Abbey paused at the cemeteryâs high-gated entrance, shivering with cold and the tiniest hint of apprehension.
This is crazy
, she thought.
I should just leave and come back tomorrow. Itâs already getting dark
. She turned west and briefly admired the sky, streaked with brilliant pink and orange as the sun disappeared over the horizon. The cemetery was wreathed in shadows, the little light left barely penetrating the thick cover of trees, which were just beginning put on their autumn colours. There wasnât a soul in sight.
Soul,
she thought.
Ha, ha.
The night was silent, except for the distant shouts of kids trick or treating.
While Abbey was not a superstitious person, she couldnât help but feel a bit spooked entering a dark cemetery, particularly on Halloween night. But her best friend, Monica, had been killed in a car crash two years ago today. Abbey had avoided this task all day, depressed, but finally guilt had forced her to come. She didnât believe Monicaâs spirit or soul or whatever was here, but she did believe cemeteries were therapeutic for the living and she wanted â needed â to pay her respects to her departed friend. And anyway, there was nothing to fear here, tonight or any other night; she had read that graveyards were actually the least likely places to be haunted, since spirits trapped on earth tended to hang around places that were significant to them in life. She figured that made a lot of sense.
Gathering her courage, Abbey went through the gates and walked briskly along the cemeteryâs well-tended paths, admiring the gleaming headstones as she passed them. The sounds of life faded quickly; Abbeyâs footsteps were loud in the cemeteryâs deep silence. She found Monicaâs grave easily enough. Her wealthy family had provided an impressive monument to mark it, the kind with a photo of the deceased encased in glass. A white guardian angel sat atop the glossy marble stone.
Abbey knelt on the damp ground before her friendâs photo. The words of the only prayer she knew ran through her head: Our Father, who art in Heaven ⊠âMonica, I miss you so much,â she whispered. She wrapped her arms around herself and rocked gently back and forth. Monica, in the photo, was smiling softly, her head tilted and her eyes shining. She seemed to be watching Abbey, listening sympathetically. Abbey was ambivalent about the photo; she wasnât sure if it was comforting or eerie.
Abbey couldnât help but think about the night Monica had died. It was the second-last year of university. She had been driving home with her boyfriend, Greg, after a night of costumed carousing with friends. Typical Halloween partying. Greg was, not surprisingly, completely wasted. Monica had been the self-appointed designated driver. In fact, she had dropped Abbey off at home not more than twenty minutes before the crash. Abbey had watched Greg, dressed as Zorro, playing with his plastic sword in the cramped quarters of the Volvoâs front seat. Monica had been annoyed, angry even, and kept yelling at him to sit still and behave himself.
When they got to Abbeyâs apartment building, the girls had embraced, Abbey in her pixie costume, and Monica in a gorgeous velvet gown, a nineteenth-century noblewoman to complement Gregâs Zorro. Then Monica had gotten back in the car and driven away. The day of Monicaâs funeral, a grief-stricken Greg had described to his friends what happened next.
He had continued his antics and they began to argue in earnest. He remembered dragging the blade of the plastic sword across her neck and playfully threatening to cut her throat if she wouldnât put out when they got home. âVery funny, Zorro,â sheâd said, then, âGod, youâre such an ass.â He began groping her, kissing her neck and fumbling at the gownâs bodice. She kept pushing him away, but he wouldnât stop, and, thus distracted, she had missing a curve in the road. The little car flew through the guard rail and rolled twice down a hill, stopped only by a collision with a tree. The driverâs side had been crushed, and Monica was pronounced dead at the scene. Greg escaped with a concussion and a broken wrist.
In the aftermath, Abbey had been furious with Greg. Whenever he entered a room, sheâd leave, often in tears. She refused to talk to him about it. She couldnât bring herself to forgive him. Their friends had naturally sided with Abbey, and slowly Greg had been pushed out of their little social group. Within a few months, he disappeared from campus. It seemed heâd either transferred or dropped out entirely. As far as she knew, nobody had seen him in nearly a year and a half.
Abbey, kneeling at the foot of Monicaâs grave two years later, found herself telling Monica about Gregâs ostracism from his friends when heâd needed them most. She thought about him often, wondered if he was okay and if heâd ever gotten over his own obvious and powerful guilt. âBut Iâm still furious with him,â she insisted. âI havenât forgiven him.â
The wind picked up then, and Abbey huddled into her sweater and considered leaving. Then she heard something, a stick breaking under a foot, maybe. She peered anxiously into the gloom, looking for movement. Goosebumps raised on her skin from both cold and fear. She sensed the presence of someone, couldnât help but wonder if the presence was alive⊠or not. âIs someone there?â she called. She moved closer to Monicaâs headstone, crouched behind it and peeked around it. She heard rustling, like footsteps in grass. âHello?â she called, her voice quivering.
âMon, Iâm sorry, but I gotta go,â she gasped. She got to her feet and started to run for the path. Footsteps behind her â she was being chased! âOh, God,â she cried.
Something grabbed her arm and pulled her to a stop. She screamed.
âShhh, Abbey, itâs me, itâs okay.â
Terrified, Abbey turned and looked at the man who was still holding her arm. His features slowly resolved in the gloom. Greg. He released her, and she stared at him, trying to catch her breath.
âWhy would you do that? Why wouldnât you answer me?â she demanded.
âIâm sorry. I just ... I didnât know if youâd want to see me.â
She gazed over his shoulder at the little angel sitting on Monicaâs headstone. âIâm going to go now. Leave you alone with her.â
âPlease donât. Stay with me,â he pleaded.
Abbey stepped towards him, trying to make out his expression. âWhy?â she asked suspiciously.
âI donât want to be alone. And I thought maybe we could talk.â
She hesitated, glancing towards the entrance, then back to Greg, who looked hopeful.
âPlease?â he said.
Wordlessly, she brushed past him and returned to Monicaâs grave. They stood side by side, staring down at Monicaâs smiling face, frozen forever at the age of twenty. Abbey had missed her friend most acutely at graduation a few months ago. They would have graduated together; theyâd already had plans to take a trip to Ireland together right after school ended. Abbey glanced at Greg.