Top Shelf Earps

Disclaimer: I do not own Wynonna Earp. I do not make any money from the writing of this story.

*

Nicole Haught took her job very seriously. Really, she had, before coming to Purgatory. Unfortunately, now she found herself reduced to sitting around and staring at her phone, like so many of her co-workers she had deemed lazy and unmotivated when she first arrived in town. Co-workers like the infamous Wynonna Earp, who was like the worst bad influence ever.

Nicole never, ever thought she would follow in that woman's foot steps on anything, but she just couldn't resist staring at her phone all day when she was consistently sent mouth-watering pictures of Wynonna Earp from the woman herself, and pictures of that top shelf ass of hers.

Today was even worse, as she found herself staring at another top shelf piece of Earp ass. Waverly Earp's ass! Oh God, Wynonna Earp was sending Nicole pictures of her little sister's booty. And yet somehow, it wasn't the weirdest part. No, that would be the promise that when Nicole got 'home', AKA back to the Earps's Homestead, she would actually get to fuck that perfect ass.

Something the twisted bitch was telling her in detail about, and although Nicole tried not to get her hopes up, last time Wynonna had promised her something, it had been the wildest night of her life. But greedily, she wanted more. And given that she was possibly going to get it tonight, it meant every second felt like she had to wait an hour, and when she did finally reach her destination, she had to make sure everything was okay with this.

"You know I think it's about time that we gave you your own key." Wynonna said with an evil smile, when she opened the door that the redhead had been frantically banging on.

"Wynonna, are you sure about this?" Nicole blurted out.

"Although, maybe, it should be to the back door." Wynonna grinned wickedly, continuing her train of thought as if Nicole hadn't said anything, "Mmmmmmmm yeahhhhhh, more appropriate that way, don't ya think? Given ya love going through my back door? And what us Top Shelf Earps want from you? What Waverly wants from you?"

"Wynonna!" Nicole snapped, glaring at her lover, "I'm serious. This is a big deal, even for you. And I, I don't want to lose you."

"Awww, that's sweet." Wynonna smiled, realizing that she was sounding patronizing, and then quickly adding firmly, "I want this. I mean it. I promise you, it would've never have gone this far if I didn't. Or if I didn't think this could work with you, and it wasn't what Waverly wanted. And believe me, really, really do want it. Mmmmmmmmm, I've been so fucking hot. All day just thinking about it."

"Me too." Nicole admitted softly, then forced herself to quickly add, "And you're sure, Waverly wants this."

"Nicole!" Wynonna groaned.

"I know, I know, but I just want to be sure." Nicole pleaded.

There was a brief pause, then Wynonna grinned wickedly, "Why don't you ask her yourself?"

With that, the older of the two Earp sisters then led Nicole up to the younger one's bedroom, where sweet little Waverly Earp was waiting for them. Oh yes, sweet little Waverly Earp was waiting for them bent over her own bed, with her tiny short shorts and panties down around her knees. Somehow, this was even nastier than if Waverly had been completely naked.

It was obviously Wynonna's idea, but it gave the impression that Waverly Earp had been listening to the conversation, and then quickly exposed herself, as Nicole was coming up to see her. And God, she was blushing so adorably, as she looked back at the other two women while biting her lip, which just made the cop want to ravage her even more.

"There, you see? She really does want it." Wynonna beamed proudly, before gently pushing, "Wiggle that cute little butt, Waves. Mmmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhhhhh, wiggle that booty, and show Officer Hot Stuff just how bad you want her cock in your ass. Almost as much as she wants it, I reckon. Isn't that right, Hot Pants? Huh? You wanna butt fuck my baby sister? Pound that hot little butt hole, like you do mine?

Turn both of the Earp sisters into your personal anal whores, who just can't get enough of your big dick up our asses? Yeah you do. Ohhhhhhhhhhhhh fuck yes, fuck her! Fuck my sister, and make both of us your nasty little anal bitches!"

"Shut up, slut. And go get me a cock." Nicole ordered firmly.

"Yes, Officer Haught." Wynonna replied happily with a grin, practically quivering with excitement as she did.

"And Waverly..." Nicole added in a more soft voice, "You're sure you want this?"

"Yes!" Waverly replied without hesitation, and then begged, "Oh please Nicole, take my ass! Take my virgin ass! I want you to take it. Only you. I want it to be yours, so we can truly be together. You, me, and Wynonna. I'd do anything to make that happen, and after seeing how much Wynonna loves it... I'm sure you'll make me your anal slut too."

More was probably said, but it was at that point Nicole opened her mouth to protest. To point out that Wynonna Earp had been a shameless anal whore long before they met, and just because she was one, didn't mean Waverly would be. That it wasn't something a nice girl like Waverly should even think about. Even if she did have the kind of butt which seemed designed to be fucked. Just like her sister.

Of course, most important of all, if Waverly truly wanted them to be together, she didn't have to pass a test, as far as Nicole was concerned. No, the only caveat was that Wynonna wanted it too, and as that seemed to be the case, they were in the clear. So with a deep and calming breath, she accepted this was going to happen, and took the first step.

"Wynonna, get me a cock, so I can take your sister's anal cherry." Nicole ordered hoarsely.

"Ooooooooooh, I thought you'd never ask." Wynonna grinned, happily doing as she was told.

"And make sure it's the 6 incher." Nicole quickly added.

"Seriously?" Wynonna whined, quickly adding while softening her tone, "How about the 8 incher? Still small, in my book. But Waverly will really feel that one. Please? Ya want Waverly to cum nice and hard, right? Besides, she's my sister. No way is a 6 inch strap-on is going to cut it. I mean, just look at that perfect ass? It was made to take big dicks."

"I don't know..." Nicole bit her lip, before realizing she was asking the wrong person, "What do you think, Waverly?"

"What, whatever Wynonna thinks." Waverly said softly, "I trust her."

"That was your first mistake, sis." Wynonna teased, before protesting when she got an unimpressed look from Nicole, "What? I'm clearly joking. Mmmmmmm, so the 8 incher, it is. AKA, the one which is been in my ass last time. I still think you should use the 10 incher, as that's what you used on me our first time together. And wouldn't that just be sooooooooo romantic?

But, as my butt was already broken in, I guess we can go with 8 inches. Mmmmmmmm, but don't be surprised if Waverly ends up begging for more. Just like me, when you punish me by giving my cock hungry booty only 8 inches. Oooooooooh yessssssss, you'll see. You'll all see. Waverly Earp was born to be an anal slut, just like her big sister."

"Wynonna, shut the fuck up, and bring me that cock!" Nicole snapped with frustration.

"Ohhhhhhhhh, yes, Mistress Haught, anything for my top." Wynonna grinned wickedly, "You know how much I love it when you're bossy."

Wynonna finally closed the distance between herself and the drawer of sex toys, briefly glancing back and expecting to see an adorably annoyed look on her top's face. However, her top was instead looking at another bottom's bottom. Oh yes, Officer Nicole Haught couldn't keep her eyes off Waverly Earp's perfect little booty. Not that Wynonna could blame her. Hell, she was kind of tempted to fuck it herself.

Of course, she would never take that privilege away from Officer Haught. Or her sister, for that matter. Not when she knew just what a butt busting stud Nicole Haught was. And just how well she would take care of Waverly's perfect little ass. So she grabbed that strap-on, returned to Officer Haught, and then looked at the Officer expectantly.

Predictably, it took quite a while for Nicole to even notice, and then realized what was being expected of her. When realization hit, she blushed, but quickly obliged, taking off her clothes, and giving Wynonna something else pretty to look at. Yes, the tomboy didn't make a show of it, sadly. But she was still revealing a rocking body to Wynonna, who very much appreciated it.

Then The Heir dropped to her knees, and attached the strap-on dildo around the waist of her beloved Officer Haught. Something she hadn't been ordered to do, making it clear the redhead considered stopping her, but instead, she simply watched the older of the two brunettes work while biting her lip.

When it was properly equipped, Wynonna took the dildo into her hand, and asked, "Do ya mind if I give it a sucking first, Officer Haught? She's my sister, so it feels like the least I could do. Mmmmmmmm, and this way, it can be my saliva slidin' into her shitter, meaning it's kind of like you and me are taking Waverly's butt cherry together."

"Wynonna!" Nicole whined, before just sighing, "You Earps seriously need a lesson on boundaries."

This in turn, had Wynonna chuckling wickedly, as she took that dildo into her mouth, and started sucking on it. Despite the fact that it was unfortunately a clean cock, Wynonna took her time bobbing her head up and down it, doing her best to put on a good show for her top. Of course, the entire time, she was wondering if she would get a chance to suck it later. When it would be flavoured in her baby sister's butt cream.

Which seemed only fair, given that Waverly had tasted Wynonna's ass on Officer Haught's dick. Hell, Wynonna imagine she was tasting her little sister's ass right now, which in turn, actually made the blow job that much more enthusiastic.

Another thing which made it that way was the fact that she was very aware of eyes on her. Mainly Officer Haught, who was giving Wynonna her full attention for the first time tonight. Even when she first went in the door, she had been distracted by thoughts of Waverly. As Waverly, Wynonna could tell that her sister was watching this, probably with a blush on her face. But she couldn't look away.

Perhaps even, that she wanted to be sucking that dick, but at the same time, was enjoying the fact that it was Wynonna doing this for her. Which would be good in the long run, given that Wynonna was a far more experienced cock sucker than her little sister. Something she proved, by effortlessly deep throating the full length of that strap-on, and even fucked her own throat for a few long minutes, before pushing things along.

"That should be wet enough, don't you think, Officer Haught?" Wynonna questioned breathlessly, and with another big smile on her face, "Or do you want me to suck your cock some more?"

"Erm, tha, that will do." Nicole stammered.

"Good. Now, go butt fuck my sister." Wynonna ordered cheekily.

"And remember, that's a virgin ass you're dealing with, unlike my whore butt. So make sure you rim it first." Wynonna pushed, "Ooooooooooh yeahhhhhhhhh, lick my baby sister's butt hole, and get it nice and ready for your strap-on cock. Ohhhhhhhhhh yessssssssss, eat that pretty little ass hole. I know you want to. But if you can't, that's okay. I can do it for you."

Nicole ignored this latest indecent proposal from Wynonna to refocus on Waverly's perfect little bottom, something she found herself staring at for a few long seconds, before kneeling down behind the other girl, and pressing her lips against an ass cheek in a slow and gentle kiss. Which wasn't much of a top thing to do, but in that moment, she just couldn't help it. Waverly's butt was just so beautiful.

It deserved this kind of treatment, especially considering what Nicole was planning on doing to it tonight. Hell, she gave the other cheek a peck, before using both her hands to spread those globes, and get a good look at those sweet little fuck holes, before she leaned down and finally began to lick one of them.

As a proud lesbian, Nicole knew that she should really eat Waverly's pussy first. Not allow herself or Waverly to be bullied into such an unspeakable act. But Wynonna Earp was very, very persuasive. And this ass was just so perfect and fuck-able, that for better or for worse, Nicole just couldn't resist it's charms. Hell, somehow this bubble butt tasted better than some of the pussies she had sampled.

Yes, she could count on one hand how many that was. But it was still impressive. In fact, the only thing which was equally good, was Wynonna Earp's ass. Obviously, she was biased, but it was a little worrying, as the police officer was sure she would do anything for a taste of these booties.

Something she was sure that Wynonna would take advantage of, and maybe even Waverly too. That all that talk of Officer Haught being the top would be meaningless if Wynonna Earp continued to be such a power bottom. Especially given how easy it was for Nicole to once again become lost in eating Earp girl booty. One so wonderfully similar to the one she normally dealt with, and yet, different.

Especially when it came to actually trying to tongue fuck it. Because Wynonna's whore holes easily open for a tongue. Yes, even Wynonna's back door. But not Waverly's holes. No, Nicole could barely get any of her tongue into that tight little virgin ass, which was a reminder to be slow and gentle with this piece of art.

Happily taking that as an excuse, Nicole continued licking that incredibly private hole for what felt like hours, while continuously ignoring Wynonna's not-so-subtle encouragement to move on. If Waverly had asked, that would be a different story. Especially if she asked for this to stop, and they could forget about it. Something which Nicole was half expecting, but also, hoping it wouldn't happen.

Because she needed to fuck this ass, and not just with her tongue. Which was why she eventually replaced her tongue with a finger, sucking on it for a few long seconds, before pushing it inside Waverly Earp's tight little ass hole, with predictable results. Namely, the two women physically involved in it crying out joyfully, which in turn, really amused the bitch watching them.

"Yesssssssss, that's it, Officer Haught! Get your finger in that virgin booty!" Wynonna eagerly encouraged, leaning her head down so she was inches away from the action, "Get it deep! Show my sister what her ass is really for. Oooooooooh, it's tight, isn't it? Yeah, I bet it is. And I bet you love it, especially after having to deal with my loose and sloppy fuck hole of an ass hole.

Mmmmmmm yeahhhhhhhhh, Officer Haught deserves a nice virgin butt hole, after doing my slutty little shit hole a favour by using it for it's true purpose. Ohhhhhhhhh, fuck yeah, finger that hole. Get my sister nice and ready to please a top with her back door. For the first of many, many times."

"Waverly, are you ready?" Nicole asked softly, completely ignoring Wynonna.

"Yes." Waverly squeaked nervously.

"Are you sure?" Nicole pushed gently, "Because you don't sound sure."

"I'm sure." Waverly said softly, then firmly added, "Please, Officer Haught, fuck my ass."

"You heard her, Officer." Wynonna grinned wickedly, "Fuck her! Fuck my little sister in the ass. Come on, mmmmmmm, I know you want to. This perfect booty is just begging to be fucked. And I know what an amazing butt fucker you are, so let me spread Waverly's butt cheeks for you. Oh yeah, that'll help. Show you just how bad I want you to butt fuck my baby sis. See?"

"Wynonna..." Nicole began to protest, as Wynonna very slowly spread Waverly's ass cheeks, before giving into temptation, "Whatever."

Waverly then gasped and blushed when, after a long pause, Officer Haught pulled her fingers out of that tight hole, and replaced them with her cock. Thankfully, this was done nice and slowly, Waverly only feeling a little pressure on her butt hole at first, so small it wasn't enough to do anything, except give her a taste of what was about to happen.

Then when her ass hole started stretching for an invading object for the very first time, it was weird, but it didn't hurt. Not really. Not compared to how she feared it might. In fact, if she was honest with herself, there was a thrill to surrendering her most private hole to Officer Nicole Haught. Which was exactly why she was doing this.

If she was being really, really honest, Waverly would admit that having Wynonna there helped. Because even though her big sister was a hot mess of a woman most of the time, she'd always been Waverly's protector. The only person in life who had always been there for her. Also, she could practically taste the happy look on Wynonna's face, as she watched her baby sister's butt hole stretching for a strap-on.

Which again, really weird, but somehow, it made things better. Which continued to be the case, even as Wynonna silent encouragement them throughout, by stroking her ass cheeks. Then, shortly after that forbidden hole stretch wide enough to allow the head of the dildo to slide through it, Wynonna Earp gave some very loud encouragement.

"You did it, Nicole! You just took my sister's cherry!" Wynonna announced loudly, and way more happily than she should, "Ooooooooooh yessssssssss, you just popped my kid sister's butt cherry! It's yours now, and always will be. Two Earp asses, the property of Officer Nicole Haught! Or at least, they will be, when you get every inch of your big dick in that perfect booty.

Come on, baby, mmmmmmm, I love watching Waverly's shit hole stretching around your strap. But you know what would be even better? Waverly's shit-pipe full of cock! Yeahhhhhhhh, teach my sister what her perfect ass is really for. Stuff her perfect little butt, and make her your anal whore. Just like her big sister. Ohhhhhhhhhhhh fuck yes, fuck her. Fuck her and make her your ass slut."

These words sounded deafening in the otherwise silent room, and honestly, Waverly was surprised Nicole didn't scold Wynonna for it. Then again, Nicole could hardly be blamed for being too overwhelmed to speak, especially given that Waverly was in the same boat. Admittedly, Waverly also had to deal with the pain of the anal penetration. Now that was about as bad as she feared.

Well, the fact that both of her favourite women were involved made the situation as bearable as possible, especially considering that Officer Haught waited several minutes to push forwards, and thus giving Waverly plenty of time to relax and get used to this sensation. Of course, there was only so much that she would ever get used to it, or could relax, but she did her best.

Despite the consistent pain and discomfort, Waverly found herself loving every moment of this. Of being bent over with her ass hole stretching for a cock. One strapped around the waist of another woman. Something which was a taboo on top of a taboo. With another taboo, of having her big sister there with her, encouraging this every step of the way.

In fact, when Nicole finally started pushing forwards, Waverly actually found herself letting out a gasp and then moan of mostly pleasure. It would be a while before the pain faded entirely, but even at its worse, it felt so very right. Even natural, in a weird way. And she just hoped that the other women enjoyed this half as much, especially the cop.

Nicole was in heaven. She loved sodomizing women, and as much as she adored anal sluts like Wynonna, there would always be something extra special about taking another girl's back door cherry. And from the very first moment they met, she felt an intense connection with Waverly Earp. In fact, with both Earp sisters.

So, it was really intense to be able to take Waverly Earp's butt cherry, especially with that butt whore Wynonna Earp right there watching it, going so far as to spread her sister's ass cheeks, providing the perfect view of Nicole's dick disappearing into that perfect little fuck hole. Which in a way, was almost like the big sister was giving her little sister's forbidden hole to the redhead, as a gift.