were obviously not anxious at all, being quite touch-feely. They initiated all the touchy-feely stuff, yet I was careful to not do anything inappropriate with them, even when we started giving each other backrubs and so forth. After all, Christina was my girl.
Well, the evening wore on, and she intercepted me in the hall on my way back from the bathroom, out of earshot of the other two. She asked which of them I liked best, and I told her it was SHE that I liked. She said she was afraid of that and that's why she'd brought her two girlfriends. Huh?
She said she liked me a lot, but that, although she had normal sexual desires, was saving herself for marriage and that she knew she'd never accomplish that dating an extremely horny guy like me, so we'd have to be just friends. My heart sank.
Christina went on to say that she was sorry that I might think she'd led me on and felt she "owed me one," and that's where her two girlfriends, who were "definitely not virgins," came in. Both liked me a lot. One had already told her she'd like to go to bed with me that evening, that she was a "sure thing." Bummed about the girl I really liked—Christina--all I could say was "Really?" before they came down the hall to see where we'd disappeared to.
Heart sunk deep in my chest, I went into the kitchen to get us all another round of brews and gather my composure, leaving the three of them alone for a few minutes. When I came back, Christina and one of her friends quickly downed their beers, said thanks for everything, and then left, saying, "We'll leave the two of you alone to your own devices. Have fun!"
Now the thing was, this girl—the sure thing—wearing a tight sweater and jeans, quite obviously had an absolutely fantastic body, gorgeous, shoulder-length, natural blonde hair, lovely blue eyes, and beautiful teeth, hands, feet, and nails. But she had the face of a dog. Her face resembled a Boston Bull Terrier, no kidding. Though Christina was the one I really wanted, honestly, if I'd been given a choice, I would have definitely picked her other friend, a tall, slim brunette with a really cute face.
In the first place, I had just been majorly disappointed to learn that the girl I'd been seeing for two months only wanted to be friends. Second, without any of my own input, she had pulled this sudden switcheroo. Third, I was having trouble with this chick's face, big trouble. So, trying to relax and accept this new order, I sat down at the table and did like 6 or 8 bong hits in rapid succession and gulped down a couple more Buds.