"Hey tutor girl." Brooke said with a knowing smirk which turned Haley's legs to jelly.
"H, hey." Haley stammered with a blush, unable to look Brooke in the eye, partly because she was embarrassed... and partly because Brooke Davis was standing in the doorway of Peyton Sawyer's house completely naked.
There was a few seconds of sound which felt like an eternity to Haley as she waited politely to be invited in, the whole time wishing either the ground would open up and swallow her or Brooke would pull her inside and fuck her brains out. Ideally the latter although Haley would have probably taken the former over just standing there like an idiot.
"You wanna come in?" Brooke finally asked, Haley rushing past her the moment she stood back, allowing Brooke to shut and lock the door behind them. There was another few seconds of silence, during which Brooke happily notice that Haley couldn't keep her eyes off of her, a fact which made Brooke smile, "See something you like tutor girl?"
Haley blushed, her eyes now drifting down to Brooke's feet.
"I'll take that as a yes." Brooke smirked, before pretending to look thoughtful, "But I guess the real question is, what is innocent little tutor girl doing here? Did she come to study? Maybe teach me or Peyton something? Or did tutor girl come to get tutored?"
Before Brooke could continue her teasing Haley looked up at her, and then totally taking Brooke off guard, quickly closed the distance between them and kissed her roughly on the lips.
Brooke was too shocked to react for a few seconds, then she happily kissed back, more happily surprised than shocked a short while later when Haley pushed her tongue into her welcoming mouth.
The kiss lasted for several minutes, and then while she still had her nerve Haley broke it and gasped, "Do whatever you want with me."
"Be careful tutor girl, I might just take you up on that offer." Brooke smirked.
"Please do." Haley said, "I... I can't stop thinking about you. And Peyton. I can't stop thinking about the two of you together. Or the thought of you two fucking me. And I... I want it so bad. Please Brooke, fuck me. I'll do anything."
Brooke was blown away by Haley's confession. She had hoped to seduce her friend into bed, but she hadn't expected to be so successful so quickly. Damn, she was good.
Unable to resist pushing Haley a little Brooke gave her friend a lustful look, leant forward and then whispered in her ear, "Anything?"
"Anything." Haley gasped, already unbelievably turned on just from one kiss and being so close to the other girl.
"So... you're going to be a good little lesbian fuck toy for me and Peyton?" Brooke pushed.
"Yes." Haley said softly, then adding something she'd never imagined herself saying, "I'll... I'll be a good little lesbian fuck toy."
Again Brooke was surprised as she had expected Haley to just blush in response. She was still blushing of course, but the look in Haley's eyes told Brooke that the other girl meant what she just said, which of course just made Brooke want to push her even more.
"Prove it. Strip for me, right here, right now." Brooke ordered.
Finally it looked like Brooke might have gone too far as Haley really looked apprehensive, "Is... is there anyone else here? Other than Peyton I mean... she is here, isn't she?"
"Maybe." Brooke said playfully, however regret it when she saw Haley become even more apprehensive and quickly changed her tune, "And by maybe I mean no. It's just you, and me, and Peyton... who is a little tied up at the moment."
"Oh... ok." Haley said softly, before she slowly removed her clothes, feeling incredibly awkward and un-sexy despite Brooke's lustful looks at her.
Once Haley was naked Brooke wordlessly took her by the hand and guided her into the house, allowing Haley to get a good look at her ass as they walked up the stairs and headed into Peyton's room.
Haley was a little surprised to see that Peyton was literally a little tied up at the moment, her hands and feet restrained by rope which was interned tied to each corner of the bed, the blonde position sideways on the bed so that her naked body was one perfect display as the two brunettes walked in. As her eyes travelled over her friend's beautiful body, particularly resting on her pussy which was easily accessible thanks to the position, Haley suppose she shouldn't have been surprised given what she knew about Brooke Davis and what she had recently learnt about the other brunette's relationship with her BFF.
Turning to that other brunette Haley found something much less surprising, in fact not also, that being there was a huge smile on Brooke's face.
Just then Haley heard Peyton's voice, "You came."
"Y, yes." Haley stammered, stating the obvious.
"And we're glad you did." Brooke said, again pushing things a bit by gently wrapping her arms around Haley's stomach and pressing her body into the other girl. Haley gasped as Brooke's rock hard nipples dug into her back and Brooke's wet pussy pressed against her ass, but offered no resistance. Pushing things a little further still Brooke gave Haley's neck a few gentle kisses, and then lightly nibbled on her earlobe before whispering in her ear, "I hope the light bondage doesn't freak you out. We haven't gone very far with it, like whips or anything, but it's a real turn on to have someone else completely at your mercy."
Haley didn't think you needed to tie someone up to have them completely at your mercy, after all that was exactly the situation she felt she was in with Brooke. She would have said as much if Brooke's soft lips and gently nipping teeth weren't attacking her neck and thus turning her entire body into a big bowl of jelly.
Brooke continued her teasing from while, her eyes occasionally drifting to Peyton who was watching them intently, obviously wishing she could join in but almost just as happy to watch.
It was extremely tempting for Brooke to just have her way with Haley right then and there with Peyton watching.
Brooke was pretty sure both girls would be happy for her to do so, but as much as she wanted to fuck Haley as her girlfriend watched what Brooke really wanted was for all three of them to have some fun. What she really wanted was an all girl threesome, and what Brooke Davis wanted Brooke Davis got.
She had to be subtle about it though, which was why Brooke took baby steps. First she slipped her hands round to play with Haley's breasts, cupping them and tweaking her nipples until they were as hard as Brooke's were. Then she slid a hand down to play with Haley's pussy lips, sliding her fingertips up and down for several moments until Haley whimpered, "Please Brooke... fuck me."
Not wanting to disappoint Brooke shoved two fingers inside Haley's needy cunt, the other brunette crying out joyfully as her pussy was first invaded and then gently fucked by the skilled fingers of another girl.
The whole time her fingers had been working on tutor girl Brooke had been kissing and nipping Haley's neck and earlobe. When she began finger fucking the other girl Brooke began to grind herself against Haley's soft but firm little ass, once again happily surprised when Haley reacted favourably, this time grinding her ass back into Brooke's pussy which only encouraged Brooke to fuck Haley harder.
When Brooke sense that Haley was getting close she finally whispered in her ear, "You know, if the bondage bothers you, we can untie her... but I was having a lot of fun teasing her before you arrived. I was just about to give her what she wanted too. Maybe you could watch. Or... maybe you could give her what she wants."
Haley bit her lip. Even though she couldn't have imagined it a week ago she wanted too. She... she wanted to give Peyton what she wanted... to lick Peyton's pussy, but first she needed something.
"O... ok, just, just make me cum first. Ok?" Haley whimpered.
"Hm... I don't know. I really love fucking you, and I loved making you cum before, but how do I know you won't run out the door the moment I let you cum?" Brooke question.
"I won't. I promise. I... I'll, I'll lick Peyton's pussy. I'll lick your pussy. I'll do whatever you want, just please make me cum." Haley begged.
