The bottle spun, grinding against the wooden floor as the group watched silently. Noah felt his heart racing.
It had already landed on Rachel once, what were the odds it could happen again? It wouldn't, it would land on someone else and this stupid game would end. Noah would laugh with Rachel, leaving before these three could come up with any more plans to see her naked.
The bottle slowed. Noah felt his heartbeat in his ears.
The bottle stopped right in front of Rachel.
"No fucking WAY bro! Let's go!!!" Mike shot up from the ground while Ethan and Jack fist-bumped each other. Their gambit had paid off. Noah looked at Rachel in disbelief. She stared at the bottle, appearing just as stunned as he was. Noah wanted to say something, but it felt as though his mouth was sewn shut.
There was no way she'd do it. Absolutely no way she was going to show these guys her tits. It would undo everything they had built together, it would completely change their friend group. Rachel had to see that, she just had to.
"Well... a deal's a deal..." Jack stood up and walked next to Ethan before promptly dropping his pants. The two glanced at each other awkwardly before Ethan took two steps away.
"You don't need to stand so close bro,"
"Do you want to see Rachel's tits or not man?" Jack stepped closer, causing Rachel to shake her head and look away in embarrassment. Her face was beat red, her smile never dimming. Noah glanced at the two naked men. Unlike Ethan, Jack was still soft. Even so, it was clear that Ethan was the larger of the two, despite Jack's noticeably above-average size. Noah felt a rush of anger wash over his body.
In every way, these two outclassed Noah, and both wanted as much of Rachel as they could get. What was worse, Rachel didn't seem to hate what was happening. Certainly, her curiosity was innocent, but she was interested all the same.
"So... are you going to do it?" Ethan asked. Rachel stared at them both with wide eyes as her fingers trailed over her lips. The room was quiet, and that quiet was slowly filling with the sexual tension between these three. Noah's hands shook as he cleared his throat.
"Rachel... seriously, you don't have to do this." He spoke firmly, happy to see Rachel glance at him with a welcoming smile.
"Come on Rachel! I literally just compared dicks for you. A deal is a deal," Jack said. Ethan nodded in agreement.
"It's true, we've both put ourselves on the line here Rachel, don't leave us hanging out to dry," Ethan said, his cock pulsing as he shifted his weight. Rachel didn't acknowledge them, she didn't even look at them. Her eyes remained fixed on Noah.
"This is fucking crazy!" She said to him. She blinked slowly as she pushed a few loose strands of hair past her rosy cheeks.
"Yeah, I know. Which is why you don't have to do this," Noah replied.
"It's not fucking crazy, it's college life bro! We're just having fun," Mike chimed in. Noah gritted his teeth, these three were like vultures. But so far, it seemed like he was the only one being bothered by what was going on. Even Luke and the other girls watched in amusement.
Noah had to play it cool, the last thing he wanted was to drive Rachel away. It couldn't end like it had with Allison, things had to be different.
"What do you think?" Rachel asked, leaning forward and letting her nose touch Noah's. He could smell the alcohol on her breath. "You think I should show them?"
Noah stared into Rachel's eyes. He was speechless. He didn't know how to take the question. If Rachel was genuinely asking for his opinion, then the answer was obviously no.
At least, his gut reaction was no... but his throbbing cock seemed to be telling a different story.
"Yeah Noah," Jack said. "You think she should show us her tits?"
"I think she should, it's only fair after all," Ethan added. Rachel glanced their way and bit her lip.
"I've never gotten to do something this crazy before, should I make them jealous?" Rachel spoke softly, her innocent tone seemingly out of place for such a taboo question. It was clear that this was just still fun and games for Rachel. She didn't care about them, she only cared about Noah. That's why she was asking, that's why she was so entertained. She would never do anything without asking him. Noah let out a deep breath. Rachel wasn't anything like Allison, because Rachel actually cared about him.
That was enough to put Noah's mind at ease.
"Totally your call babe." Noah felt his cock pulse at those words. This could actually happen, Rachel was on the verge of showing the group something only Noah could have, and it was a huge turn-on. Rachel stared at Noah a moment longer, tapping her fingers against her thigh before sighing and shrugging.
"You know what? Fuck it..." She stood up and unclasped her bra with one tug and let it fall to the floor.
The room went silent. Everyone was staring at Rachel, even Luke. Jack's once-soft cock quickly began to swell. Rachel stood, resting her weight on one leg, accentuating the curves of her hips and legs. Something about her being half undressed made her round, perky breasts pop more than normal. She flipped her hair, giving an embarrassed smile as the room took her in.
Noah knew that Rachel was attractive, he knew that she was more attractive than any other girl in their small town of Herferd. But this moment was teaching him a valuable lesson. Rachel wasn't just a pretty small-town girl. She was arguably one of the most attractive women at Godfrey.
And he was beginning to realize just how dangerous that was.
"Wow... she actually did it," Mel said blandly, glancing over at Jack's now throbbing member. "Even managed to get Jack hard... good for you." She and Kate glared at Rachel, who simply laughed as she squeezed her breasts gently.
"I did, didn't I? Does that mean you think I'm hot?" Rachel asked.
