Tutoring Tutor Girl

Disclaimer: I do not own One Tree Hill. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

*

Haley James Scott cautiously entered the home of possibly her least favourite person in the world Rachel Gatina. It wasn't that long ago she couldn't have imagined entering this home under any circumstances, but that was before her best friend Brooke Davis had started living here.

More importantly that was before that same Brooke Davis, the best female friend she ever had and the most popular girl in her school, had talked her into a sexual relationship where she was Brooke's bitch and thus forced to obey her commands whatever they may be.

The thing was the last time she had obeyed an order which was allegedly from Brooke to come to this house she found Rachel, the girl who had been trying to steal her husband, waiting for her and they'd had sex. No, scratch that, Rachel had fucked her in just about every sense of the word, humiliating her almost beyond belief, and to her shame Haley had loved it.

So as she slowly opened the unlocked door and then closed and locked it behind her as the text she had received had instructed her to do Haley wondered who exactly had ordered her here, and what exactly would happen when she got to the bed room Brooke and Rachel shared.

Naturally Haley had been wondering that since she received the text, but now her mind was racing extra fast, her heart pounding in her chest as she ascended the stairs. Honestly Haley wasn't sure who she'd prefer. Probably Brooke.

She was her best friend and then there was the part that when they had sex Brooke always made her feel so loved and cared for... but at the same time there was just something about Rachel. The way she had abused her, oh Haley couldn't stop thinking about it, the images of her last time with the redhead making her so wet.

Of course it was nothing compared to how she felt when she received the answer to her question, Haley kind of guessing as she heard soft cries and a weird smacking sound as she approached her destination. Still, to poked her head into Brooke's bed room and find her best friend bent over the knee of the total bitch, Rachel Gatina spanking Brooke Davis right in front of her... Haley honestly couldn't put into words how obscene that was. And to her shame, just how much it turned her on.

Brooke was unaware that Haley was there, but she did know her arrival was imminent. It was the main reason her pussy was so wet, because sure, getting her ass spanked was more of a turn on that she could have ever imagined. But there was just something about getting caught which drove her wild. And this wasn't like all those times she had talked Peyton, and/or Haley into having sex with her in the girls locker room or the toilets at school, or even a friend's house.

No, this time someone was walking in on her getting her naked butt beaten like a disobedient child. And it just so happened to be the girl who had been the first to catch her in the act and the start of a chain of events which led her to this very pleasurable point. Well, sort of pleasurable.

There was still definitely a lot of pain, especially because every so often Rachel would smack her ass with what had to be all her might, and even a gentle spanking from her rival made it hard for Brooke to sit down.

Or harder, given all the constant butt fuckings Brooke was taking from now both Peyton and Rachel, Brooke honestly unable to remember what it was like to sit down without wincing. The only difference was just how sore her ass was, and given the current butt beating she was receiving the answer to that was bad, but not that bad.

It helped that Rachel not only stopped in between each strike and thus gave Brooke time to recover but she shamelessly groped the brunette's butt, and caressing at least some of the pain away. True, Rachel blatantly did that for her own enjoyment, having confessed as much only a few minutes ago, but that in turn only made Brooke enjoy it more. And she loved being used for another girl's pleasure.

Of course when Haley got here Brooke's enjoyment was going to at least double, the cheerleader captain dreaming of all the fun they have when one member of her squad finally got here while another member continued spanking and groping her captain's butt with glee. Then when Brooke did finally spot Haley she grinned so widely that her dimples were on full display, her body going from tingling in anticipation to practically burning with it.

Given their positions, and the fact that she was constantly looking for her, it wasn't surprising that Rachel was the first one to spot Haley watching them. Although to be fair it wasn't like Haley was doing a particularly good job of hiding herself.

In fact it look like she wasn't even trying, only occasionally ducking her head out of sight when she clearly thought Rachel was going to look up, the allegedly smart tutor apparently completely unaware that Rachel had spotted her the moment she had arrived. Rachel just hadn't reacted to it because she was finding this so amusing.

Using the situation to her advantage Rachel began picking up the pace of the spanking, making the hard blow to Brooke's perfect butt more frequent and sometimes concentrating on one specific spot to make sure she had her rival turned bitch crying out loudly for her.

It helped that she had already turned Brooke's butt cheeks a cute little pink colour since she had bent the other girl over her knee about fifteen, twenty minutes ago in preparation for Haley's arrival, that flawless flesh quickly turning a rosy red under the assault.

Then and only then did Rachel look up and give Haley a wicked smile, "Hey there tutor girl, what kept you?"

Ignoring the question Haley turned to her friend and asked, "What's going on? Brooke, are you alright?"

"I'm fine Hales." Brooke beamed from her place over Rachel's knee, "Rach was just showing me who's boss."

"Oh God." Haley murmured her disbelief, her pussy dampening as her fears were realised.

"That's right bitch, I'm showing you who's boss." Rachel praised the bitch over her knee before turning her attention back to the bitch now cautiously walking into the room for a better look at what was going on, "And I'm about to do the same to you Haley. Mmmmmmm, I'm about to spank that ass of yours. Just. Like. This."

To emphasise her point Rachel dished out three extra hard spanks to coincide with the last three words. As she did that she looked directly into Haley's eyes, another wicked grin crossing her face as she watched the stuck up tutor with every blow she gave their mutual friend's butt.

The temptation to keep spanking Brooke just like that while staring a hole into Haley's soul was almost overwhelming, but Rachel's hand was already tired and she wanted to save her strength for both spanking Haley and more importantly fucking the two other girls.

So she forced herself to stop and then, after groping Brooke's butt for a couple more seconds, Rachel pushed her captain unceremoniously off of her lap and onto the floor, giggling wickedly as the supposed Queen Bee of their school crying out first in surprise and then in pain, Brooke clutching her well beaten ass and scowling at the redhead for a few long seconds.

Then when she returned the look with a glare of her own Brooke lowered her head in submission, causing Rachel to chuckle again before turning her attention back to Haley.

"Well, what are you waiting for bitch? Bend over my knee already!" Rachel ordered, patting her knee invitingly.

"Why should I?" Haley grumbled, crossing her arms.

"Oh I don't know..." Rachel said mockingly, "Maybe because you don't want me to tell your husband about you slutting it up with two girls behind his back? Or should I say three girls?"

"I wouldn't count you." Haley grumbled, turning her head away slightly.

"I would, especially now I've decided to make this a regular thing." Rachel grinned.

Haley raised an eyebrow, "I thought you weren't gay?"

"I'm not." Rachel quickly replied before smiling, "You two are gonna be the dyke sluts licking my cunt. I'm just going to have some fun dominating your skanky asses. Mmmmmmm, speaking of which, get over here, so I can give you a nice hard spanking, or I'll call up Nathan and tell him just how much you love my pussy."

Seeing Haley open her mouth to protest Brooke quickly chimed in, "Just do it Hales. We all know you want too."

Haley looked back and forth between Brooke and Rachel for a few long seconds, then she let out a groan of frustration and stomped over to where the redhead was sitting. She stopped in front of her for a second, Haley getting to tower over someone for a change, the bitch just grinning up at her, confident she knew what Haley was going to do.

And she was right, although Haley was very tempted just to smack Rachel across the face and leave. However, that might cost Haley her marriage, and if she was honest with herself she wanted this bitch to spank her ass and then fuck her like the little lesbian slut she had become.

"Yeah, that's right bitch." Rachel grinned, "We'll teach you your proper place yet."

Despite the very strong urge to say something back what could Haley possibly say? Rachel had her right where she wanted her and all Haley could do was take a calming breath and wait for the butt beating to begin. Unfortunately Rachel was in no hurry to do that, reaching out and grabbing Haley's ass and then squeezing and pinching it like it was a piece of meat. Haley was pretty sure she continued insulting her too, although she did her best to block that part out.

Then came the pain. Not much at first, but the suddenness of the first blow had Haley crying out. She gritted her teeth and dug fingernails into the palm of her hands to try and stop herself from crying out again, or at least minimising her cries of anguish, but it was no use.

Rachel was clearly determined to make her scream, and eventually she succeeded. Haley was proud that she didn't succeed until the spanking really got going. However making the bitch work for it wasn't much of a consolation when she was bent over Rachel's lap with the redhead relentlessly striking her ass like she was a naughty child.

What did make it better was that Haley felt like she deserved this. After all, she had become addicted to lesbian sex after allowing her best female friend to seduce her, pretty much becoming the lezzie slut of three women. The whole time she was still in love with Nathan, but as much as she loved her husband she just couldn't stop fucking other women.

Therefore, every time one of her lesbian lovers bent her over their knee, she thought maybe she deserved this. Maybe she deserved every blow she was getting, the pain of the spanking therapeutic, especially when Rachel spanked her as unlike the two women she was actually friends with the redhead didn't hold back.

Rachel enjoyed teasing Haley at first, but she definitely had the most fun brutalising Haley's butt, a huge grin on her face the entire time she watched that pale flesh slowly but surely turned red under the assault. And by the time she was even considering stopping it was bruised and a dark, angry red, Haley literally weeping pathetically without a hint of her former pride.

Honestly Rachel couldn't get enough of it, enjoying the hell out of watching the high and mighty, and supposedly innocent, little teenage wife reduced to tears thanks to her methodical strikes.

The only downside was Rachel was concerned at the looks she was getting from Brooke, and even then she wasn't sure why she cared about them. Or why she somewhat showed Haley some mercy after she first caught a glance of them.

Although it wasn't much, Rachel simply massaging Haley's butt in between spanks, and while this caressed away some of the physical pain she clearly continued to make Haley suffer as she whimpered with humiliation as Rachel went back and forth between treating her ass like a piece of meat and a punching bag.

All of this made Rachel embarrassingly horny, and that, more than the looks she was getting from Brooke, caused her to push Haley roughly off of her lap and then stand up, quickly tear off her clothes and order Brooke, "Eat me!"

Grinning happily Brooke quickly stepped forward, dropped to her knees in front of Rachel and buried her face in her pussy. Rachel then closed her eyes and let out a long moan as her friend began licking her pussy with rapid and eager swipes of her tongue, the redhead just enjoying the sensation for a few long minutes. After all, she was wet and ready for it, so why shouldn't she enjoy it?

What did she have to worry about at this stage? Oh, right... Haley, Rachel opening her eyes and smirking down at her rival as she brought her hand up to the top of Brooke's head, tangled her fingers in her pretty brown hair and pulled her into her cunt.

The redhead then began taunting both of the brunettes, "Oh yeah Brooke, eat me. Eat my pussy you nasty little dyke! Fucking eat me out! Ohhhhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhh, lick my pussy just like your slutty little tutor bitch! Mmmmmmmmm, I bet you wish this was you, don't you Hales? Mmmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhh, I bet you wish this was your face buried in my pussy, licking my fucking cunt like the little rug muncher you are! Ooooooooooooh yessssssssssss, you wanna lick me, I can tell, ooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhh, and you're in luck, because I have another hole you can lick! Oh yeah bitch, I want you to lick my ass while your best buddy licks my pussy! Come on, don't be shy. Get behind me and become my little ass kisser! Oooooooooohhhhhhhhh yeahhhhhhhhh, I want Haley James Scott to become my ass kisser."

While Haley looked appropriately appalled by this order, but to Rachel's surprise she slowly crawled behind her without too much fuss. Haley even took the hint and started off by pressing her lips to Rachel's ass cheeks, literally becoming her ass kisser in the process, a fact Rachel delighted in taunting the other girl about.

Although truth be told thanks to the combination of those two female mouths working on her most intimate areas it wasn't long before Rachel had little clue what she was babbling on about because she was just so lost in the pleasure that Brooke and Haley were giving her.

Brooke was delighted at the chance of tasting Rachel's pussy again, and would have love to have given a long drawn-out cunt licking. However it quickly became very clear Rachel wasn't interested in slow and gentle, and honestly after the rough treatment she'd already received, and watched Haley receive, Brooke didn't object to returning the favour with the roughest pussy licking she could dish out.

That involved grazing her teeth against Rachel's clit, which bizarrely the other girl seemed to enjoy just as much as Brooke's soft lips and tongue attacking that sensitive area. Then, shortly after Haley kneeled down behind Rachel, the redhead gave Brooke the permission she had been waiting for.

"Ohhhhhhhhhhh yesssssssssssssss, fuck me, mmmmmmmmmm, fuck me you dyke!" Rachel cried out joyfully, "Ooooooooooooh fuck my pussy, fuck my ass, aaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhh fuck, yes fuck, fuck my fucking fuck holes! Mmmmmmmmmm, fuck them with your tongues! Fuck my cunt and my butt with your little dyke tongue! Yeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssssss, get both those tongues inside me and fuck me like a slutty little lezzie whore! Oooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh yeeeeeeeeeeeessssssssssssss, aaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhh Gooooooooooodddddddddd, Brooke! Fuck me Brooke! Oh Haley, oooooooooooooooohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh aaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhhhhh fuckkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk!"

Happily obliging Brooke slowly pushed her tongue as deep as it would go into Rachel's cunt. She then left it there for almost a full minute so she could just enjoyed the feeling of Rachel quivering around her tongue.

Then she began thrusting that soft wet muscle in and out of her friend/rival, making Rachel scream and buck her hips into Brooke's face. Rachel also shoved Brooke's face as deep into her cunt as possible with a firm grip on the back of her hair, which was kind of painful, but also a hell of turn on for Brooke, and it did make sure her tongue went nice and deep, so it was mostly a win-win.

Brooke also liked the fact that Rachel's other hand was pushing Haley's face as deep as it would go into her ass, encouraging her formally prudish friend to eat her other friend's ass out with as much passion as she could muster.

Which was a lot, Brooke just about able to feel Haley's tongue invading Rachel's butt through the thin wall separating the redhead's front and back passages, making it official two cheerleaders were in fact tongue fucking a third at the same time, Brooke kind of wishing they were all wearing their uniforms as that visual would have been incredible. Not that it was bad in it's current form, Brooke wishing Peyton was here so she could take pictures. Or better yet be in Brooke's position so Brooke could get a good look at this wonderful sight.

Then again Brooke wasn't so sure she wanted to give up her current position, especially as she was soon receiving a mouthful of girl cum, most of which she was proud to say she swallowed.

She wasn't so fortunate with the following climaxes, although most of that ended up on her face which gave her a wicked thrill, meaning she enjoyed this almost as much as Rachel. Especially as after Rachel's fourth orgasm Brooke just couldn't resist reaching between her legs and rubbing herself to an orgasm of her own, while of course still doing her best to tongue fuck Rachel through her climaxes.

Rachel was embarrassed how hard and frequently she came. After all, she was supposed to be straight and here she was cumming harder, and a lot more times, then with any guy.

At least this time round she not only had the excuse of fucking the hottest girl in school, but two girls at the same time. Two girls who were clearly total pussy loving dyke sluts who gobbled each other's cunts, and asses, whenever they could. Besides, she was being assaulted from behind, as well as in front, a talented tongue in her pussy and ass at the same time, so what choice did Rachel have but to cum hard and frequently?

Anyone probably would from being given such passionate oral sex while receiving an equally skilful rim job. Or at least that was what Rachel told herself before and after she became completely lost in the ecstasy she was receiving, Rachel coming very close to passing out. The only reasons she didn't was because she was likely to fall and hurt herself.

And more importantly she wanted to strap-on fuck at least one, and ideally both, of these girls. So reluctantly Rachel reached down, grabbed two handfuls of long hair and pulled the two other girls away from her pussy and ass, stepped aside and pushed their faces together.

"Kiss!" Rachel growled, barely getting the word out before Brooke and Haley did just that, "Oh yes, kiss and taste me on your tongues you nasty bitches! Mmmmmmm yeah, taste my cum Haley! Taste it on Brooke's tongue. Taste that cum on her tongue while Brooke tastes my ass on yours. Yesssssssss, that's it Brooke, taste my fucking butt on your precious tutor girl's tongue! Oh fuck, that's so hot."

Even though Rachel continued to provide commentary and kept her hands on the other girl's heads for a little while it was completely unnecessary, something Haley and Brooke proved when Rachel let go of them completely and moved back and yet her fellow cheerleaders kept passionately making out with each other.

They continued doing so as Rachel retrieved the same strap-on she'd previously used to fuck both these girls and slowly strapped it on while keeping her eyes glued to where Brooke and Haley were kissing. God, I feel so straight now, Rachel thought sarcastically. Desperately ignoring that thought Rachel cleared her throat to get the attention of the other girls.