A 2fer on Fantasy Cards

A 2fer On Fantasy Cards

The events in this story take place after Decisions, Decisions

####

The next school day after she became engaged to Bill, Denae saw Janet at their Modern Sexuality class. Janet could not help but notice the new jewelry on Denae's finger because Denae, enamored with the idea of being engaged and with the ring Bill gave her, went to great lengths to keep her left hand prominently visible. Janet congratulated Denae but their conversation was cut short when the professor began class. Afterward, Janet walked with Denae to the coffee shop and sat in a booth with her while she waited for Bill.

After Denae told Janet all about how Bill had proposed on one knee and how he had traveled down to Florida to seek her parents' permission, the topic turned to the research paper that was due by the midterm. Denae told Janet she was in great shape and, with the exception of some final notations and comments, was nearly finished. "The paper practically wrote itself," Denae stated. "Using my own story rather than someone else's experiences made it easy."

"Yeah. You're going to get a good grade," Janet responded. "The day you missed class to go to Atlanta, I wound up talking with Alden's T.A. after class. She told me Alden tends to give better grades to students who present their own adventures/encounters/experiences/stories instead of re-telling someone else's."

"That's good to hear."

"I'm glad you're in good shape. But me? I've got nothing," Janet complained. "I can't think of a time I have owned my sexuality."

"Nothing?" Denae asked. "Hasn't there been one time you did something on a date or somewhere?"

Janet thought for a moment. "No. Nothing pops out. And I can't think of anything I could do. I'm stuck."

"Hhmm. Something you could do?" Denae wondered. "Do you have a boyfriend?"

"No," Janet replied. "Single at the moment."

Denae then started brainstorming and offered ideas such as having sex with a complete stranger, trying a new position, trying bondage, having sex outside. She offered as many ideas as she could think of and then asked Janet if there was anything she had never tried but was curious about.

Janet checked the surroundings to see if anyone might overhear them. Then she leaned in and whispered, "Well, I've been curious about what it would be like to be with another girl."

"Oo la la," Denae whispered as she fanned herself, indicating she found Janet's idea very erotic. "Are you really curious about that, or just throwing the idea out for the paper?"

"I've actually been wondering. But if it turned out to get me a great topic for the paper, that would be sweet."

"Well, you probably have choices. For someone who looks like you, it should be easy for you to find a girl to help you out. Sorority sisters?"

"No," Janet replied cautiously. "While there would be a level of trust with a sister, it could alter dynamics."

As the two continued to seek a solution for Janet, Bill arrived and sat down next to Denae. Denae re-introduced Janet to Bill though it was unnecessary. Janet congratulated Bill on the engagement and then offered to leave so they could be alone, but they both invited her to stay.

Denae explained to Bill that Janet was searching for a topic for her paper but did not go into specifics of what had been discussed. Bill, in an effort to avoid the subject, asked the girls if either would like coffee, offering to get it for them. As Bill walked away, Denae was struck an idea; one that could not only help Janet but could also satisfy some of her own desires. Denae wondered if Janet would be interested in satisfying her girl-girl curiosity with her in the interest of her paper and, in exchange, if Janet would have sex with Bill so she might watch. Not sure how to bring these notions up to Janet, Denae decided to file the idea away until she could find a suitable time and manner to broach the subject with her.

####

That evening, while studying at Bill's apartment, Denae pointed out that neither of them had drawn a fantasy card since before the beginning of summer. Bill acknowledged that was true but told her he assumed there would no longer be a need for the fantasy cards now that they were engaged. Secretly, Bill did not like the fantasy cards; he felt pressured by Denae to participate in the venture and the result was planned, rather than spontaneous sex. For her part, Denae saw the cards as a way to keep Bill interested in her; fearing Bill's lack of sexual experience would drive him to seek pleasure with other women.

"Oh no. I want to keep those going even after we're married. We can learn a lot about each other and have fun doing it," Denae insisted.

Denae retrieved the small plastic box which held the cards and sat on the couch with Bill while she withdrew one of the pink index cards. When she read it, she raised her eyebrows. "Well, this one will take some planning," she said.

Intrigued, Bill asked what card she had drawn. When she handed it to him, he read, 'have sex with another girl.' Denae laughed when Bill's eyes got big while reading the card.

"Are you serious? One of your fantasies is to have sex with a girl?"

"Well, I've been curious about it for a while," she admitted. "Why not find out before college is over?"

Bill had several questions about Denae's fantasy, not the least of which was if she was a lesbian or bisexual. Denae assured him she was neither but stated that she had always been curious to see what it was like to have sex with a girl; to caress her and be caressed by her and to taste another woman's juices. Denae wanted to know what it was like to excite a girl and to see if another girl could excite her.

At some point during the discussion, Bill pointed out that Denae's fantasy would exclude him. "Not necessarily. You could watch," she teased.

Then suddenly Denae snapped her fingers as she remembered something. She picked up the box again and rifled through the pink cards. After looking at a few of them, she found the one she sought, pulled it from the box and handed it to Bill. "Here ya go. We could combine these two."

Bill looked at the newest card. 'Watch Bill have sex with another girl.'

Bill shook his head and said, "Oh, no. Uh uh. We're not doing that."

"Why not?" Denae protested.

"Well mostly because I love my fiancé and I'm not about to risk blowing things with her. Besides, that's just...creepy."

Denae, touched by Bill's insistence that he loved her, drew close to him and put her arms around him. "I'm glad you love me but doing that wouldn't mess anything up as far as I'm concerned."

She reminded him what she shared with him in the car last summer; she wanted to see him have sex with another girl because she liked seeing him do manly things and she deemed having sex was among the manliest things he could do. Denae also reminded him of the time he had sex with Suzy, at her urging, and told him she had gotten aroused by watching him with her. Denae also assured Bill he would not be cheating on her since it was her fantasy, and she would be there for the act.

Bill was dumbfounded. "What? Seriously? You liked seeing me doing that?"

"Yeah. I got to see your hips moving and your cute butt tightening up while you pounded her. And I got to see your ball sack scrunch up when you were about to cum. I don't get to see that when you're fucking me."

"I don't honestly know what to say."

"Think about it. We could combine two of my fantasies into one and you would get something out of it too."

There was more discussion. More accurately, Denae tried to convince Bill to be open to this and Bill baulked at the idea. Finally, Denae suggested she propose a potential participant and let Bill reevaluate his position. He seemed unconvinced and they agreed to put the subject to rest for the time being.

####

When Denae saw Janet in class the next day, she told her she had been giving some thought to potential topics for her paper and might have come up with one Janet could use. Janet indicated she was very interested in Denae's idea since she had not yet resolved the matter. Professor Alden walked in at that point and Denae suggested she and Janet talk after class.

After class, Denae and Janet walked together toward the coffee shop. Janet was anxious to hear the idea Denae had for a topic for her paper. Denae played coy until they found a booth. Once seated, Janet begged Denae to share her idea.

Denae proceeded cautiously. "Okay. Remember all the ideas we floated the other day? Anal, bondage, stranger, etc.? There was one I would be willing to help you with."

Janet leaned in. "Please tell me. I would welcome your help."

Denae whispered, "If you were curious about having an experience with another girl, I would be willing to help you out there."

Janet looked surprised and also intrigued. "You'd do that?"

Denae nodded in the affirmative.

Janet sat back as the thought registered in her mind. After a few seconds contemplating the idea, she whispered, "Oh wow. That could be awesome. I mean you're completely hot."

"If you and I were to do that so you could write about it for your paper, would you do me a favor in return?"

"Favor in return? What do you mean?"

"More sex, but with a guy. My fiancé."

Janet looked confused. "You mean a threesome?"

Denae snickered. "No. Not a threesome. Well, maybe in a sense. What I mean is after we do our thing, would you be interested in my fiancé?"

"Are you serious? Your fiancé? What?"

Denae held her hand up to try to calm Janet. "This will sound strange, but I get really turned on watching my fiancé have sex with other girls. And I was hoping you might...you know...lay him after we're done."

"Fuck. That's different."

"I know. I'm not sure why, but I really get horny watching him with someone."

"So, you've done that before?"

"Once. That's a long story. But that's how I found out I like seeing him. I know this feeling's not common, but I can't help it."

Janet thought for a second before asking, "So, Bill?"

"Yes. The best part is he has a huge cock."

Janet's response to that was raising her eyebrows and sipping her coffee.

Bill arrived at the coffee shop as usual and found the girls together in a booth. Janet looked at Bill differently than she had before and then said she had to leave.

"You and Janet are thick as thieves all of a sudden, huh?" Bill asked after Janet departed.

"We wound up sitting next to each other in Modern Sexuality. I'd never seen her in any of the major classes before. Turns out she is a junior and this is her first. It's a small class so we kinda just started talking. Turned out she's really nice. And she's really cute, don't you think?"

He nonchalantly replied, "I guess so."

"C'mon. She's brunette. You like that. And has nice boobs and sparkly eyes. You don't think she's hot?"

"I didn't say that. I just don't pay much attention." Putting his arm around her, he continued, "Ya see? I have this really terrific fiancé who happens to be the best-looking girl at this entire college. So, I don't really notice others."

Smiling proudly, Denae returned, "That's nice to hear, but let's get real. You're only human. You have to admit she's hot. I can tell she's hot."

Bill's facial expression changed, as if he just realized something. "Hey, wait a minute. Is she...?"

Denae simply smiled and nodded.

"She's the one you want to...you know...?" he asked.

"Yup. What do you think?"

He shook his head in disbelief, resigned to Denae's plan to bed the young woman. "Well, I'll admit your taste in women is almost as good as mine."

Denae laughed at the comment and then leaned closer to Bill. Whispering, she asked Bill if Janet would be someone, he could envision himself having sex with. Bill reminded Denae that he had an amazing fiancé, so he did not feel the need to have sex with Janet or anyone else. Denae argued that it would be perfectly fine with her and that she would, in fact, like to see Bill with her, as it excited her sexually. He simply stared down at his coffee.

"Let's face it. It turns me on, and you need to sow your oats anyway."

"What in the world are you talking about?"

"You know." Whispering again, "Our numbers. You're behind. And every guy wants to have multiple girls. This way you can satisfy that need and I can get off on it."

Denae was referring to the number of previous sexual partners each had had prior to finding one another. Denae had had eleven before meeting Bill; a number that surprised her when Suzy helped her fully recall her history. On the other hand, Bill's only previous partner was a girl in high school who later died of leukemia. Bill had always resisted any of Denae's attempts to confess her past to him. On the night of their engagement, she told him despite his insistence he wished to be left uniformed.

The two would have continued arguing about Janet assisting in the fulfillment of two of Denae's fantasies, but Bill changed the subject, and the pair talked to pass the time until they both had to go to class. They agreed Denae would come over to Bill's apartment that evening when Denae finished work and after Bill had officiated the last of his basketball games.

####

Denae looked at her phone. The text message that had just arrived was from Bill, letting her know there was one half left in his final game and then he would be home. Denae was at Bill's apartment already and was sitting on the couch drinking wine with Janet.

"He'll be here in about forty-five minutes," she cheerfully told Janet.

"So, we're really doing this?" Janet asked. Putting her hand on Denae's arm, she added, "I've been looking forward to something like this. And I'm glad this will be with someone I trust...and is hot."

"Yes, we'll absolutely do this," Denae replied. "I'll try to really give you something good to write about for your paper."

"And Bill is okay with this?" Janet asked.

"He'll balk at first and he will take a minute to come around, but he's a guy. He won't be able to resist."

Janet giggled and took another sip of wine. Janet was still wearing the clothes she had worn at school earlier in the day; a sweatshirt embroidered with the letters of her sorority and some running shorts. Denae, who had come from the boutique, was wearing a tight mini skirt and a silky blouse. As was her habit, she had shed her high-heeled shoes at the door when she let herself in.

Janet found herself looking at Denae's legs, admiring her smooth, olive complexion. She was also taken with how Denae was able to wear very little make-up and still look amazing. Janet was fascinated with how beautiful Denae was and noticed that even her feet were cute.

Janet took another sip of wine, contemplating what she and Denae would soon be doing and what she would be doing with Bill afterward. "Is his dick really as big as you say?"

Laughing, Denae said, "Yeah. He's hung. You'll see. But if you're not satisfied, you'll get a full refund."

They both laughed; due in part to Denae's remark, but mainly due to the amount of wine they had consumed. As the two continued to talk and sip wine, the clock rolled forward. Eventually, they both heard a key unlock the door, signaling Bill's arrival. Janet adjusted her posture and sat more upright while Denae remained seated with her knees up on the couch.

When Bill entered, he was surprised to see Janet there with Denae. Denae greeted him and stated that Janet had come over and they wound up sharing a bottle of wine. "It's okay if Janet hangs out a while, isn't it?"

Bill, both nervous and suspicious, stammered as he replied, "Oh sure. Hi Janet. It's good to see you again."

As he set his gym bag down and kissed his fiancé, he asked if they had eaten anything. Denae informed him they had not, but they could all decide on food. He also mentioned that he was sweaty from having officiated three games and would prefer to shower before entertaining company.

"That's a good idea. Why don't you go shower while we girls finish off the wine?" Denae suggested.

At that, Bill excused himself and headed for his bedroom and for the shower. As he closed the door behind him, Denae turned to Janet and patted her thigh. "Well, shall we?"

"I can't believe we're doing this. But I'm super excited."

"Good. Come on."

Denae got up from the couch and took Janet by the hand as they walked toward Bill's bedroom. Denae cracked the door and could hear Bill in the shower, so she led her brunette friend into the room. Silently pointing to the bed, she urged Janet to sit on the corner. When Janet had done so, Denae put her hands on Janet's face and leaned down and kissed her. It was a deep, passionate, open-mouthed kiss. The two pressed their tongues against each other.

"Hey, we could do without this sweatshirt," Denae said, as she lifted Janet's shirt up over her head. Janet assisted by raising her arms.

Denae unbuttoned and removed her own top and the two girls looked at each other, their upper bodies clad only in their bras. Signaling to Janet to wait, Denae turned and left the room. She soon returned, pushing the ottoman from the family room. The wheels squeaked faintly as she positioned it in the corner of the room. She then reached for Janet and motioned for her to get up.

"Quiet. Come with me." she urged Janet in a whisper.

Denae took the girl by the hand and led her silently toward the bathroom. The door was partially closed, so Denae pushed it open enough for the pair to enter single file. Janet resisted slightly, pulling back on the hand Denae was holding. Denae turned around and motioned for her to come with her but to stay quiet.

As Denae approached the shower curtain, she could hear water splashing off Bill's body. She reached up and pulled the curtain back just enough to stick her head in. This startled Bill, who stopped and remained motionless for a split second until he realized it was his fiancé peeking in on him.

"You almost scared me," he said, raising his voice over the noise of the water.

"Sorry. I just wanted to take a quick peek."

"If Janet left, why don't you join me?"

"That sounds fun. But I had something else in mind right now."

Before Bill could ask her to expound, Denae drew back the curtain more fully. He did not see Janet right away and so did not cover himself. But as Denae stepped aside so Janet could look into the shower, Bill instinctively covered his manhood with his hands.

"Hey! What's going on?" he demanded.

Denae laughed. "Sorry. Don't be shy. I thought you might want to see what Janet looks like under her sweatshirt."

As she said those words, she moved around behind Janet, unhooked and removed her bra and tossed it out into the bedroom behind her. Janet did not make any attempt to stop the undressing or to cover her breasts. Bill looked on in silence as Denae gently pinched Janet's nipples with her fingers.

Denae broke the silence a few seconds later by asking Bill, "Doesn't she have gorgeous boobs?"

Still in stunned silence, Bill offered no reply, but did not look away either.

Denae's adjusted her hands and cupped Janet's breasts and gently squeezed. "We're going to go out into your room for a while. You'll find us out there when you finish your shower.

The girls retreated to the bedroom.

"Did you get a look at his dick?" Denae asked quietly.

"Just a quick glance before he covered up. I couldn't really see much."

"That's okay. You can do more than see it later. You won't be disappointed."

Denae guided Janet to the bed and then walked around and moved the ottoman, positioning it in the path to the door, and then closed the bedroom door. Denae joined Janet on the bed, reclining next to her. She looked at Janet and asked if Janet was certain she wanted to proceed. Janet looked Denae in the eyes, nodded in the affirmative and whispered, "Yes. I really want this."