Chapter Two A Pleasant Surprise
I knew something was very wrong even before I opened the door to the guest suite. Stephanie was wearing a tank top and short shorts and lying on our bed, sobbing.
"Hey, what's going on," I asked tentatively. "Did something happen with Tyler."
Stephanie glared at me. She had a very odd expression on her face — angry but also vulnerable.
"If you have to know, I just fucked Tyler. Or more to the point, he just fucked me!"
"What the hell? How did that happen?"
"Maybe if you hadn't been doing the same thing with my best friend down on the dock, he wouldn't have texted me to come to his room to watch."
I was floored. I was certain the dock was out of sight from the cottage. Lisa had been a little loud when I was going down on her, and when we were fucking, but I was pretty sure only the loons out on the lake would have heard that.
"That asshole has installed security cameras all over the property to keep an eye on her. He says he can't trust her. Can you believe it? But what's even more unbelievable is that my so-called loving husband decides he's free to fuck her while his wife is asleep 50 feet away!"
"I understand you're upset," I began. "I'm not going to deny being with her. But there's more to the story than you probably saw on the video..."
"What?" She replied. "So you've fucked her in the past?"
"That's not what I meant. I went down to the dock to go out in the canoe, and she was lying naked on the chaise lounge, playing with herself with a vibrator. She went on and on about how much of a drunken asshole her husband is, talked me up by repeating a lot of the nice things you've said to her about me, then begged me to get her off. It was just sex, there were no feelings, and it won't happen again."
"I used to think you were a good guy," she replied quietly, "but I'm not sure I can trust you any more. If it's so easy for you to fuck someone who's special to me, why wouldn't you do it with other women I don't even know?"
"Because I love you," I interrupted. "We've talked and talked about how I want to make love to you more often, and you promised me that we'd do it first thing this morning. Then you sent me away with a raging hard-on, and a couple of minutes later, I come across your very attractive friend lying naked by the water pleasuring herself."
"I'm sure she was grateful for the attention," Stephanie responded quietly. "But not only do I have to deal with the fact that my husband is a cheater, but I'm no better, because I let Tyler fuck me too."
"Let's talk about that," I began. "Whose idea was that? And tell me again how you ended up in their room."
"I was fast asleep. My phone buzzed, and when I didn't respond the first time, it buzzed again. Finally after the third alert, I grabbed the phone and saw the messages from Tyler. He told me he needed to show me something that I'd really want to see, and to come to their room right away."
By this time, the anger in Stephanie's voice had subsided.
"He has a laptop on the desk in their room. He beckoned me over, and I could see you going down on Lisa. There was no audio, but it appeared you were in command, giving her orders. Then you started fucking her hard. It didn't last that long, but I could tell you both enjoyed it. And then you finished by cumming all over her. I have to admit it would have been hot, if it had been a porn flick and not live video of my husband and best friend."
There were tears streaming down Stephanie's face as she continued her story.
"I was really upset, and started to leave, but he grabbed me by the arm. He told me that if my husband and his wife were going at it, didn't they deserve a bit of payback? I tried to pull away, but he threw me on the bed and pulled my shorts down. He unzipped himself and and tried to enter me."
"I begged him to slow down, and even offered to suck him off, hoping that would satisfy him, or at the very least get me a bit wet if he still insisted on fucking me. Lisa had told me in the past that he has a huge cock, and she wasn't exaggerating. I had trouble getting it in my mouth, and when I couldn't deep throat him, he pulled out, held me down on the bed and started pounding me. I think I'm going to be sore all weekend."
By this point, Stephanie was almost blubbering, and she didn't resist when I sat down next to her and put my arm around her.
"At first, it was really painful, and I could tell he was taking out his anger with Lisa on me. I felt like he was raping me, and I should have been able to stop him."